video game PokéRate: Unova [Gen 5] | The crowned winner is... | P. 114

[Ponzi]

This Gen makes me want to hand out only 0s and 11s. I love it 

[Magickarp]

Finished the tier maker, but now realizing how hard it will be to copy that over

 

[UnusualBoy]

The worst gen and I feel offended to participate but I will anyway.

 

 

Let me work on my scores.

[Curaga]

30 minutes ago, Magickarp said:

Finished the tier maker, but now realizing how hard it will be to copy that over

 

Oh yeah... it's nice for a visual, but then you still have to fill out the ballot manually

 

I like it as a visual aid so that when I see I've scored two Pokemon the same but I obviously like one more than the other, I'll bump one of them up/down, but it's totally optional — we already know some people don't give scores other than 1 and 10 so the tiers won't help them lmao

[Suilen]

Was there a Gen 5 rate on the new ATRL that's now archieved/deleted? Or was this the only one?

 

https://classic.atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=507842

[Heldenzeit]

Currently debating whether I should dump the first 56 exists all in one or two posts and then only start truly revealing the top 100 or not? What is yalls take on this? 

[Suilen]

7 minutes ago, Heldenzeit said:

Currently debating whether I should dump the first 56 exists all in one or two posts and then only start truly revealing the top 100 or not? What is yalls take on this? 

Maybe post them in fives? 56 or even 23 at once will probably be a bit hard to take + all the comments (and people will complain if they're omitted).

[Conker]

Just do 10 a day. That's what we did in the Gen 1 rate.

 

Working on this right now. 

[Edge Of Glory]

7 hours ago, Suilen said:

Was there a Gen 5 rate on the new ATRL that's now archieved/deleted? Or was this the only one?

 

https://classic.atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=507842

there was and i hosted it and it was a MESS bc i was in my last semester of high school + couldn't make graphics the way i wanted + i included megas/forms in the rankings when everyone wanted them separately iirc?? 

 

may this rate run much, MUCH more smoothly. #SimisearforAnythingButLastPlace 

[PillowCase]

Gothorita when I catch you! 

[UnusualBoy]

Ok, I just finished the rates and wow, it was such a chore, I was like when is the list gonna end?  

 

This made me realize that with a shorter dex, it would've been a decent gen but it's so bloated with fillers.

[Magickarp]

16 hours ago, Edge Of Glory said:

there was and i hosted it and it was a MESS bc i was in my last semester of high school + couldn't make graphics the way i wanted + i included megas/forms in the rankings when everyone wanted them separately iirc?? 

 

may this rate run much, MUCH more smoothly. #SimisearforAnythingButLastPlace 

Do u still have the results? 

[Edge Of Glory]

18 minutes ago, Magickarp said:

Do u still have the results? 

here ya go!!

 

the way i gave simisear my 11 just for it to barely be second-to-last place...if i gave it a 10, it would've tied with patrat for last place, and anything less would've made it last place

 

 

[Conker]

Back in 2014 on GameFAQS when we get every gen (up until Gen 6)? 

 

Nobody posted any pictures. We were basically going by instinct whenever a Pokémon was posted. 

 

And if pictures were posted, it was the very cut/copy/paste picture of a Pokemon from Google Images (with Safesearch turned off for some of them.)

 

And they (40+ users) provided write-ups way longer than mine. 

[SLIME]

in

[BambiStar]

Feel like the Gen 1 Rate didn't take forever with roughly the same amount of (and arguably more boring) mons  doubt anyone will care if all the filler Patrats, monkeys, etc are dumped at once though

[BambiStar]

 

because of what she's been through and she's still singing 

[Graves]

The first chunk of the dex is definitely the weakeast - when it's at it's most "Gen 1 Retread". Things get a lot better once you got to the Sewaddle ~ Sandile part of the roster

[Suilen]

8 hours ago, Edge Of Glory said:

here ya go!!

 

the way i gave simisear my 11 just for it to barely be second-to-last place...if i gave it a 10, it would've tied with patrat for last place, and anything less would've made it last place

 

 

Not me being among the participants when I absolutely don't remember that, but those 11s check out.

 

 

Chandelure will probably be sabotaged hard this time, so we'll see.

[Graves]

 

He's just like me fr.

[Konril]

The amount of Mon's I do not care for this Gen maybe I'll pull an @Gourgeist & @Magickarp, and be allergic to the 2-9 keys.

[coolcristobal]

I don't want my ballot to look like a trolly mess but most of this dex really is either a 10 or a 1, and unfortunately there's more 1's.

 

And there's more 10's than Kaloser has new Pokemon in total 

[artc0cx]

Started making mine, I already know who's my 0 

 

[Shendelzare]

A certain FIRE type pokemon really saved this gen hun 

[Chiidish]

Let me submit