dirrtydiana Posted April 27 Posted April 27 On 4/25/2024 at 2:17 PM, Digitalism said: I think he did. He is just saying that for someone with that huge peak there wasn't any unescapable singles. There's nothing wrong with that This is the one she obviously has smash famous songs but if you guys sit back and realize that she has been putting so many bodies of work out, the GP will not recognize her recent singles as a you belong with me or blank space, etc
The Music Industry Posted April 27 Posted April 27 4 minutes ago, Moloko Plus said: The circle jerk in here I really dislike Taylor but even I know the majority of the replies in here are highly DELUSIONAL… Taylor has been winning too much, so hate circle jerks on here is a way for them to cope 2
OnlyManInTheWorld Posted April 27 Posted April 27 Taylor literally OWNS this site. The obsession and absolute delusion in the comments 6
NEX Posted April 27 Posted April 27 34 minutes ago, Communion said: I mean the singles from the swamp witch albums that rejuvenated her career critically and even the vault track singles off the TVs felt like they came and went. But Anti-Hero was arguably a huge, huge hit across every demographic, so odd comment. Is it Over Now Peak: #1 Top 10 weeks: 4 Top 20 weeks: 13 Overall weeks: 23 Yes, End! Peak: #1 Top 10 weeks: 2 Top 20 weeks: 4 Overall weeks: 13 Literally 3x bigger with that Top 20 residency than the lead single of a supposed MPG -- Is this the new OTH base? Has anyone tried the chicken? 1 1 1 1
Communion Posted April 27 Posted April 27 (edited) 4 minutes ago, NEX said: Is it Over Now Peak: #1 Top 10 weeks: 4 Top 20 weeks: 13 Overall weeks: 23 Yes, End! Peak: #1 Top 10 weeks: 2 Top 20 weeks: 4 Overall weeks: 13 Literally 3x bigger with that Top 20 residency than the lead single of a supposed MPG -- Is this the new OTH base? Has anyone tried the chicken? Such a weird response since you'd 1) assume I would argue Yes, And? is a huge hit (it wasn't) and 2) just gone and purposefully earned an Off-Topic warning that of course I'm going to report the post for? Like? What? And that's before even getting into that Neil Tennant is British so what would American Hot 100 figures even have to do with anything? (PS: This is also not a cue to do *another* off-topic post with OCC stats either) Edited April 27 by Communion 3 2 1
aesthetic bih Posted April 27 Posted April 27 (edited) To be fair, not a lot of artist have a hit as huge as Billie Jeans (them included) so idk what that guy is yapping about... For example, Joni Mitchell does not have a Billie Jeans hit, but does that make her less impactful and less of a legend? ABSOLUTELY NOT! Edited April 27 by aesthetic bih 2
Shelter Posted April 27 Author Posted April 27 12 minutes ago, Communion said: Such a weird response since you'd 1) assume I would argue Yes, And? is a huge hit (it wasn't) and 2) just gone and purposefully earned an Off-Topic warning that of course I'm going to report the post for? Like? What? And that's before even getting into that Neil Tennant is British so what would American Hot 100 figures even have to do with anything? (PS: This is also not a cue to do *another* off-topic post with OCC stats either) That Tay song was radio driven, no one knows it 1
NEX Posted April 27 Posted April 27 8 minutes ago, Communion said: Such a weird response since you'd 1) assume I would argue Yes, And? is a huge hit (it wasn't) and 2) just gone and purposefully earned an Off-Topic warning that of course I'm going to report the post for? Like? What? And that's before even getting into that Neil Tennant is British so what would American Hot 100 figures even have to do with anything? (PS: This is also not a cue to do *another* off-topic post with OCC stats either) Ok, since you struggled to comprehend, let me break it down to you: spending 13 weeks in the top 20 without any push, remixes, performance or even a video clearly doesn't align well with your weak "came and went" drag. To help you comprehend I used an example of a #1 hit from your fave. If Is It Over Now "came and went", what would you call Yes, End? The song with a major push, 50+ remixes, and a music video. Oh did I mention Mariah Carey?? Mariah Carey!! And not you trying to make this into a British charts situation when you spoke directly about her career rejuvenation and critical acclaim in general. Such a master of deflection lol. And stop worrying about my warning points - it never went above 0. 1 3
WildHeart Posted April 27 Posted April 27 On 4/26/2024 at 12:57 PM, Avenger said: People here not knowing Pet shop boys is a living proof, nothing remains forever in about 20 years or so Taylor music will also be spoken about like this! People are just not interested in visiting old music and that's alway been the case for most part. No she won't. Imagine comparing century's biggest artist to Pet Shot Boys and thinking you made any point. People still know and listen acts like MJ, The Beatles, Nirvana, Madonna, Elvis etc. and Taylor will be no different than them. On 4/26/2024 at 4:28 PM, LIDDOATIN said: FACTS Only but even comparing Taylor's Legit "SMASH HITS" to Gaga's, Katy's, Adele's SMASH HITS? they pale even FLOWERS and I'm Good stomped on boring unknown fan-inflated songs like fortnight, anti-hero, cardigan, willow The NERVE of liddos when Gaga released only ONE hit song in the last DECADE Taylor's top 5 biggest hits outstreams Gaga's whole forgotten catalogue everyday. The nerveee 1 1 6
Communion Posted April 27 Posted April 27 6 minutes ago, NEX said: I used an example of a #1 hit from your fave. Sis, you're literally admitting to knowingly making Off Topic posts Neil Tenant didn't mention Ariana Grande, so that you decide to randomly mention her is...the textbook definition of off topic trolling users are told not to do. Like you're going 2 for 2 in the WP. Good luck.
