Saddy Posted September 14 Author Posted September 14 46 minutes ago, °ColdFire° said: Do Britney next. Oh I will, unless someone is already planning to do that 1
sparrowblue Posted September 14 Posted September 14 the way One In A Million and the album won in the end 4
sparrowblue Posted September 14 Posted September 14 @Saddy you did great again. next time we need playlisting and payola for Enough Said 3
prézli Posted September 14 Posted September 14 I gave 11 to One in a Million in the previous rate, it went #2, now I gave them to another song and One in a Million wins. 2
°ColdFire° Posted September 14 Posted September 14 30 minutes ago, prézli said: I gave 11 to One in a Million in the previous rate, it went #2, now I gave them to another song and One in a Million wins. You've done enough damage during this rate 1 2
LesFleur Posted September 14 Posted September 14 On 9/13/2024 at 5:16 PM, Saddy said: #30 I Can Be Score: 7.71 High score: 10 @ChooseyLover@sparrowblue@LesFleur Low score: 6 @Saddy On 9/13/2024 at 5:16 PM, ChooseyLover said: This is not okay It really is not. I'm a day late and pressed all over again. It's giving me flashbacks to Messed Up not making it this far On 9/13/2024 at 5:22 PM, Saddy said: #28 Never No More Score: 7.82 High score: 10 @sparrowblue@SoldierofLove Low score: 4 @prézli SMH also deserved higher. The combination of her voice and the production on this is top tier. On 9/13/2024 at 5:29 PM, ChooseyLover said: Beautiful beautiful song. Should have been way higher but it's not well known so I guess only hardcore fans have come to appreciate it. Amazing taste @LesFleur I'm glad it made it this far but it's really underrated IMO On 9/13/2024 at 5:25 PM, Saddy said: #27 A Girl Like You ft. Treach Score: 7.84 High score: 10 @°ColdFire° Low score: 6.5 @Homebrand Glad to see one of my favs from this album get a deserving place in the top 30 but it also deserves higher. 1
LesFleur Posted September 14 Posted September 14 On 9/13/2024 at 5:46 PM, Saddy said: #21 Journey to the Past Score: 8.11 High score: 11 @SoldierofLove Low score: 1 @prézli @prézli HOW CAN YOU GIVE THIS A 1? GOORRLLLLLLLLLLLLL I can't believe this is not top 10 2 2
LesFleur Posted September 14 Posted September 14 5 hours ago, Saddy said: #18 The One I Gave My Heart To (1998 Guy Roche Album Version) Score: 8.18 High score: 11 @ChooseyLover@Mariya Takeuchi@LesFleur Low score: 1 @prézli Comments: Sparrowblue: "The superior version of this song. The vocals and production are much much stronger. The rent must've been due! I still don't know why they chose that karaoke version for the album." This didn't even make the top 10. This should be top 5 at a minimum …and another 1 from @prézli 1 1
LesFleur Posted September 14 Posted September 14 5 hours ago, Saddy said: #13 At Your Best (You Are Love) Score: 8.57 High score: 11 @SoldierofLove@Devin@LesFleur Low score: 2 @prézli Comments: Sparrowblue: "The isley brothers said she made it her own song and there's no higher praise than that" This is not top 5? HOW? The ballad version is divine
LesFleur Posted September 14 Posted September 14 5 hours ago, ChooseyLover said: So Miss You is officially Aaliyah's best ballad according to the 12 of us. It's her most overrated I think due to the sentimental value. It's cute but At Your Best (You Are Love), Turn the Page and The One I Gave My Heart To far superior IMO. And none of them made the top 10 2
LesFleur Posted September 14 Posted September 14 5 hours ago, Saddy said: #7 Rock the Boat Score: 9.24 High score: 11 @brokee@LesFleur Low score: 3.5 @prézli Comments: Prézli: "R.I.P. I never liked this song." Sparrowblue: "Aaliyah and static went in the studio with a purpose that night!" @prézli got me looking so crazy right now omg. This song is PURRRRRRFECTION. Effortless, seductive realness. Sexy without being crass or try-hard. They don't do it like this no more
LesFleur Posted September 14 Posted September 14 5 hours ago, ChooseyLover said: The babies crying alone makes this song worse than Rock The Boat but let me keep it CUTE! Sis don't do it. This is an everlasting bop and you will deal
LesFleur Posted September 14 Posted September 14 5 hours ago, Saddy said: #2 If Your Girl Only Knew Score: 9.65 High score: 11 @ChooseyLover@prézli@SoldierofLove@°ColdFire° Low score: 7 @Saddy Comments: Sparrowblue: "She came back with something to prove" #1 One in a Million Score: 10.00 High score: 11 @sparrowblue@Devin@LesFleur Low score: 8 @Saddy Comments: Sparrowblue: "Probably my favorite and her signature song aside from try again. You just can't deny this one." Omfg I'm shook One in a Million won. I didn't see a slow jam winning. I thought More Than a Woman would get it not one of my 11s actually pushing through. @Devin @sparrowblue we did it. . 3
ChooseyLover Posted September 14 Posted September 14 (edited) 8 minutes ago, LesFleur said: Sis don't do it. This is an everlasting bop and you will deal Sure is, I think I rated it either a 9 or a 9.5. But sometimes I don't like certain Timbaland production choices And Rock The Boat is perfect. 16 minutes ago, LesFleur said: It's her most overrated I think due to the sentimental value. It's cute but At Your Best (You Are Love), Turn the Page and The One I Gave My Heart To far superior IMO. And none of them made the top 10 I pay a lot of attention to the lyrical content of songs and I just can't see that song that way tbh. And I don't care about the MV either... I just remember Toni acting funny on it and getting viral on Twitter Definitely I'm still taken aback by Turn the Page's low position. And The One I Gave My Heart To never gets a lot of love either. This rate favored a lot of One in a Million singles but somehow not that one Edited September 14 by ChooseyLover 2
Saddy Posted September 14 Author Posted September 14 37 minutes ago, Devin said: taste won thank u @Saddy for doing this! Thanks for participating
prézli Posted September 14 Posted September 14 @LesFleur Instead of tagging me, come and join Timbaland's 2nd babe rate.
brokee Posted September 16 Posted September 16 I was busy last two days so did not really got time to check so lemme catch up with it all as Ive arrived to the party so late so don't mind me.
brokee Posted September 16 Posted September 16 I'm surprised that one in million really got the last laugh but not mad at its great album
brokee Posted September 16 Posted September 16 I like that last year rating and this year rating is different also if your girl only knew is one of the best ever ahhhhhh 1
brokee Posted September 16 Posted September 16 I find myself listening to one in million more often these days 1
brokee Posted September 16 Posted September 16 Anyway gotta thank for @Saddy for doing another round of Aaliyah rating. Thank you for involving in this and investing your time for this. Hopefully we will see another round next year with more Aaliyah music lovers. 3
brokee Posted September 16 Posted September 16 Also gotta thanks @sparrowblue commenting on songs. I like reading them. 4
brokee Posted September 16 Posted September 16 One last thing seeing prezil voting low my fav songs too I was like no way and then they added comment too and I was that was funny. anyway thanks for everyone who participated even tho I was also one but just happy to see that people are interested in Aaliyah's music hope you know the you got taste in great music. Hope you guys having a nice day. 2
Recommended Posts