Namie-Knowles Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 (edited) As someone who was an infant during Britneys peak and a young teenager during Katy's peak I want to ask ATRL on their thoughts. Since a lot of people here are older than me and might have a clearer view of things. Rank their peaks from the smallest to biggest. Edited July 7 by Namie-Knowles Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
PMKARDASHIAN Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Britney and Gaga easily, id say Gaga (because I lived through both) and Gaga's peak caught the entire world on fire 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post Punky Rooster Posted July 7 Popular Post Share Posted July 7 Britney by far, to even question this is hilarious. 7 14 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RobynYoBank Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 (edited) Gaga, Britney, Katy. Biggest to smallest. I think people tend to inflate Britney's peak a bit here and forget that she peaked at the peak of album sales. Gaga was undeniably the biggest artist in the world at her peak, while Britney played second fiddle to Eminem, boy bands, and had female peers - Shania Twain, Spice Girls. Edited July 7 by RobynYoBank 2 2 1 2 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TedMiracle Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Britney > Katy = Gaga ATRL loves to exaggerate Gaga's peak. 9 3 4 4 9 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
itshyolee Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Yesss let's see what the OG gays have to say 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Roberto Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Definitely not Katy. I would say Gaga but BOMT was just too astronomical. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
halcyonday Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Gaga. 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kexin Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Britney paved the way for both of them 4 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
UseYourIllusion2002 Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 9 minutes ago, RobynYoBank said: Gaga, Britney, Katy. Biggest to smallest. I think people tend to inflate Britney's peak a bit here and forget that she peaked at the peak of album sales. Gaga was undeniably the biggest artist in the world at her peak, while Britney played second fiddle to Eminem, boy bands, and had female peers - Shania Twain, Spice Girls. Britney didn't play second fiddle to Eminem and the boy bands though? ...Baby One More Time went 14x platinum which is more than any *Nsync album, just as much as the highest selling Backstreet Boys album, and more than the highest selling Eminem album from that time which went 12x platinum. She was also a much bigger phenomenon in the media. On the other hand, The Fame is 6x platinum while Teenage Dream and Fearless, both released around the same time, are Diamond. Even Loud is right behind The Fame at 5x platinum . 6 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hausofbryan Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Not Katy being mixed in with two literal pop legends 5 3 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Eternium Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 33 minutes ago, RobynYoBank said: Gaga, Britney, Katy. Biggest to smallest. I think people tend to inflate Britney's peak a bit here and forget that she peaked at the peak of album sales. Gaga was undeniably the biggest artist in the world at her peak, while Britney played second fiddle to Eminem, boy bands, and had female peers - Shania Twain, Spice Girls. You have no sense of reality with this post, sis. OT: Britney > Gaga >>>>>>> Katy. Britney was absolutely massive and ruled everything - everyone was either a Britney clone or anti-Britney for a long period. Gaga was humongous, too, and definitely a strong second. She didn't have quite as much impact as Britney or the continued success, but she was the closest we've seen since. Katy is not in the conversation. She didn't have the same impact - she just had back-to-back massive smashes. TD was massive, but she wasn't a phenomenon in the same way Britney and Gaga were. 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
A-V-XYZ Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Gaga >>>>> Katy >>>>> Britney Britney only had 1 Hot 100 #1 at her peak and won 0 Grammy awards. Lmao. Haha. 2 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Alyssa Edwards Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Britney above Gaga but not by an insane level. Both were the biggest things on the planet when they were at their peak. 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JackOfHearts Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Katy doesn't really belong in this comparison. 🤔 As for the other 2, it's too difficult to compare their peaks. Apples and oranges. Katy is a California raisin or something. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rhaenyra Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Britney ushered in a new era of pop and set the standard and Lady Gaga revolutionized it and changed the pop game forever. Katy was just happy to be on the ride 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TipToe Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Katy was a chart monster but her celebrity status was very minor compared to GaGa and Britney tbh. From my personal experience: GaGa peak circa Bad Romance was the biggest. Britney had the media machine of the early 00s working on her favor, she was everywhere, but the impact of her art was very restricted to the teen pop realm and the novelty factor wasn't very big outside the controversial aspect. Now GaGa had everybody and their momma singing and dancing to BR, the novelty factor surrounding her was more striking and reached a bigger demographic... proof of that is that she had bigger competition than Britney and still got all the industry accomodating to her, copying her "eccentric" style as the next big trend etc. 1 1 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Trent W Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Britney was the biggest one I've seen The commercial success, the impact, the influence, the insane celebrity, the britney mania All at the same time. Gaga was a second one, she definitely came close, but Britney was completely inescapable For me the 3 biggest peaks have been: Britney>>Gaga>> Taylor last year. Katy doesn't have a horse in this race, she shouldn't be mentioned, her peak was small. 2 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tistotal Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 are you really putting THE Britney Spears in the same level as pop icons Katy Perry and Gaga? I did not live Britney's peak but there must be a reason why everybody knows her and can recognize her smash hits. Britney, of course. 6 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AllyGayTor Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 The Katy setup 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Carla Rosón Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Britney>Gaga>Taylor>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Katy (as much as i love her her peak was nowhere as big) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Happylittlepunk Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Britney and Gaga are legends. Katy is barely an icon herself. There is no competition! 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RobynYoBank Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 (edited) 1 hour ago, UseYourIllusion2002 said: Britney didn't play second fiddle to Eminem and the boy bands though? ...Baby One More Time went 14x platinum which is more than any *Nsync album, just as much as the highest selling Backstreet Boys album, and more than the highest selling Eminem album from that time which went 12x platinum. She was also a much bigger phenomenon in the media. On the other hand, The Fame is 6x platinum while Teenage Dream and Fearless, both released around the same time, are Diamond. Even Loud is right behind The Fame at 5x platinum . TFM is at 40M units. There's only one album from this century above it. There's like ten albums above Britney's biggest album from just that decade alone, including multiple female albums. Edited July 7 by RobynYoBank 1 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
PerfectCure Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 This thread gets made every 2 weeks The answer will always be Lady Gaga 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
YourHonesty Posted July 7 Share Posted July 7 Easily Britney as far as celebrity status. Gaga was more of a traditional artist, while Britney was a marketing machine. The endorsements, TV spots, merchandise, etc. were endless. Not to mention the tabloid obsession and sex appeal (both of which reached audiences beyond music fans). With Britney you have to think of it in terms of all the success of her first few albums + a Kim K level media reach, which Gaga never achieved. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts