celeb news Critics pan Woman's World: The Guardian 1/5, Pitchfork: "A monumental catastrophe"

[Sazare]

These lashings were expected but how on earth does this sound anything like Stupid Love?

[perfect blue]

Lashings deserved.

 

Why did she think this song deserved to see daylight, as a lead single nonetheless? Why did no one on her team decide to speak up and warn her? I truly don't get it. She's totally lost it creatively. 

[kellebrity98]

3 minutes ago, SupremeGoddess said:

working with a rapist is what's unprofessional here. using that controversy for clout is what katy is doing here. 

 

as a former katy kat she can rot in hell after this

it's very hypocritical since when Doja worked with him she did not get a drag (Kim is the same)

[Kiel D-01]

The fact that many OGHs were vehemently denying that WW sounded similar to SL only for the music critics to disagree.  
 

 

[Matthew4815]

Quote

With its pulsating synths and steamroller chorus, "Woman's World" is clearly modeled on Lady Gaga's 2020 single "Stupid Love," a brazen return to form that successfully launched Gaga into the second act of her career. There seems to have been a miscalculation, though: "Stupid Love" worked not because of its sound but because it took the core elements of Gaga's music—slightly nonsensical lyrics, acid-trip concept, a general struggle with vowels—and turned them up to 11.

 

7 minutes ago, Khal said:

This mess right here is hilarious

[Navyofbadgals]

You better celebrate

but there was nothing to celebrate 😔🙏

[Infernal Paradise]

The P4K review is absolutely SCATHING nnnn  

 

The SL comparisons and nun quote being used to tell her to hang it UP 

 

[Sannie]

1 minute ago, byzantium said:

Isn't the phrase a "failed Stupid Love" a little redundant? 

No. At this point, Woman's World could only wish to debut in the top five and see a modicum of SL's chart run, streams, and sales. The bar is in hell.

[KatyPrismSpirit]

The nun pleaded, Katy Perry please stop, then collapsed and died

[LionH3art]

Dead give away they didn't listen to the song and are being unprofessional since the song doesn't sound anything like stupid love. 

[SinnerCity]

The Guardian ATE with that review OMG

[Mean Trees]

Edited July 12 by Mean Trees

[Navyofbadgals]

Just now, dirrtydiana said:

 

Maybe her team should've spent that check on good reviews instead of ATRL banners 

 

this is so embarrassing for the forum. Giving promo a panned song produced by that guy

Girl click on it 😭 it links the Cher song

[Burn]

4 minutes ago, dirrtydiana said:

Maybe her team should've spent that check on good reviews instead of ATRL banners 

She doesn't have any ATRL banners. Kesha is on light mode and Cher is on dark mode, and the "stream and discuss Woman's World" pop-up banner links to Cher's thread. Trust the mods are on the right side of history.

 

Edited July 12 by Burn

[Sugden]

3 minutes ago, byzantium said:

Isn't the phrase a "failed Stupid Love" a little redundant? 

thats when you know the bar is in hell

[Sazare]

In the immortal words of Sister Catherine Rose Holzman, uttered moments before she died: "Katy Perry, please stop."
 

[Kiel D-01]

Just now, kellebrity98 said:

it's very hypocritical since when Doja worked with him she did not get a drag (Kim is the same)

I thought Doja was contractually obligated to work with him since she's in his label, I could be all wrong. 
 

As for Kim however, this is plainly inaccurate. Every Kim Petras working/talking about Dr. Luke thread is full of people dragging her. 
 

one of many examples: https://atrl.net/forums/topic/421833-kim-petras-on-dr-luke-i-have-nothing-to-be-ashamed-of"-kesha-responds/page/16/

 

[bunnyeyes]

Just saw a screen recording of the comments on the video and she is getting dragged exponentially for appealing to the male gaze in the video and for being tone deaf given women's rights are under attack. I'm not going to join in on dogpiling on this woman, but I really can't imagine working with a former friend's abuser. 

[tost1]

WAITT is Stupid Love now getting praised by the critics? What a day... 

[Venice B]

2 minutes ago, kellebrity98 said:

it's very hypocritical since when Doja worked with him she did not get a drag (Kim is the same)

In what world are y'all living that Kim Petras didn't get lashings for working with him? Before Katy she was the one who would get the most lashings because of it, and she wasn't even that famous 

[mitochondria23]

The pitchfork article took me tf out. 
that nun reference was a chefs kiss. 

[Sannie]

1 minute ago, LionH3art said:

Dead give away they didn't listen to the song and are being unprofessional since the song doesn't sound anything like stupid love. 

They are literally describing the song in detail to a T. They clearly listened to it. The real question is, have YOU?  

[BrattyBottom]

1 minute ago, dirrtydiana said:

 

Maybe her team should've spent that check on good reviews instead of ATRL banners 

 

this is so embarrassing for the forum. Giving promo a panned song produced by that guy

It's not being promoted on the site, don't worry. It links to Cher's song.

[ebaby]

I actually find the chorus extremely catchy, but the video is a mess and the rest of the song just gives people sat around and threw buzz words into a blender.

 

 

 knowing Dr. Luke is involved is just so 

Edited July 12 by ebaby

[Sazare]

4 minutes ago, byzantium said:

Isn't the phrase a "failed Stupid Love" a little redundant? 

No, only on ATRL is Stupid Love considered anything other than an artistic triumph. This weird hivemind opinion does not extend beyond the bounds of this website.