base talk Better first 12 #1s: Rihanna vs Taylor Swift

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

 

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

[Brooklyn Baby]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

[Taylor fanboy]

This is a set up. 
 

Rihanna but I hope they share a #1 with This Is What You Came For (feat. Rihanna & Calvin Harris) (Taylor's Version) (From The Vault)

[Raver]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

Rihanna 10

Taylor 2 

[Expensive Taste]

Is this question serious? Rihanna has the most commercial voice in the industry, and all, I mean, ALL of her #1 hits are completely memorable.

[aotearoa]

where's Lift Me Up?  

[Nebur]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

[naval23]

Even Swifties can admit that Taylor's #1s are some of her worst

 

Delicate, Style, Love Story, Trouble deserve

[ChrisTheLoner]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

 

Rih - 10

Tay - 6

 

Rih easily wins in that department 

[1000 forms of queer]

16 minutes ago, Diesel is Desire said:

 

 

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

 

[HarajukuPrincess]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off (Tie)

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan (Tie)

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero (Tie)

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

 

Of course Rih is gonna take this one, but love Taylor's too. 
 

[JoeAg]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

 

damn! actually a little bit closer than I'd expected…

8 vs 4

 

Rih 

[Selenasworld]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

[woohoo]

I'm dead even 6 on 6 but ATW TV gives an edge, because I listen to it weekly still. That and I've lost interest in R9 over the last EIGHT YEARS

[Bey_Rihstan]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

 

yikes! it's a bloodbath 

[Gladiator]

Taylor has a notorious history of releasing some of my least favorite tracks as singles. 
 

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

[IsidoraMarí]

Hmmm I think Rihanna's hits are far older than Taylor's giving them that nostalgia edge. 

 

I'll give Taylor Cruel Summer over S&M but that's about it. Possible tie for Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

 

Now Down Bad STOMPS The Monster so keep streaming

[Blue Skies]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

[Punky Rooster]

All Rhi except for Taylor's best song, cardigan.

[Anomaly]

5 minutes ago, Punky Rooster said:

All Rhi except for Taylor's best song, cardigan.

Oh wow, I couldn't have said it better myself  

[superben]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

[alfonso12]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

 

Rihanna wins. 

[Flower]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

[taylorrrr]

SOS vs We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

Umbrella vs Shake It Off

Take a Bow vs Blank Space

Disturbia vs Bad Blood

Live Your Life vs Look What You Made Me Do

Rude Boy vs cardigan

Love the Way You Lie vs willow

What's My Name? vs All Too Well (10 Minute Version)

Only Girl (In the World) vs Anti-Hero

S&M vs Cruel Summer

We Found Love vs Is It Over Now?

Diamonds vs Fortnight

[Lady Claire]

I don't even have to pick the song v. song battle, it's obviously Rihanna as all of her #1s were actual huge hits everywhere