Is Gaga seen as a success poison?

[ChandlerBing]

 

This is heartbreaking, she is such a hardworker and she does not deserve this.

[Heldenzeit]

Yes, we really need to get annemarie82 and bp4girl back on track, somebody talk to them! 

[halcyonday]

Not the GP smacking her like that on insta 

Edited 2 hours ago by halcyonday

[Digitalism]

But isn't she  feature/supporting elixir?

Edited 2 hours ago by Digitalism

[blondeskinnyrich]

whatever, they were saying she should be in s2 when Bloody Mary was trending and now suddenly they think she's gonna ruin it...

who cares what annemarie82 has to say

[Eternal220]

well her fans hail her as the entertainment industry and she flopped across both film and music this year. she's aiming to complete the trifecta by flopping on TV too. 

[Femininomenon]

JFAD did a lot of damage to her image 

[BabyBenzz]

success-poison only if she's the lead, when she's featured she can be successful depending on the person she latches onto.

[Ethereaaal]

A success poison would not have the most successful song in 2024.

 

I know a true success and acclaim poison though, and her weird fans are already infesting this thread 

 

Cute!

Edited 2 hours ago by Ethereaaal

[BGKC]

The comment sections on social media regarding any of the more polarizing MPGs is always going to be a full on hate train. She wasn't to blame for the joker. It's obviously her own fault for agreeing to do it, but that's the extent of that. A musical feat on Wednesday isn't exactly destined to ruin the show the way turning the joker into a musical was destined to fail. 

[Radical Pessimism]

Not you feeling sorry for a multimillionaire 

[Abracadabra]

Because of 5 Karen's on Instagram?

[Ethereaaal]

8 minutes ago, Charmed Life said:

Yes, let's all ignore LG's colossal damage to a movie franchise, and the millions that's abandoned her latest solo music is droves.

 

Oh yes! Lets all blame it on Gaga, one of the few positive things per critic consensus!
 

Smart and so feminist of you! 

Edited 2 hours ago by Ethereaaal

[Robyn.]

She's not success poison necessarily, but she's a hit or miss, and it has been the case for nearly a decade now.

 

She's no Taylor or Beyoncé where you're sure whatever they drop will draw massive attention, it's really all about luck with Gaga. 

[Ethereaaal]

2 minutes ago, Charmed Life said:

Well why wouldn't we?  She's partly to blame for being cast in a musical no one wanted, and that's what turned a lot of the original audience off.

 

Cry all you like, but it's true.

Yes, let's not blame Toad at all like you said. I agree, girl!

Are we supposed to cry? 

Edited 2 hours ago by Ethereaaal

[burninredhot]

I'm actually shocked. I checked instagram and there's not one positive comment on that post 

[istan4badgalriri]

19 minutes ago, Ethereaaal said:

A success poison would not have the most successful song in 2024.

 

I know a true success and acclaim poison though, and her weird fans are already infesting this thread 

 

Cute!

nobody said Bruno Mars was a success poison 

[Keeandga]

No she's somewhere in the middle. 

[Prodigal Self]

15 minutes ago, Charmed Life said:

Yes, let's all ignore LG's colossal damage to a movie franchise, and the millions that's abandoned her latest solo music is droves.

 

I understand that your fave Madonna ruining like 20 movies with her terrible ass acting and her bankrupting multiple movie studios makes you an expert on the topic but still don't get carried away too much 

[Ethereaaal]

1 minute ago, Charmed Life said:

Sounds like it.

 

and Todd was responsible for the first being a massive hit. What's not clicking?

What's not clicking girl? Did I not say I agree? Toad is a genius! That filmography is so glorious right?

 

xoxo, Joanne 

[TeemoR]

Yes, DWAS would be doing at least 25 M daily streams if it was a solo Bruno song. 

[Infernal Paradise]

Doesn't she currently have one of the biggest, Grammy-nominated songs of the year under her belt? That alone would be enough to disqualify her from this claim.

 

I can however think of one artist in particular that is SUCCESS, ACCLAIM AND ACCOLADE trifecta poison, though. For TEN years and counting, no less. And that happens to be YOUR fave, @ChandlerBing . Congrats on the decade-long bombing on ALL fronts, which is difficult to get, not everyone has that!

