Jump to content

The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page


Recommended Posts

Posted
1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

A fitting title for our next song as it's the last one left from its album.

 

:ryan3:

 

 

Oh not Last Corinthians... that was quick :clack:

  • Haha 1

  • Replies 10k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Brooklyn Baby

    1241

  • wastedpotential

    837

  • Dear Reader

    463

  • Klein

    375

Posted
3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

A fitting title for our next song as it's the last one left from its album.

 

:ryan3:

 

 

GOODBYE CHRISTMAS ep maybe you would of got 2's if it was december not sep

Posted

61ieflTtw5L._UF1000,1000_QL80_.jpg

 

242. Last Christmas

5.038

 

Comments

brokee

10 - "I think I heard this version before original so this one is so nostalgic."

reputation1989

9.5 - "Unironically bop."

wastedpotential

9.1 - "I know She walked into the studio, whipped out Her pink flip phone, and called up George Michael. Of course, he came running at the call of the Lord. They discussed Her upcoming cover, recorded it, and then left. Immediately after, She whipped out Her pink flip phone and called Andrea Guadeloupe Hernandez Finlay Swift and said "It'll be fun, it's gonna be a very epic- I wanted to make- My one thing was, I went into the studio with George Michael in the BMR Building, and I sat down with the president of Big Machine Records, and I said, I want to make history, and that's what this is". Naturally, Andrea Guadeloupe Hernandez Finlay Swift clapped and cheered for her Daughter over the phone, because she knew history was on its way!"

NewStanner

8 - "Hold on, why is this actually good?"

MusicLoverDude

6 - "I will always prefer the Ashley Tisdale or Ariana Grande versions."

1989

5.6 - "I mean, this is the most listenable song on the Xmas EP, but that's not saying much."

pavi

4 - "I love her but she didn't do this classic justice."

LoveInStereo

3.5 - "What makes her music special is her pen. It's bad enough she's doing a cover but a song that's been covered into oblivion with this.. particular.. vocal performance. This isn't good."

Achilles.

3 - "Nobody but George Michael should be allowed to sing this."

Where are you now?

2.5 - "Remember when i heard it at Burlington Coat Factory."

Klein

1 - "You can't spell Last Christmas without SH*T!"

Bosque

1 - "No girl."

blown away

0 - "I feel secondhand embarrassment listening to this. How dare you butcher a classic like that?"

 

Results

Spoiler
SLUTTVFTV 7
Starchild 7
llikeh 10
KillingYourCareer 10
AbeHicks 10
Losing my ground 10
brokee 10
Sanguine 10
reputation1989 9.5
wastedpotential 9.1
makeawish 9
Kyle-x 9
folkloreking 8
PerfectSacrifice 8
Feanor 8
Nein 8
creativity. 8
kyungsoowift 8
greeneyedsoul 8
NewStanner 8
greento 7.9
StØned 7.9
MidnightsAtPeace 7.6
Namigo 7.5
SleepingTigers 7.5
twoheadlightshine 7.1
PaloSanto 7
The Music Industry 7
sanzo 7
4Real 7
gagacasanova 7
Enrique523 7
AshleyLovescats887 7
Ampersand13 7
Tedwards 7
burninredhot 7
fridayteenage 7
Holy Ground 7
BOAZ 7
FolkLover1989 7
Flames2Embers 7
sparrowblue 7
enchanted0 7
Top Dash 7
TheArgonaut 6.9
Mr. Duff 6.7
badidearight 6.5
idkwiam 6.5
Mocha 6.5
Dear Reader 6.5
Edge of Glory 6.5
Michael196 6.3
roso 6.1
Forever Winter 6
pinkbowvintage 6
Live To Tell 6
Riverbank 6
Life Savers 6
chosensparkles 6
Gorjesspazze9 6
Iamanearthling 6
Axolotl 6
Yog 6
djcalpal 6
liam13 6
MusicLoverDude 6
Bussea 6
Blood Magic 6
Rev8 6
Don 6
K$Ellie 6
SoSickOfThatSOL 6
1989 5.6
G.U.Y_Del_Rey 5.5
Bindi 5.5
tb6591 5.4
terrorblade 5
SylMacPer 5
NordicGuy 5
Avrileon 5
305 5
Soobin 5
Theluckyone 5
Hurem 5
Vespertine 5
D-@-N 5
tjspy 5
Mezik 5
Miles. 5
GuyNextDoor 5
Supernatural 5
Catch22 5
Clauss 5
Flower 5
My Tears Ricochet 5
yourfaveisaflop 5
chiliam 5
Lazuli 5
Cruel Summer 5
heckinglovato 5
Ms. Togekiss 5
Velvet Night 4.5
wehavetostan 4.5
Peroxide 4.2
skizzo 4
ChapelHooker 4
halcyonday 4
frankvert 4
vinicius 4
Prismee 4
americanlife 4
Ger.vaz 4
ONOPKA 4
Hooker Barbie 4
Byzantium 4
pavi 4
Lorenzo22 4
jacobhalkohit 3.5
AdrianNicki 3.5
LoveInStereo 3.5
Solaria 3
NEX 3
a_d_22 3
Arrows 3
itsjem 3
Fitzswiftie 3
Schami66 3
LVP 3
Terylee 3
TaylenaStan 3
LovaticSwiftie 3
Diarrhoea 3
Achilles. 3
Where are you now? 2.5
Safe&Sound 2.2
DevilsRollTheDice 2
CamiloPg_ 2
@freakum. 2
modern thing 2
Strawberry Bubble 2
paulyyyozd 2
fab 2
Heldenzeit 2
PoisonedIvy 2
Taylor fanboy 2
beagle 1.2
Teen Spirit 1
Tusk 1
Great Username 1
NextBish90 1
Sad Beautiful Tragic 1
holyground13 1
ellis-bell 1
Klein 1
Quicksand 1
Swirl900 1
jacklovesyou1 1
TMRA 1
Bosque 1
By the Water 1
StonedSoulPicnic 1
LastKiss 0
blown away 0

