rate Aaliyah's Discography Rate | WINNER REVEALED

[Saddy]

Just now, Yog said:

Love this song! Glad it got top 20

it's one of her best songs 

[Saddy]

		#14 I Don't Wanna Score: 8.41
		High score: 11 @ChooseyLover@Mariya Takeuchi@sparrowblue Low score: 4 @prézli   Comments: Sparrowblue: "Is this an underrated r&b gem of r&b history? i think so"

[Saddy]

		#13 At Your Best (You Are Love) Score: 8.57
		High score: 11 @SoldierofLove@Devin@LesFleur Low score: 2 @prézli   Comments: Sparrowblue: "The isley brothers said she made it her own song and there's no higher praise than that"

[Saddy]

		#12 Back & Forth Score: 8.58
		High score: 11 @°ColdFire° Low score: 6 @Yog

Edited September 14 by Saddy

[SoldierofLove]

2 minutes ago, Saddy said:

		#13 At Your Best (You Are Love) Score: 8.57
		Low score: 2 @prézli

@prézli

 

[ChooseyLover]

5 hours ago, Saddy said:

		#16 Loose Rap ft. Static Score: 8.31
		High score: 10 @ChooseyLover@LesFleur Low score: 6 @Yog

Loose Rap was 8th last time... This is food for thought. I'm dead by the lack of taste exhibited

Edited September 14 by ChooseyLover

[Yog]

Just now, Saddy said:

		#12 Back & Forth Score: 9
		High score: 11 @°ColdFire° Low score: 6 @Yog

My sabotaging worked 

[Saddy]

		#11 Extra Smooth Score: 8.60
		High score: 11 @°ColdFire° Low score: 5 @prézli

[Saddy]

Before I start revealing the Top 10, look at this list to see if your fav song is still here alive

4 Page Letter
Are You That Somebody?
I Care 4 U
If Your Girl Only Knew
Miss You
More Than a Woman
One in a Million
Rock the Boat
Try Again
We Need a Resolution ft. Timbaland
 

[ChooseyLover]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

		#11 Extra Smooth Score: 8.60
		High score: 11 @°ColdFire° Low score: 5 @prézli

Extra Smooth is not better than Loose Rap, I Can Be or U Got Nerve but I see this was highly rated last time too (#12).

[Yog]

Just now, Saddy said:

4 Page Letter

Come on thru, my 11!!  

[Yog]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

Before I start revealing the Top 10, look at this list to see if your fav song is still here alive

4 Page Letter
Are You That Somebody?
I Care 4 U
If Your Girl Only Knew
Miss You
More Than a Woman
One in a Million
Rock the Boat
Try Again
We Need a Resolution ft. Timbaland
 

Solid top ten tbh 

[Saddy]

Just now, Yog said:

Solid top ten tbh 

Yeah, love to see it 

[ChooseyLover]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

Before I start revealing the Top 10, look at this list to see if your fav song is still here alive

4 Page Letter
Are You That Somebody?
I Care 4 U
If Your Girl Only Knew
Miss You
More Than a Woman
One in a Million
Rock the Boat
Try Again
We Need a Resolution ft. Timbaland
 

Rooting for If Your Girl Only Knew but I see we'll get a solid top 10 again. Good job everyone

 

[Saddy]

		#10  We Need a Resolution ft. Timbaland Score: 9.04
		High score: 10 @Saddy@Mariya Takeuchi@sparrowblue@SoldierofLove@LesFleur Low score: 6 @prézli   Comments: Sparrowblue: "Definition of too ahead of its time for everybody given the chart performance"

[ChooseyLover]

I Care 4 U and 4 Page Letter didn't make it to the top 10 last time. Loose Rap and Choosey Lover did it instead. Maybe we upgraded the top 10 tbh.

Edited September 14 by ChooseyLover

[SoldierofLove]

3 minutes ago, Saddy said:

Before I start revealing the Top 10, look at this list to see if your fav song is still here alive

4 Page Letter
Are You That Somebody?
I Care 4 U
If Your Girl Only Knew
Miss You
More Than a Woman
One in a Million
Rock the Boat
Try Again
We Need a Resolution ft. Timbaland
 

I rated all of these between 9 and 11. I served taste!

 

[SoldierofLove]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

		#10  We Need a Resolution ft. Timbaland Score: 9.04
		High score: 10 @Saddy@Mariya Takeuchi@sparrowblue@SoldierofLove@LesFleur Low score: 6 @prézli   Comments: Sparrowblue: "Definition of too ahead of its time for everybody given the chart performance"

@prézli is somethin else  

[Yog]

Just now, SoldierofLove said:

@prézli is somethin else  

He's definitely sabotaging the rate worse than me  

[Saddy]

1 minute ago, ChooseyLover said:

I Care 4 U and 4 Page Letter didn't make it to the top 10 last time. Loose Rap and Choosey Lover did it instead. Maybe we upgraded the top 10 tbh.

I'll post the top 10 from the last rate and this rate, so y'all can compare it 

[Saddy]

		#9 I Care 4 U Score: 9.06 High score: 11 @Mariya Takeuchi@sparrowblue@Devin Low score: 6.5
		@prézli   Comments: Sparrowblue: "A perfect ballad. I hate we'll never hear the demo cut of this from the one in a million sessions"

[SoldierofLove]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

		#9 I Care 4 U Score: 9.06 High score: 11 @Mariya Takeuchi@sparrowblue@Devin Low score: 6.5
		@prézli   Comments: Sparrowblue: "A perfect ballad. I hate we'll never hear the demo cut of this from the one in a million sessions"

@prézli strikes again. Sis was so unserious with this rate. It's giving voter fraud. 

[ChooseyLover]

2 minutes ago, Saddy said:

		#9 I Care 4 U Score: 9.06 High score: 11 @Mariya Takeuchi@sparrowblue@Devin Low score: 6.5
		@prézli   Comments: Sparrowblue: "A perfect ballad. I hate we'll never hear the demo cut of this from the one in a million sessions"

So Miss You is officially Aaliyah's best ballad according to the 12 of us.

[ChooseyLover]

1 minute ago, SoldierofLove said:

@prézli strikes again. Sis was so unserious with this rate. It's giving voter fraud. 

The worst part is that I think her 11's are still alive omg. She's the real winner of this rate

[Saddy]

1 minute ago, SoldierofLove said:

@prézli strikes again. Sis was so unserious with this rate. It's giving voter fraud. 

I think we talked more about @prézli than about this rate