SlimyGhoul Posted April 22 Posted April 22 53 minutes ago, Rotunda said: Why are y'all pretending like negative/mixed Pitchfork reviews aren't always discussed/dissected on this site? Taking Pitchfork seriously is not mutually exclusive with discussing or dissecting with whatever dribble they're farting out I fear
Rotunda Posted April 22 Posted April 22 16 minutes ago, SlimyGhoul said: Taking Pitchfork seriously is not mutually exclusive with discussing or dissecting with whatever dribble they're farting out I fear I'd argue that a lot of the discussion happening in this moment isn't really serious. We're talking about comparing scores for JLo and Taylor Swift . Pitchfork sometimes hits and sometimes misses, but each review kinda has to be viewed in a vacuum. The scores don't always make sense across artists, or even just across eras from the same artist. 1
stevyy Posted April 22 Posted April 22 Monique said it best: Sometimes you fave to forgo doing what's popular in order of doing what's right.
shimind Posted April 22 Posted April 22 1 hour ago, Twizzy said: Reverse ageism Pitchfork saw Taylor still dominating hard past the pop star expiration age of 30 so they had to throw a stone.. stop being blind as a stan.. why can't u guys see that the album is the equivalent of a large pile of cow dung
wigglytuffer Posted April 22 Posted April 22 This Is Me... Now is actually a really good album. There's a clear theme, it's cohesive, a NORMAL amount of tracks and only suffered commercially because J.Lo's a non-event when it comes to releasing music nowadays (and I say that with love). TTPD is just way too bloated, the reason why I Can Do it With a Broken Heart is having a moment is because it's one that you can distinctively point out. The rest sound the same. Of course TTPD has some great moments, but it's a daunting experience to listen to it from start to finish 1
Dark Phoenix Posted April 22 Posted April 22 Because TIMN is well produced, it has good melodies and a theme; while 31 songs that not only sound the same but also similar to the past albums doesn't make the cut.
Recommended Posts