Would Disease have been a hit if it was produced by RedOne?

[LanaDelRey]

With Disease GaGa unsuccessfully tried to recreate her past pop glory days in the vein of Judas, Bad Romance, Poker Face; however, it's been rejected by the general public and pop stans alike despite stans begging her to make a return to this type of sound for years.

 

What was missing? Could it have been RedOne's production that was the missing ingredient needed to to truly make this song reach its full potential? 

Edited 2 hours ago by LanaDelRey

[polygon]

No, the song itself is cacophonic

[yonsé]

in 2009 maybe

 

ReDone's productions are dated af

 

besides, the production is the best part of Disease

[shookspeare]

if anything the production is the only thing that's good about it, her problem is the dope vocals and forgettable melody

[HonourableVomit]

tell me when RedOne's last hit was

 

quickly 

[LanaDelRey]

8 minutes ago, shookspeare said:

if anything the production is the only thing that's good about it, her problem is the dope vocals and forgettable melody

I'm sure RedOne would have told GaGa her vocals sound horrendous on the track and made her re-record them. 

Interestingly she only started singing like that after ditching him...

[LanaDelRey]

5 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said:

tell me when RedOne's last hit was

 

quickly 

2011 so the same year as GaGa's last solo hit 

[Assassin]

It's a solo lady Gaga single so no.

[smartalek22]

42 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said:

tell me when RedOne's last hit was

 

2020 when GODVa Max used him on solo 1 billion streams smash hit Kings & Queens

[Solar]

To me, Disease is perfect the way it is

[nhatpb]

this song does not have repeatable value, whoever produce it

[Bumba]

No, but it would have been better. I haven't listened to it since it came out… truly a non-event and everyone forgot it happened while we were all begging for a comeback

[Sannie]

2 hours ago, LanaDelRey said:

With Disease GaGa unsuccessfully tried to recreate her past pop glory days in the vein of Judas, Bad Romance, Poker Face; however, it's been rejected by the general public and pop stans alike despite stans begging her to make a return to this type of sound for years.

 

What was missing? Could it have been RedOne's production that was the missing ingredient needed to to truly make this song reach its full potential? 

 If this were the case, it would've been produced by RedOne.

 

But no, the man who hasn't had a hit in fifteen years wouldn't've guaranteed a hit.