base talk X-Tina vs. Taylor Swift: Bigger Talent?

[Lagerfeld]

If we judge these girls by these criteria, which one will be considered the bigger talent?

 

Vocals | Songwriting | Dancing | Acting | Artistry | Catalog

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

[Josh]

this is a set up

[La Reina]

Pretty sure even Taylor herself would say Xtina bar songwriting. 

[ReH2o]

[XDNA]

I'll say they're equal and have strength in different areas. Xtina is generational vocal talent and Taylor is a generational songwriting talent. 

[Xtina23]

I think Taylor would also think it's Xtina since X's album was the first album she ever bought!!

[liam13]

my two faves  

vocal: legend X

songwriting: legend T

dancing: legend X

acting: legend X

artistry: legend T

catalog: legend T

 

a tie 

but if i still have to choose, i'd choose taylor.

[Patient Zero]

Xtina of course 

[itshyolee]

Christina wins easily. 

 

Hell, she would win based off of her singing abilities alone.

[Bends]

Taylor is more talented in terms of business.

[RideOrDie]

taylor sweetie... 

[Dark Miracles]

Xtine is an equally good if not better songwriter (as are almost all top female artists from 00s era), sings circles around her, performs circles around her, there's nothing to compare here

[nostalgic]

Xtina has the pipes and Taylor has the pen  two masters of their craft.

[Gladiator]

I think the answer is very clearly Christina. 

[XtiRih]

Please

 

lyrically this song EATS everything Taylor has released

 

vocally? I think Christina's fart is more melodic than Taylor's best performance.

 

You might as well ask a question

 

Whitney vs. Bebe Rexha

 

 

[Erreur2 La Nature]

Christina Aguilera is more talented than Taylor Swift.

[KKCuteCat]

People who voted for Xtina when her only talent is screaming in every song  

[XtiRih]

5 minutes ago, KKCuteCat said:

People who voted for Xtina when her only talent is screaming in every song  

• Now Playing: Avril Lavigne

[KKCuteCat]

16 minutes ago, XtiRih said:

• Now Playing: Avril Lavigne

The fact you brought Avril here thinking it was a shade to me  ?

[QuanticXplosion]

The Christina Aguilera for me. But The Taylor Swift is an amazing talent as well. 

[CherryBay]

Xtina and is not remotely close 

[Marry The Gods]

Christina Aguilera and Taylor would agree  

 

[Cottonmouth]

Xtina for all apart from success. 

 

Vocals | Songwriting | Dancing | Acting | Artistry | Catalog

 

 

[Kiss It Better]

Xtina sweetie.... and songwriting wise i know Xtina doesn't write all of her songs, but Taylor wishes she could write Hurt 

[shyboi]

i think i voted Christina but i meant Taylor