celeb news Critics pan Woman's World: The Guardian 1/5, Pitchfork: "A monumental catastrophe"

[Cain]

1 hour ago, Shelter said:

26 pages  atrl loves a downfall 

The fact Katy had nothing to fall down from 

 

We're watching someone on the ground sink

 

[Enrique523]

I can't believe i missed the party with this thread, what a RIOT 

 

The first post having almost 200 likes, i can't 

[Dolce Vita]

1 hour ago, Shelter said:

26 pages  atrl loves a downfall 

to be fair you need to be on top of something to fall down. this was more like…a sinking experience, i fear. 

 

[Soup in Teapot]

Not this lady is suffering like Gaga during Artpop era

[Nova_23]

1 hour ago, Broken said:

Yep. P!nk and Kelly hate him.

 

He's horrible...

 

 

 

Yea he sucks. Katy really messed up cause it's one thing to be a commercial and critical failure. it's another thing to be both while also losing the respect of your peers because you worked with their abuser. There's a reason why we haven't seen anyone come in and defend Katy from the lashings or come out and talk about how "good" the song is. Even Crisp Rat got his peers to come out and defend him from the "worst" Chris allegations. Katy has no one. 

 

It's all indefensible behavior. 

Edited July 13 by Nova_23

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, Dolce Vita said:

to be fair you need to be on top of something to fall down. this was more like…a sinking experience, i fear. 

 

Yeah, this is the first time on ATRL i've ever seen such a party being thrown for the downfall of a pop star who was ALREADY over to begin with 

 

 

Katy truly made history with this one 

[Enrique523]

On 7/12/2024 at 5:24 PM, Vespertine said:

I wish Taylor hadn't ever made up with Katy.

 

I miss the days when she was super petty, like returning to Spotify on Katy's album release day. This would've been a perfect day to bully Katy. 

 

 

I'm still hoping for a surprise release of Rep TV on September 20th 

[PlERRE]

2 hours ago, PoisonedIvy said:

Is there like… ANY review that isn't purely negative?

Probably in the Katy base. 

[Enrique523]

On 7/12/2024 at 6:20 PM, BrokenMachine said:

Stopped reading there 

Yeah, Woman's World is absolute trash and deserves all the lashings but the way some critics want to rewrite history and act as if Stupid Love was some kind of triumph... let's not 

[PlERRE]

THE AMOUNT OF POPULAR POSTS IN PAGE 1

 

[Ethereaaal]

50 minutes ago, Soup in Teapot said:

Not this lady is suffering like Gaga during Artpop era

Except Gaga was never this panned and irrelevant 

[Tower]

Caring about critics in 2024

[Mr. Blue_Shirt]

56 minutes ago, Soup in Teapot said:

Not this lady is suffering like Gaga during Artpop era

Which would make 21 Savage her T.I.

 

[Human Fly]

This thread is on par with ARTPOP's HDD thread where the predictions went from 560k to 250k each day and Katy's CTTR 45k thread 

[Human Fly]

1 hour ago, Soup in Teapot said:

Not this lady is suffering like Gaga during Artpop era

ARTPOP was more like shock to everyone because her predictions went from 560k to 250k within 5 days and critics were too harsh on her. Applause peaking at #4 didnt help her in her case. 

But this is whole another level. 

Poor Katy, she'll never come back to grace of pop scene again.

[Genius1111]

27 pages now! Sugden's thread is an instant classic, I fear. (And a good one to print out and save as a memento.)

 

Ms Hudson's career is comparable to the Titanic, honestly. Everything that could have gone wrong, has indeed gone wrong.

[Wicked]

 

[sunbathinganimal]

4 hours ago, WildAmerican said:

The biggest death blow of them all on Wikipedia:

 

nnnn the stan battle on the edit history

 

[scheibe]

 

[Apolonio ₃₄]

38 minutes ago, Wicked said:

 

 

5 minutes ago, scheibe said:

 

[TayDuaStan]

https://themusic.com.au/features/katy-perry-womans-world-review-feminism/nCAijrGws7I/13-07-24

"Katy Perry's legacy used to be a Teenage Dream but now it's more of an early mid-life crisis nightmare. Unfortunately for her, Katy Perry is a Barbie Girl in a Woman's World. Come on Barbie, let's go retire."

[NoAngelus]

2 hours ago, MAKSIM said:

Calling WW trash is not an example of bad journalism, it's a reflection of popular opinion. 

Bad journalism is when you make review sound like ATRL post. 

[MAKSIM]

5 minutes ago, NoAngelus said:

Bad journalism is when you make review sound like ATRL post. 

Music reviewers aren't doing combat journalism in Gaza. Pop culture reviews have always been shady. Roger Ebert built a whole career over the way he could word how disastrous a movie truly is. This song is getting the professionalism in reviews that it deserves. 

[Soup in Teapot]

At least she is very rich and has a good man. She will be fine.

[Mr. Blue_Shirt]

24 minutes ago, sunbathinganimal said:

nnnn the stan battle on the edit history

 

'The source cited literally says "bombed with critics"' is sending me so bad dd