 

- Birthday: 17
- This Is How We Do: 24
- Rise: 11-43
- Chained to the Rhythm (feat. Skip Marley): 4-8-12
- Bon Appétit (feat. Migos): 59
- Swish Swish (feat. Nicki Minaj): 46
- Save as Draft: OUT
- Hey Hey Hey: OUT
- Cozy Little Christmas: 53
- 365 (with Zedd): 86-OUT
- Con Calma (Remix) [with Daddy Yankee & Snow]: 22
- Never Really Over: 15-28
- Small Talk: 81-OUT
- Harleys in Hawaii: OUT
- Never Worn White: OUT
- Daisies: 40-79
- Smile: OUT-OUT
- Not the End of the World: OUT-OUT
- Electric (from "Pokémon 25: The Album"): OUT-OUT-OUT
- When I'm Gone (with Alesso): OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-97-OUT-90-91-100-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT

- Where We Started (with Thomas Rett): OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT

- Woman World: 63-OUT

- Lifetimes: OUT-OUT

- I'm His, He's Mine (ft. Doechii): OUT-OUT

 

 

 

 

[TeemoR]

2 minutes ago, istan4badgalriri said:

nobody said Bruno Mars was a success poison 

So do you think Gaga is bringing down the song's success since she is success poison?

[Ethereaaal]

Just now, Infernal Paradise said:

Doesn't she currently have one of the biggest, Grammy-nominated songs of the year under her belt? That alone would be enough to disqualify her from this claim.

 

I can however think of one artist in particular that is SUCCESS, ACCLAIM AND ACCOLADE trifecta poison, though. For TEN years and counting, no less. And that happens to be YOUR fave, @ChandlerBing . Congrats on the decade-long bombing on ALL fronts, which is difficult to get, not everyone has that!

 

- Birthday: 17
- This Is How We Do: 24
- Rise: 11-43
- Chained to the Rhythm (feat. Skip Marley): 4-8-12
- Bon Appétit (feat. Migos): 59
- Swish Swish (feat. Nicki Minaj): 46
- Save as Draft: OUT
- Hey Hey Hey: OUT
- Cozy Little Christmas: 53
- 365 (with Zedd): 86-OUT
- Con Calma (Remix) [with Daddy Yankee & Snow]: 22
- Never Really Over: 15-28
- Small Talk: 81-OUT
- Harleys in Hawaii: OUT
- Never Worn White: OUT
- Daisies: 40-79
- Smile: OUT-OUT
- Not the End of the World: OUT-OUT
- Electric (from "Pokémon 25: The Album"): OUT-OUT-OUT
- When I'm Gone (with Alesso): OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-97-OUT-90-91-100-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT

- Where We Started (with Thomas Rett): OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT

- Woman World: 63-OUT

- Lifetimes: OUT-OUT

- I'm His, He's Mine (ft. Doechii): OUT-OUT

 

 

 

 

Reporting you sis for violence! 
 

Spoiler

Facts 

 

[Robyn.]

1 minute ago, Infernal Paradise said:

Doesn't she currently have one of the biggest, Grammy-nominated songs of the year under her belt? That alone would be enough to disqualify her from this claim.

 

I can however think of one artist in particular that is SUCCESS, ACCLAIM AND ACCOLADE trifecta poison, though. For TEN years and counting, no less. And that happens to be YOUR fave, @ChandlerBing . Congrats on the decade-long bombing on ALL fronts, which is difficult to get, not everyone has that!

 

- Birthday: 17
- This Is How We Do: 24
- Rise: 11-43
- Chained to the Rhythm (feat. Skip Marley): 4-8-12
- Bon Appétit (feat. Migos): 59
- Swish Swish (feat. Nicki Minaj): 46
- Save as Draft: OUT
- Hey Hey Hey: OUT
- Cozy Little Christmas: 53
- 365 (with Zedd): 86-OUT
- Con Calma (Remix) [with Daddy Yankee & Snow]: 22
- Never Really Over: 15-28
- Small Talk: 81-OUT
- Harleys in Hawaii: OUT
- Never Worn White: OUT
- Daisies: 40-79
- Smile: OUT-OUT
- Not the End of the World: OUT-OUT
- Electric (from "Pokémon 25: The Album"): OUT-OUT-OUT
- When I'm Gone (with Alesso): OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-97-OUT-90-91-100-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT

- Where We Started (with Thomas Rett): OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT

- Woman World: 63-OUT

- Lifetimes: OUT-OUT

- I'm His, He's Mine (ft. Doechii): OUT-OUT

 

 

 

 

This is such a tired drag, you know why?

 

Because Katy has been deemed a flop for several years, and her own fans don't deny it so I don't know what calling her a flop over and over again is doing here.

Heck, even Katy has acknowledged that her career is not at the same place.

 

However, Gaga is still constantly part of the discussion when talking about the current main girls, and monsters never lose an opportunity to type "TABS" in every thread at any small victory from Gaga.  

We might as well shorten it to "TAB".