rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[Forever Winter]

1 hour ago, frankvert said:

TS: 2.79

Fearless: 2.96

Evermore: 2.06

TTPD: 1.97

[frankvert]

58 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

 

4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Fearless was dragged down by vault tracks. Don't really use TS that much aside from its classics. eversnore and The Worst Album Ever Released were rightfully dragged

 

 

[Technicolor]

I have been listening to Taylor lately so let me do this 

[Forever Winter]

Some of these scores chile 

 

[halcyonday]

18 hours ago, frankvert said:

Just submitted my rankings. Here's the average per album: 

 

TS: 2.79

Fearless: 2.96

Lover: 4.68 

Evermore: 2.06

TTPD: 1.97

 

you ate that tbh

[gagacasanova]

On 8/10/2024 at 2:58 PM, jacklovesyou1 said:

Is the vaults dragging anyone else's scores down lol i like a few of them .. but overall yikes

Half the vault tracks on Fearless are bangers, the other half... mids. Same with Speak Now & Red (which has at least one that is super forgettable).

 

1989 has the superior vault tracks imo.

 

[frankvert]

5 minutes ago, gagacasanova said:

Half the vault tracks on Fearless are bangers, the other half... mids. Same with Speak Now & Red (which has at least one that is super forgettable).

 

1989 has the superior vault tracks imo.

 

Vault tracks dragged down all of my scores for each album with TVs. The only vault track that got a 10 from me is on Red. You wanna guess? 
 

[jacklovesyou1]

@Forever Winter any hints about certain song rankings so far .. without making it obvious lol.. obviously the positions will naturally change by the 31st

[Forever Winter]

15 minutes ago, jacklovesyou1 said:

@Forever Winter any hints about certain song rankings so far .. without making it obvious lol.. obviously the positions will naturally change by the 31st

Let me just say some ballots/scores will be disqualified cause I see some people rating 1 for like 10-15 songs on an album. 

 

That or I might ask them to revise

 

[Forever Winter]

1 minute ago, jacklovesyou1 said:

@Forever Winter any hints about certain song rankings so far .. without making it obvious lol.. obviously the positions will naturally change by the 31st

If you're talking about like actual overall song rankings, I haven't seen the averages yet. But looking over everyone's scores, it's definitely mix of tasteful and not tasteful 

 

[jacklovesyou1]

7 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Let me just say some ballots/scores will be disqualified cause I see some people rating 1 for like 10-15 songs on an album. 

 

Mess if you're gonna do a troll vote at least make it not obvious smh

[jacklovesyou1]

Daily reminder to not waste your 0 on ME! be smart swifties !!!

[gagacasanova]

1 hour ago, frankvert said:

Vault tracks dragged down all of my scores for each album with TVs. The only vault track that got a 10 from me is on Red. You wanna guess? 
 

I didn't give any vault tracks a 10, I did give a few 9's spread out through the TVs. 👀

 

The lowest score I gave on a vault track was a 2 

Edited August 12 by gagacasanova

[Forever Winter]

3 hours ago, gagacasanova said:

I didn't give any vault tracks a 10, I did give a few 9's spread out through the TVs. 👀

 

The lowest score I gave on a vault track was a 2 

Hopefully this was for We Were Happy

 

[Migs30283]

On 8/10/2024 at 6:28 PM, Forever Winter said:

Hi friends.

 

Kind weekly reminder to please submit your ballots. I know some of you are already working on them but including you here anyway:

 

