celeb news Critics pan Woman's World: The Guardian 1/5, Pitchfork: "A monumental catastrophe"

[Archetype]

6 hours ago, BrattyBottom said:

The Dr. Luke produced 'Woman's World' – which is as empowering as an advert for Vagisil

Not Dazed one-upping P4K  

[WildAmerican]

we need to nominate this thread and its posts for some sort of award

 

[AvadaKedavra]

Is honestly crazy how the album has so many hitmakers. The visuals-aesthetic are amazing-otherworldly
Without the Dr Puke thing im totally sure this would be a 9/10 era and everyone would be very hyped and praising her?
Damn. I honestly didnt expect the backlash to be this titanic. I thought people would get outraged about dr luke but move on...........
This is one of the reasons why people should never move away from their moral lines. Karma will probably come. Universe has a way
 

If Katy were more humble, she' would move the album release despite the millions spent, apologize to Kesha for working with Dr. Luke, and say she's had a change of heart.
She'd rework everything and just release the album later without him.
People would respect her for doin the right thing.
there's always space for forgiveness.
 

Taylor can pull off all these surprise album drops and random things at a moment's notice. Why can't Katy?

 

This album seems like it's going to be a massive bomb worse than witness.
If things look this bad, why not cancel a project that could do so much long term damage? labels push back projects all the time
The folks at Capitol are idiots for allowing this after seeing the huge backlash in the early days of this announcement.

i thought the album music would be enough to save the record but im honestly scared at how big this backlash is 
the only good thing of this is how is helping kesha. She deserves more support. Stream joyride
 

 

Edited July 13 by AvadaKedavra

[Funnyfatty]

This year is the year of karma i guess. 
 

evil people like Drake, jno and now Katy are being DESTROYED. Rightfully. They have done so many stupid things behind other peoples back and now they are suffering.

 

Fatty perry is first and foremost NOT a vocalist. Terrible vocals terrible singer.

she is NOT a songwriter. 
she is NOT a performer. 
She is NOT an artist 

She does NOT have a vision. 
 

She needs that stupid specific group in order to get a hit but bich YOU SHOULDN'T WORRY about getting a hit. 
 

The way most artists are switching producers every album every era because they want to try something different and go through a change but this woman has such a terrible vision that she believes that she can't work with someone other than dr puke (A RAPIST) 

 

Kesha is not my friend, she is just a woman i heard on the radio. 
i heard her story and i felt bad. 
titty perry though knows her and was her friend. SHE DECIDED TO WORK WITH A MAN THAT RAPED HER FRIEND. For her own benefit (to get a hit i guess). 
 

I always hated this woman but glad that everyone else is seeing the light. 
 

if she had the power, she would have done worse things to Taylor btw. She is not as smart as taylor so she HAD TO act friendly towards her. 
 

clown hoe. 
 

A womans world that is created by a rapist? She truly is DISGUSTING

[Summerboy95]

This thread made my day UGH 

[Soda Pop Queen]

lol not surprised it's being panned. She's never been hot with music critics. I'll see what the numbers are to determine if it's another certified flop or not.

[eyeroll]

2 hours ago, Aurora said:

Seeing so many adult men on here frothing at the mouth at the takedown of a woman is disturbing. Imagine proudly sporting avatars of women while actively getting excited about the public tearing down of an innocent woman and holding her to the alleged actions of one sixth of this song's production team. Misogyny is alive and well.

I know it's wild that Katy stans were so rude about Kesha's comeback and supporting her abuser right? Wild times we live in!!

[Sombre]

Waiting on America's Test Kitchen to publish a review.

[Matthew4815]

Shew reading this thread today has been fun.

[Infernal Paradise]

9 hours ago, G.U.Y_Del_Rey said:

The lashings on aoty.org, 24/100 score

 

https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/987959-katy-perry-womans-world/user-reviews/?sort=recent

 

 

 

 

 

(mods should consider making this an official jonny btw it's instantly iconic)

 

[longjohn9898]

not the NUN'S LAST WORDS living on forever as the final line of the most scathing review I've seen in years 

 

I've asked for years and here's to hoping she finally does

 

[ALA]

Well... good that she already has the album ready to release and announced. I think if this song does poorly (... it's looking likely) and she never announced 143 it might have been reworked or WW would not be on the album

[RideOrDie]

well well well... guess it looks like rideordie is no longer your biggest worry kitkats

 

[Aston Martin]

29 minutes ago, Sombre said:

Waiting on America's Test Kitchen to publish a review.

PLEASE the way I can picture the lady who does the equipment reviews absolutely eviscerating this

 

 

[Sannie]

Usually the comment section on YT is filled with fans praising the artist they love but even the comments (from what I can see) are lashing this. Just a massive overall bomb. I've always wondered what goes on behind the scenes when something like this happens. Is her team scrambling? Surely they see all the negative stuff being related to Dr. Luke and they have an entire album with him ready to go.  

[Nova_23]

11 hours ago, Sannie said:

OH MY GOD. Now they're all just tag teaming her at this point. I knew it would be bad, but not this bad.

 

 

 

This just cured my depression. I can't stop laughing The lashings all in one post  

[$ebert]

Satisfying

[Peak Now]

Not 18 popular posts on the first page I- 

[duybeeGAshantiGA]

26 minutes ago, Sannie said:

Usually the comment section on YT is filled with fans praising the artist they love but even the comments (from what I can see) are lashing this. Just a massive overall bomb. I've always wondered what goes on behind the scenes when something like this happens. Is her team scrambling? Surely they see all the negative stuff being related to Dr. Luke and they have an entire album with him ready to go.  

Lmao you are not wrong. Even on my Youtube people are trashing it. A few people on my facebook friends pretend/force themselves to like it tho.

[Cloröx]

Listen the snippets for the rest tracks and they are even worse than Woman's World 

 

 

 

[The7thStranger]

You know, we're focusing too much on the Dr. Luke backlash. We need to start discussing the music.

 

It SUCKS.

 

I'm sorry, but this song is vacuous and so pender heavy.

[descg]

"This feels like the 78th best pop song of 1996."

From a Youtube comment 

[Suilen]

Deserved after the Kats' semi-transphobic deflections to Ethel Cain.

 

As for Katy, I don't know an artist more clueless about who they are and what they should be doing.

[Mr. Stratus]

whoever made that toilet gif must've had a six sense cause it feels like everyone is getitng pleasure in just coming and taking their own personal dump. Katy needs to address it and flush it - before it overflows

[duybeeGAshantiGA]

1 minute ago, descg said:

Nelly Furtado

But at least Nelly is a decent human being. Katy has none. She actually has all the money in the World that would be more than enough for her to have the best support/material to make decent music, but she ran to Dr Lupe. Nelly Furtado, on the other hand, is almost like an independent artist who doesnt have much budget.