Enough time has passed; can we now admit that Gaga needs to go back to RedOne?

[Lagerfeld]

 

 

 

He is the only one who understood the essence of DARK POP.

 

[CherryBay]

She is capable of making a good music but for some reason she is avoiding doing it. Why not to go back to the same people she already worked with ? Baffles me

[Distantconstellation]

None of what u put is what made her gaga. She needs to go back to Just Dance, pokerface, lovegame, paparazzi gaga. 

[Kayseri Mantisi]

those hits were hits because of GaGa, not because of some washed up fad producer, let's stop being misogynistic for once. GaGa is still blessing us with bops and if RedOne produced Disease y'all would've found something else to complain about.

[Maleficent]

Even if it was a good enough song, I feel like it wouldn't have the same magic anymore. Plus people would just compare it negatively to their past work together. I feel like it would be similar to how Katy ran back to Luke to try and recreate her past hits, and we got 143.

[Bethenny Frankel]

how many damn times does this tired thread need to be made? please go touch some grass

[Iceland]

No, enough rah rah music 

[mrpartyrocker]

Girl she hasn't even released lg7 yet 

[yonsé]

nobody wants her music to sound like it did 15 years ago.

 

then yall would just be complaining that it's dated. let her cook.

[EnigmaticAndroid]

She's not as desperate as Katy 

Edited 3 hours ago by EnigmaticAndroid

[Slap]

No. This is not a producer issue. Going back to some dated producer won't fix it and will be shakier than the Richter scale can even measure. No more rah rah or show tunes we want something original and fresh. She has the talent. 
 

Honestly Chromatica was on the right track and as long as she can make money touring there shouldn't be this desperation for success on the charts because nobody makes money from it anyway.

Edited 3 hours ago by Slap

[Princess Aurora]

It depends on what song she wanna make

[Bussea]

damn ma can we hear the album first 

[Helix]

realsitically why should she go back to someone who didn't produce a hit since like a decade?

 

Yes it is always nice to reminisce older days but lets be honest they wont ever be able to recreate the spark they had with the fame/the fame monster

 

(I wouldn't complain if they prove me wrong tho)

Edited 3 hours ago by Helix

[Mr. Blue_Shirt]

ATRLers want pop girls to evolve their music so it wouldn't sound dated in modern times, but at the same time they want pop girls to work with the producers from decades ago?!

 

 

 

[lgaga1fan]

Gaga is working with much more talented producers than RedOne and has been for years now. Their work together was lighting in a bottle but its been 10 years. His work with her on Angel Down was very special though. 

[Helix]

also not you including Judas which was one of the biggest bombs for a major popgirl back in 2011. It's definitly not what she needs right  now

 

Of course it stood the test of time and people are finally understanding to appreciate this gem but this process literally took 10 years to happen and back in the day people HATED Judas

[flower moon]

i think they worked well together. he was good at cleaning up/polishing her ideas. i think they should always work together a bit tbh

[LadyDiana]

Her last single sounds like her 2010 reject and that did not work

[massenlight]

I think she needs good taste, cause if she thinks that disease is a well-produced track then thats the problem

[808dream]

I think this will never happen, all one can hope is for some of their scraps on an anniversary re-release (maybe). 

[SharGaga]

Suresh the new album is not even out yet but stay living the in the past.

[Sugar-Rush]

No, when was the last time RedOne produced a hit or even just a good song? I appreciate his contributions to Gaga's earlier career, but it's time to move on imho.

[Acuminatus]

Well if you want a 143 scenario then sure

[Funnyfatty]

Gaga is the one acting like a clown and flopping but its redone that gets dragged 

 

She literally became a totally different woman in order to get herself a hit. I'm shocked at the delusions.