  Reveal hidden contents

@PoisonedIvy @Klein @State of Grace. @Badgalbriel @Heldenzeit @fridayteenage @Dear Reader @wastedpotential @FolkLover1989 @Folklore89sm @Cruel Summer @Goaty @taylor__fan @vale9001 @Kyle-x @Popboi. @Saint James @Gladiator @Feanor @Ms. Togekiss  @Great Username @Lille @LostInStereo100 @Cleanromantic @Michael196 @MardinBeksloy @cruelhprince @RideOrDie @YR. @Buffy @PrismaticOwen @Chris @OnlyManInTheWorld @Taylor fanboy @KatyPrismSpirit @Starchild @By the Water @Raphy23 @19SLAYty9 @Squall @mael @Bosque @Save-Me-Oprah @YellowRibbon @Prismee @AndThenTheCocaine @Timeless @IBeMe @Achilles. @Fama  @G.U.Y. Gaga @drivers license  @UnusualBoy @Taylor Sniffs @idkwiam @4Real @DesiredConsternation @Kavish @Bussea @SleepingTigers @byzantium @AbeHicks @RihannaLoverrr @Holy Ground @Taylena @TaylenaStan @TayDuaStan @Hunter_13 @Shendelzare @Lorenzo22 @feelslikeadream @Rev8 @TheArgonaut @Jaay @Fifteen @doonerr @P!NK2LOVE @xfreshkidxx @inshadesofcool @Indie Go Mind @GreatestLoveofAll @creativity. @Ayanaa @JoeAg @Sanguine @Legend E @Quicksand @ChrisTheLoner @Walk_Away21 @wehavetostan @MissedTheTrain @bluebirdsforever @Juánny @woohoo @Bloo @burninredhot @KeshaSwift @Miss Americana @Trent W @ariananext @blown away @Maroonx @Sabrina Carpenter @Strawberry Bubble @Kimi @Safe&Sound @enchanted0 @aesthetic bih @My Tears Ricochet @rebeltwat @LoveInStereo @dussel_06 @Kyungsoowift @diemoehre @Clauss @Flower @?????? @WeFoundWill @makeawish @Yog @Mocha @jacklovesyou1 @halcyonday @Mezik @Edge Of Glory @nostalgic @AdrianNicki @modern thing @holyground13 @yourfaveisaflop  @Sad Beautiful Tragic @Taemira @roso @Alldeezy @djcalpal @Doogle @TMRA @frankvert @Virgos Groove @BlackAura @Britney Jean @TaggedGalaxy @Bad News @olivethetree @taylorrrr @TaylorNation @KOMH @SoulKiwi @skwonderfactory @FlyOnTheWall @Pheromosa @Frogger17 @Carrie-is-no-1 @Rep2000 @Theluckyone @UNNAMI @alestevens @NoOneDiesFromLove @Jude @Miss Fortune@houndsoflove @Life Savers @Danial @Ramona16 @VeniceBeach @sleepevaded @oceans @Gam @romas_ld@MusicLoverDude @kyoshi @PurrKaty @Mellark @Lemon @Starkboy @pavi @BeenTheShit @KnightOfAllRealms @Finkypop @Lightbringer007 @Maroon legacy @chiliam @Sailor Moon @LovaticSwiftie @Hitchhiker @Sweeftie13 @siegetheday @dreamofyou @Saintlor @HappierJealousy @greeneyedsoul @queenoftheclouds @Nico Robin @Bonicap @Mandalore @cruelcooper @cat1867 @BabyBenzz @touch @2NE1 @Underdogs @Better Mistakes @Monster Queen @Arcade ring @Nashe @TaylorFantasy @Illuminati @youreyesgocold @Wonderland @Ruben @Dragonfly @xXavril @PerfectSacrifice @Jai @danielins @mypaintoyou @Trainwreck @swiftawaywithme @Fastlane @Aiya @Ken Lee @naval23 @Isaiah @EtherealCat @Rider @Miles. @evtimow @chaeyonce @Terylee @Bindi @sparrowblue @Nein @All Too Well @jacobhalkohit @Wolf Alice @eli's_rhythm @BloodLuster @Fitzswiftie @dreampop @Migs30283 @aotearoa @Finish Ticket @ALittleGauche @RoyalT @willmcclure9 @blueberries @ChapelHooker @K$Ellie @Jenlisa @Josh @Sazare @Mighty Oaks @foundwonderland @ronelmaano13 @Ithinkforme13 @Everyperfectsummer @Aquamarine @ellis-bell @dwuw @AM98GJ @JosephT @discotitzz @OhMyAlf @taemin @GiftFromGod @GambleBreauxNews @Hephaestus @DatChickDoe @simmnfierzig @wren @Ramona16 @BtDecember @LaFlaca @SwiftLover @JawBreaker @beagle @Lazuli @Donquizote @Sprawl @TayGod @Jaspurr @Meeko @Gorjesspazze9 @fromily @Digitalism @evermore. @Ger.vaz @If U Seek Amy @fememeist @JustHoran @mileytayIor @Diarrhoea @ChatshireCat @sexyback007 @tombiz @diamondsky @venuss @Delusional @keerbyriri @MusicLoverDude @Finny @shookspeare @katyslut @Kristen@Ampersand13 @Matchatea @piotrert @Meev @Mark! @YourFavoriteWeapon @TayRianaPH @BlackoutZone @americanlife @NorbertMinaj @SwiftBoy @Swiffer @Swift_Fenty @Britney Is Fierce @iamanearthling @Flames2Embers @Calvin @Cornelia Street @ttds @Tiziano's Boy @style17 @EndofASadMovie @Mdawg @Da Vinci @scottstreet @ang @TeamThiem @JorgeM @PatrickGray.12 @justin464 @ohjulia @saintjude @Raspberries @vinicius @Everyperfectsummer @RoseBud @Axolotl @Lulento @Venice B @soulsearcher @zuzufruit @Listentoyourheart @Kuntmonster@taylordswift13 @PiperHalliwell @SLUTTVFTV @Technicolor @MerveAksak @Mike95 @twoheadlightshine @Verge of Obscene @Tal_reputation

 

Submitted Ballots (58):

  Reveal hidden contents

1. terrorblade

2. tb6591

3. SlyMacPer

4. PaloSanto

5. greento

6. NordicGuy

7. Forever Winter

8. The Music Industry

9. Solaria

10. pinkbowvintage

11. 1989

12. Peroxide

13. DevilsRollTheDice

14. NEX

15. Live To Tell

16. Teen Spirit

17. sanzo

18. MidnightsAtPeace

19. Avrileon

20. CamiloPg_

21. 4Real

22. KillingYourCareer

23. a_d_22

24. Namigo

25. llikeh

26. 305

27. Arrows

28. skizzo

29. Soobin

30. Tusk

31. Riverbank

32. theluckyone

33. LastKiss

34. itsjem

35. Hurem

36. Life Savers

37. folkloreking

38. gagacasanova

39. Vespertine

40. freakum.

