Ariana's singing gets criticized and dragged; goes viral

[commander]

I think she nailed that annoying "theater" tone and intonation perfectly. And coming for Ariana's vocals in general is insane

Edited 7 minutes ago by commander

[MaxMartin]

she sounds like it should be , also , isn't the song like 4mins long with some impressive vocal acrobatics at the end? she will shut their mouths as always. 

[Colmillo]

It's not like a casual movie goer is going to be like "she doesn't sound like someone singing in a musical" anyway, so...

 

[Archetype]

This is why theater people rarely ever find success outside of theater.  Their intonation and tone are grating and annoying outside of the context of a live performance.  No one actually wants to go to the movies and hear someone pronounce every single letter like they're being electrocuted up the ***.  
 

This movie is going to smash and Ariana was the perfect fit for her role.

[Truth Teller]

"Real Broadway actresses" do not do well in cinema or any other medium for that matter. They are EXTRA and look cringey and un-natural. All their techniques, in vocalization and animated expression, are strictly suited for the stage. They cast Ariana for a more modern, understated approach that kids and people who aren't flamboyant theatre geeks will be able to stomach. If they wanted Kristine Chenoweth, I'm sure she was available

[tost1]

18 minutes ago, Katamari said:

what a weirdo  

 

is this what an OAR does? i cant believe i used to do that

 

oh princess ari

 

 

 

OAR?

[Katamari]

1 minute ago, tost1 said:

OAR?

idk what that is that you wrote 

 

 I said OAH

 

 

 

 

 

[Truth Teller]

37 minutes ago, commander said:

I think she nailed that annoying "theater" tone and intonation perfectly. And coming for Adriana's vocals in general is insane

She really did. This is the absolute worst she's ever sounded.

 

A method actress, I fear

 

[rac7d]

22 minutes ago, MaxMartin said:

she sounds like it should be , also , isn't the song like 4mins long with some impressive vocal acrobatics at the end? she will shut their mouths as always. 

Their looking for somthing to criticize and failing 

also none are qualified to critique singing at this level anyway. 
 

she gonna get Oscar nominated and they need to cope 

[CBC]

it cant be a bigger bomb than JFAD so who cares

 

[OrgVisual]

Imagine coming for Ariana's singing   

[Pud]

This is so dumb.
 

She ISNT performing on a broadway stage. She's singing in a film…

[Badgalbriel]

I hate theatre kids. Totally insufferable 

[Thuggin]

This isn't the final take btw. The number in the movie is live.

 

Also, first the complaints were "She sounds too much like Chenoweth, she's just doing an impression and didn't make it her own" and now it's "She doesn't sound like she's singing theater at all" like okay. I'm all for constructive criticism but I feel like most of these people were never going to be happy from the minute the casting was announced

[sha-nasty]

1 hour ago, commander said:

I think she nailed that annoying "theater" tone and intonation perfectly. And coming for Adriana's vocals in general is insane

LITERALLY! I hate that style of broadway singing & the clip triggered me so I'd be inclined to say she nailed it. Still will check out the movie w/ my girlfriends regardless

[stoopidjenna]

I think she sounds good but something about the sound mixing sounds off… hopefully it's just the audio quality for this clip

[Matchatea]

2 hours ago, Gelato said:

idk she sounds good to me

 

i'd focus any criticisms on genuine issues like the colour grading, lighting and camera work. the set is so beautiful and to see it look so washed out in the clips so far is sad 

And makeup!!! I'm sorry but they did my good sis DIRTY in some of the scenes… 

 

2 hours ago, Katamari said:

what a weirdo  

 

is this what an OAH does? i cant believe i used to do that

 

oh princess ari

 

 

 

Happy you saw the light!!  

[Matchatea]

1 hour ago, tost1 said:

OAR?

***OG Ariana Radical 

[Jude]

Invalid opinion. Those are the people who have been praying for the Wicked downfall because their irrelevant faves were not casted. Those people are really annoying and I can't wait for this movie to prove them all wrong and eat dust.

Edited 21 minutes ago by Jude

[BrokenMachine]

2 hours ago, Archetype said:

This is why theater people rarely ever find success outside of theater.  Their intonation and tone are grating and annoying outside of the context of a live performance.  No one actually wants to go to the movies and hear someone pronounce every single letter like they're being electrocuted up the ***.  

Yeah, all of this. While being live in a theater they need to sing in that style, but that doesn't mean it'll work in other forms of entertainment

[toast]

Chile...anyways, so who's already bought their advance tickets?