WildHeart Posted April 27 Posted April 27 (edited) 19 hours ago, JO1s said: Sure... Another proof that ATRL's 40 years old audience is once again out of touch with real world 12 hours ago, RandomHooker said: Her catalogue is weak and bland. Taylor Swift's biggest hits are not remembered and have no impact. Mind you Gaga's forgotten catalogue is barely competing with Katy's 13 hours ago, Bey'Knight said: She's a 34-year old woman who can't handle criticism or stay single for a week Criciz! ng someone's love life while your fave stays with her cheater is crazy, don't you think so? Hive talking about hits here when their fave's last real hit was from 15 years ago is... really hilarious. Is this how y'all cope with your has been faves Edited April 27 by WildHeart 1 4
thequeenofpopmadonna Posted April 27 Posted April 27 (edited) Pet shop boys they are right on Edited April 27 by thequeenofpopmadonna
WildHeart Posted April 27 Posted April 27 16 minutes ago, thequeenofpopmadonna said: At last people have started realizing and seeing the bubble of taylordom. People = the voices in your head? People decided to make her the biggest artist in the world. This level of coping is crazy... 17 minutes ago, thequeenofpopmadonna said: No one remembers after days and weeks except her swifties. She has the most remembered catalogue of the century. If only Madonna fans could do the same and she wouldn't be left behind her peers 5
thequeenofpopmadonna Posted April 27 Posted April 27 (edited) 41 minutes ago, WildHeart said: People = the voices in your head? People decided to make her the biggest artist in the world. This level of coping is crazy... She has the most remembered catalogue of the century. If only Madonna fans could do the same and she wouldn't be left behind her peers The rest of the world except swifties. Duh Her albums are not even in the top 30 for the best selling albums of all time by females in the UK. No one remembers her albums either. Sorry swiftie, desperate try. Edited April 27 by thequeenofpopmadonna 1 1
WildHeart Posted April 27 Posted April 27 34 minutes ago, thequeenofpopmadonna said: The rest of the world except swifties. Duh 500M of them? Cool. 34 minutes ago, thequeenofpopmadonna said: No one remembers her albums either. They do. This is why all of her albums chart all over the world. We are not talking about Madonna and her barely 4M streamed catalogue here 5
thequeenofpopmadonna Posted April 27 Posted April 27 (edited) 37 minutes ago, WildHeart said: 500M of them? Cool. They do. This is why all of her albums chart all over the world. We are not talking about Madonna and her barely 4M streamed catalogue here Yeah right. Madonna has 13 no.1s singles there. Your favorite had only 3 in the so-called inflating streaming era. Fewer than Ariana. Tragic. Again No one remembers her disposable and factory-lnstalled like produced songs. I think she should compete with Shakira with two. Edited April 27 by thequeenofpopmadonna
WildHeart Posted April 27 Posted April 27 21 minutes ago, thequeenofpopmadonna said: Madonna has 13 no.1s singles there. Too unfortunate that almost of them are forgotten. Imagine #1 "remembered smash" doing 50k daily streams... The definition of no one curr catalogue 3
Album Leak Posted April 27 Posted April 27 (edited) 3 hours ago, aesthetic bih said: To be fair, not a lot of artist have a hit as huge as Billie Jeans (them included) so idk what that guy is yapping about... For example, Joni Mitchell does not have a Billie Jeans hit, but does that make her less impactful and less of a legend? ABSOLUTELY NOT! I think the point is that you'd expect someone of Taylor Swift's current MASSIVE status to have global monster hits. Most of her biggest hits are pre-Reputa (and it's debatable whether those hits are global classics to begin with), when she was big, but nothing compared to how big she is today. Edited April 27 by Album Leak
Princess Aurora Posted April 27 Posted April 27 I think Taylor is like Mariah. They have so many hits but the GP only knows one or two songs by them Disclaimer: This comment is not used to demean or offend any of the singers but to show what Pet Shop Boys was trying to convey with that message. I love them both and PSB is iconic 3
Alongoria13 Posted April 27 Posted April 27 Dismissing the Pet Shop Boys over an objective, harmless comment… Their influence on music is still felt to this day, the ignorance 6
The Next Day Posted April 27 Posted April 27 (edited) All I know is PSB still know enough about the current pop landscape to land a hit thread on ATRL after 40+ years in the industry, you go boys! Stream Nonetheless for clear skin! Edited April 27 by The Next Day 4 1 2
pisuke Posted April 27 Posted April 27 12 minutes ago, Alongoria13 said: Dismissing the Pet Shop Boys over an objective, harmless comment… Their influence on music is still felt to this day, the ignorance These people stan Taylor of all people. Their music knowledge has to be null or they wouldn't be. 3 4 5 1
Recommended Posts