41. chosensparkles

42. reputation1989

43. D-@-N

44. badidearight

45. Velvet Night

46. Enrique523

47. Mr. Duff

48. AshleyLovescats887

49. ChapelHooker

50. Gorjesspazze9

51. halcyonday

52. iamanearthling

53. AbeHicks

54. Axolotl

55. jacobhalkohit

56. PerfectSacrifice

57. Frankvert

58. Venice B

Reminders:

For your ballot to count, it must be submitted via Google Form and comply with the rules in the OP (all 260 songs must be rated, no troll ratings, etc.).

https://forms.gle/bNn6wDEC2wz4mkPc7

The Google Form autosaves your results even if the form is incomplete.

You may go back into the form at any time to edit, even after submission.

Your ballot will not record onto the Excel spreadsheet until you click Submit at the bottom of the form.

Please ping me in this thread to confirm your submission.

 

Deadline: August 31 (3 weeks from today)

 

Please let me know if you don't want to participate or want to be removed from the pinglist.

won't be participating. thanks anyway.

[vinicius]

Loved answering this!

Very proud of my 5 11's.

[Forever Winter]

3 minutes ago, vinicius said:

Loved answering this!

Very proud of my 5 11's.

I see your ballot. Thanks for participating  

[jacklovesyou1]

the temptation to sabotage cruel summer but it's such a bop ugh

[Forever Winter]

1 hour ago, jacklovesyou1 said:

the temptation to sabotage cruel summer but it's such a bop ugh

I've thought about this too  but there are 5 other songs more deserving 

[jacklovesyou1]

27 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

I've thought about this too  but there are 5 other songs more deserving 

Would @foreverwinter13 lie???

 

[wastedpotential]

dddd some of y'all bout to be real mad at me, but I just re-ran my evermore scores and my average score for the album is a 9.8, and I'm not changing it because I've seen some of y'all's scores 

 

And before anyone asks, it's not a troll ballot because I gave one song a 6 

 

edit actually I re-re-ran the math and it got a 9.4, I guess what they say about bags and math is true 

Edited August 13 by wastedpotential

[Forever Winter]

46 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

dddd some of y'all bout to be real mad at me, but I just re-ran my evermore scores and my average score for the album is a 9.8, and I'm not changing it because I've seen some of y'all's scores 

 

And before anyone asks, it's not a troll ballot because I gave one song a 6 

 

edit actually I re-re-ran the math and it got a 9.4, I guess what they say about bags and math is true 

Don't worry, the scores that appear to be sabotaging albums will not count.

 

You can stay true to your real rankings 

[Forever Winter]

Yall have 5 0s you can use for sabotaging, you don't need to do it for entire albums 

 

[wastedpotential]

1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

Don't worry, the scores that appear to be sabotaging albums will not count.

 

You can stay true to your real rankings 

dddddd sister that is my real ranking 

Spoiler

Aside from No Boulder, No Christ, everything else ranks from an 8.7 to an 11 with fourteen songs over 9.0 and six songs at or over 10 

 

[TaylenaStan]

So after initial scoring these are my rankings
 

Spoiler

Reputation - 8.9 (1x11)
Folklore - 8.6
Red (OG + Vault) - 8.3 (2x11)
Red (OG) - 8.25
Speak Now (OG) - 8.2
1989 (OG) - 8.2 (1x11)
Speak Now (OG + Vault) - 8.0
Evermore - 7.9 (1x11, 1x0)
1989 (OG + Vault) - 7.0
Fearless (OG) - 7.0
TTPD (Standard + Anthology) - 6.4 (1x0)
Fearless (OG + Vault) - 6.2
TTPD (Standard) - 6.1
Debut - 6.0
Midnights (Standard + 3am) - 5.9 (2x0)
Lover - 5.3 (1x0)
Midnights (Standard) - 5.1

inch resting some things dont make complete sense in my head, for example evermore being in the middle of the pack but then again the highs are HIGH but i also sabotaged a certain overrated fan fav song that would usually get a 7-7.5 from me but will get a 0 instead 

reputation is in my top 5 but i wouldnt say its her best album but i guess no deluxe + vault tracks to drag the average down + i didnt sabotage any song on there.
Red by far the best vault obviously  But even as a Red stan i cant give a certain track on the standard a high score which sadly (alongside the deluxe) drags the average down

overall i will sit with this rating a bit and adjust the numbers + write comments for a couple tracks and then submit 

Edited August 13 by TaylenaStan