rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[Brooklyn Baby]

4 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

@Forever Winter are you getting a lot of comments with people's ballots? I've scored everything, but I'm not sure how to much write for each comment. If you've only got a few, then I'll leave some essays, but if you have a bunch then I'll just stick to the funnier one-liners 

Only a handful of users have added comments, so I wouldn't limit myself. Go crazy and comment on each song

 

[wastedpotential]

Just now, Forever Winter said:

Only a handful of users have added comments, so I wouldn't limit myself. Go crazy and comment on each song

 

nnnn okay I'll be sending in 150 word paragraphs for each of my general thoughts 

[Europe]

It feels unfair to not be allowed to give every song a 10 on Debut and Fearless

 

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

14 minutes ago, AbeHicks said:

It feels unfair to not be allowed to give every song a 10 on Debut and Fearless

 

 

A Perfectly Good Heart a 10?! 

 

[jacklovesyou1]

Is the vaults dragging anyone else's scores down lol i like a few of them .. but overall yikes

[wastedpotential]

1 hour ago, jacklovesyou1 said:

Is the vaults dragging anyone else's scores down lol i like a few of them .. but overall yikes

The only vault that matched the average of the associated album was Sermons Now 

[Klein]

10 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

The only vault that matched the average of the associated album was Sermons Now 

And the one that really brings the average of the album down is Fearless 

[wastedpotential]

2 minutes ago, Klein said:

And the one that really brings the average of the album down is Fearless 

Yeah, Red/1989 vaults are slightly below average but my Fearless album average is a full point higher without the vault 

[Klein]

15 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

Yeah, Red/1989 vaults are slightly below average but my Fearless album average is a full point higher without the vault 

I haven't done them yet so i don't know, but I wouldn't be surprised if the Red vault increased the album average for me tbh. Sure, there's Message In A Butthole and Run dragging the rest down, but there's also Stay Stay Stay and Girl At Home on the original... 

Edited August 10 by Klein

[wastedpotential]

3 minutes ago, Klein said:

I haven't done them yet so i don't know, but I wouldn't be surprised if the Red vault increased the album average for me tbh. Sure, there's Message In A Butthole and Run dragging the rest down, but there's also Stay Stay Stay and Girl At Home on the original... 

Redsurrection was really about a wash for me (balancing Sacred Baptisms and Testaments with Biblical Man and then Satan x3 with Raum) 

[Klein]

7 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

Redsurrection was really about a wash for me (balancing Sacred Baptisms and Testaments with Biblical Man and then Satan x3 with Raum) 

I think I got that Biblical Man is Better Man, but I have no idea what the other two (positives ones, the negatives are easy) are supposed to be. Is Testaments Treacherous? 

All these biblical names are fun until you have to understand what you're talking about 

Edited August 10 by Klein

[wastedpotential]

4 minutes ago, Klein said:

I think I got that Biblical Man is Better Man, but I have no idea what the other two (positives ones, the negatives are easy) are supposed to be. Is Testaments Treacherous? 

All these biblical names are fun until you have to understand what you're talking about 

nnnnn SBT. I debated whether to put the and in there or not for the sake of grammatical correctness 

 

Spoiler

And don't knock the biblical names because I desperately need to go to church and atone for some recent behavior but that's just not happening so this is as close as I'll be coming 

 

Edited August 10 by wastedpotential

[Klein]

1 minute ago, wastedpotential said:

nnnnn SBT 

 

  Hide contents

And don't knock the biblical names because I desperately need to go to church and atone for some recent behavior but that's just not happening so this is as close as I'll be coming 

 

Oh praise SBT again for me king. We need to payola it to the top #1. 

 

Spoiler

You've picked my interest, go on 

 

[wastedpotential]

4 minutes ago, Klein said:

Oh praise SBT again for me king. We need to payola it to the top #1. 

 

  Hide contents

You've picked my interest, go on 

 

Spoiler

ddd one of two songs I know for DAMN sure we both gave an 11 

 

[Klein]

6 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

  Reveal hidden contents

ddd one of two songs I know for DAMN sure we both gave an 11 

 

Spoiler

I'm pretty sure there's a third coming (depending on how many 11s I have left by then). I guess we'll have to wait for the rate to know if i was right because this one is a bit more out of the box. 

Edited August 10 by Klein

[wastedpotential]

4 minutes ago, Klein said:

  Hide contents

I'm pretty sure there's a third coming (depending on how many 11s I have left by then). I guess we'll have to wait for the rate to know if i was right because this one is a bit more out of the box. 

Spoiler

Oh yep that's a third 

 

Spoiler

We might have 4 depending on what you pick for evermore 

 

I haven't assigned my fifth 11 because I'm still picking between two songs on The Apotheosis but I know you stan for both so maybe we'll get lucky with schrodinger's 11 and go 5 for 5 

 

 

Edited August 10 by wastedpotential

[Klein]

2 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

  Hide contents

Oh yep that's a third 

 

  Hide contents

We might have 4 depending on what you picked for evermore 

 

I haven't assigned my fifth 11 because I'm still picking between two songs on The Apotheosis but I know you stan for both so maybe we'll get lucky with schrodinger's 11 and go 5 for 5 

 

 

Spoiler

If I know you like I think I know you, there's not a chance we're sharing the same one for evermore 

 

And I don't think TTPD is getting an 11 from me. If it did, it would actually go to part 1 instead of part 2 anyway 

 

[wastedpotential]

7 minutes ago, Klein said:

  Hide contents

If I know you like I think I know you, there's not a chance we're sharing the same one for evermore 

 

And I don't think TTPD is getting an 11 from me. If it did, it would actually go to part 1 instead of part 2 anyway 

 

Spoiler

nnn to be clear, my evermore decision has changed an ungodly number of times 

 

for instance, it was almost the better half of the Drew Dunlap fantasization duo 

 

and it was also almost the song I've been debating making my username for like six months 

 

and it was also almost the song whose title includes the name of the NFL team I grew up supporting 

 

and of course it was also almost the song that gets the standing ovations every night on tour 

 

******* Hell I love evermore too much 

 

Spoiler

however I have a guess as what your choice very well may be, which was never in consideration for me 

 

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

8 hours ago, jacklovesyou1 said:

Is the vaults dragging anyone else's scores down lol i like a few of them .. but overall yikes

Fearless and 1989 for sure. And a couple of the Red ones 

 

[jacklovesyou1]

31 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Fearless and 1989 for sure. And a couple of the Red ones 

 

As someone who doesn't really use Speak Now i have to agree Speak Now vaults are actually decent tbf 

[Axolotl]

evermore supremacy, just submitted my rates 

[Axolotl]

I already know I'll be alone in my 11s 

[Brooklyn Baby]

1 minute ago, Axolotl said:

evermore supremacy, just submitted my rates 

I see it. Thank you  

[frankvert]

Just submitted my rankings. Here's the average per album: 

 

TS: 2.79

Fearless: 2.96

SN: 5.13

Red: 6.11

1989: 6.59 

Rep: 6.53

Lover: 4.68 

Folklore: 8.41 

Evermore: 2.06

Midnights: 5.23

TTPD: 1.97

Others: 2.59

 

*All scores are based on Scooter's Versions 

 

[wastedpotential]

38 minutes ago, frankvert said:

Just submitted my rankings. Here's the average per album: 

 

Evermore: 2.06