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I could never hate the classic that is Last Christmas no matter who sings it 

  • Like 4
Posted
1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

A fitting title for our next song as it's the last one left from its album.

 

:ryan3:

 

 

spacer.png

Posted

Y'all suck.

 

Quote

9.1 - "I know She walked into the studio, whipped out Her pink flip phone, and called up George Michael. Of course, he came running at the call of the Lord. They discussed Her upcoming cover, recorded it, and then left. Immediately after, She whipped out Her pink flip phone and called Andrea Guadeloupe Hernandez Finlay Swift and said "It'll be fun, it's gonna be a very epic- I wanted to make- My one thing was, I went into the studio with George Michael in the BMR Building, and I sat down with the president of Big Machine Records, and I said, I want to make history, and that's what this is". Naturally, Andrea Guadeloupe Hernandez Finlay Swift clapped and cheered for her Daughter over the phone, because she knew history was on its way!"

 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 2
Posted

 

the best version of this classic!

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
  • Confused 2
Posted

The way I used to have a Christmas playlist of Back to December, CWYWM, and Last Christmas. 
 

What a time to be a stan! Little did I know, she would BLOW these songs all out of the water with a REAL WINTER CLASSIC.

 

 

Posted

The way this song is a holiday staple for malls in Manila :bibliahh:

Posted
3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

1 - "You can't spell Last Christmas without SH*T!"

 

:deadbanana2:

Posted

Yeah DON'T EVER COVER THIS SONG unless you're ashley tisdale then i'll allow it

  • Like 2
  • Haha 1
Posted

It's the way I have been very happy with each and every song eliminated so far. My faith in this rate is going up by the minute. I fear I have to be careful because otherwise the first diva I'll lose will hurt too much :clack:

Posted (edited)
1 minute ago, Axolotl said:

The way this song is a holiday staple for malls in Manila :bibliahh:

It really is. Not just Manila though but in Philippines as a whole.

Edited by Taylor fanboy
Posted
3 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

Excuse you, his name was Martin :gaycat6:

I always think Chris Martin, then remember he's Coldplay. From there it's a 50/50 chance I'll remember which of Coldplay's two first names is Taylor-Collaborator-???-Johnson's first name. 

Posted

Oh our first song from The Tortured Poets Department...

 

:suburban:

 

Take a guess!!!

Posted
7 minutes ago, Tusk said:

Did you like re-recording it?

Yes! It's gonna be the lead single of Debut TV instead of some khia vault track but don't tell anyone :ryan3:

Posted
2 minutes ago, Klein said:

It's the way I have been very happy with each and every song eliminated so far. My faith in this rate is going up by the minute. I fear I have to be careful because otherwise the first diva I'll lose will hurt too much :clack:

@Klein i think it's usually around the 150 Remainers where things get messy lmao..  

  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

I’m scared 

Posted
Just now, Forever Winter said:

Oh our first song from The Tortured Poets Department...

 

:suburban:

 

Take a guess!!!

Robin, unfortunately. The song is way too good

  • Thanks 1
Posted
Just now, Forever Winter said:

Oh our first song from The Tortured Poets Department...

 

:suburban:

 

Take a guess!!!

Oh tattooed golden retriever or Aaron-spawn, it's your time :suburban:

  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

Cassandra plz

Posted
Just now, Forever Winter said:

Oh our first song from The Tortured Poets Department...

 

:suburban:

 

Take a guess!!!

Cassandra haters are HOMELESS and should focus on getting a job first before hating on this CLASSIC.

  • Thanks 3
Posted
Just now, Klein said:

It's the way I have been very happy with each and every song eliminated so far. My faith in this rate is going up by the minute. I fear I have to be careful because otherwise the first diva I'll lose will hurt too much :clack:

I'm expecting one of our mutual favorites to miss the top 200 and give me a meltdown :clack:

Posted

Robin or TTPD?

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

Posted

Not you guys rating London Boy, YNTCD and The Man above TTPD :suburban:

  • Thanks 2
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.