Katamari Posted February 25 Posted February 25 I hope the Beatles can reach 400 weeks at some point even congrats to the legends
Michael196 Posted February 25 Posted February 25 weeks in the top 10 #1's top 10's entries Taylor Swift 384 13 16 19 The Beatles 382 19 32 59 The Rolling Stones 308 9 38 61 Barbra Streisand 277 11 34 64 Mariah Carey 233 6 18 24 Drake 233 13 16 16 Herb Alpert 210 5 10 28 Garth Brooks 208 9 19 27 Michael Jackson 191 6 10 30 Bruce Springsteen 180 11 22 42 Drake also ties Mariah for fifth place and will most likely surpass her next week... 1 2
Cruel Summer Posted February 25 Posted February 25 On her way to literally being the biggest US artist of all time at this point, incredible that she was able to take down a Beatles record that’s based on cumulative performance The fact that’s she’d almost certainly have done this a while ago if it were just pure sales makes it even more impressive. We’re witnessing history! 6
family.guy123 Posted February 25 Posted February 25 4 minutes ago, Michael196 said: weeks in the top 10 #1's top 10's entries Taylor Swift 384 13 16 19 The Beatles 382 19 32 59 The Rolling Stones 308 9 38 61 Barbra Streisand 277 11 34 64 Mariah Carey 233 6 18 24 Drake 233 13 16 16 Herb Alpert 210 5 10 28 Garth Brooks 208 9 19 27 Michael Jackson 191 6 10 30 Bruce Springsteen 180 11 22 42 Drake also ties Mariah for fifth place and will most likely surpass her next week... Morgan Wallen has at least like 188 I think
elincomprendid Posted February 25 Posted February 25 2 hours ago, Brikenbur said: So, The Beatles accomplished this with all pure sales and Taylor sales + streaming Well Taylor has 437 in the top 10 of the Album Sales chart (without counting the chart announced today) so idk what you are trying to get into here 14
elincomprendid Posted February 25 Posted February 25 1 hour ago, Michael196 said: weeks in the top 10 #1's top 10's entries Taylor Swift 384 13 16 19 The Beatles 382 19 32 59 The Rolling Stones 308 9 38 61 Barbra Streisand 277 11 34 64 Mariah Carey 233 6 18 24 Drake 233 13 16 16 Herb Alpert 210 5 10 28 Garth Brooks 208 9 19 27 Michael Jackson 191 6 10 30 Bruce Springsteen 180 11 22 42 Drake also ties Mariah for fifth place and will most likely surpass her next week... Morgan is now #10 with 190
Kern Posted February 25 Posted February 25 Some can’t stand it and it’s only going to get worse for them 1
ATRL Moderator feelslikeadream Posted February 25 ATRL Moderator Posted February 25 1 hour ago, By the Water said: folklore: lpss - 1 week This is a travesty Deserved at least 25+
wastedpotential Posted February 25 Posted February 25 2 hours ago, By the Water said: Here's a breakdown of those weeks: Midnights - 68 weeks 1989 - 60 weeks Fearless - 58 weeks Lover - 54 weeks folklore - 30 weeks Taylor Swift - 17 weeks Red - 17 weeks 1989 (Taylor's Version) - 17 weeks Speak Now - 15 weeks reputation - 12 weeks evermore - 11 weeks Red (Taylor's Version) - 9 weeks Speak Now (Taylor's Version) - 9 weeks Fearless (Taylor's Version) - 4 weeks Beautiful Eyes - 2 weeks folklore: lpss - 1 week Total: 384 weeks in the top 10 Oh Reputation get off the floor
Hunter_13 Posted February 25 Posted February 25 42 minutes ago, feelslikeadream said: This is a travesty Deserved at least 25+ It's literally because of the one off RSD vinyl release. It counted separately than folklore lol
BrandNewBrandon Posted February 26 Posted February 26 (edited) 4 hours ago, Brikenbur said: So, The Beatles accomplished this with all pure sales and Taylor sales + streaming Now, I'll be the first to comment something negative about Taylor but I'll have to disagree that this isn't a big accomplishment. It's not as historic as her fans make it out to be though considering Billboard didn't allow for albums at 18+ months to chart on the general chart up until 2010, which meant that Whitney's gigantic peak with her fourth album couldn't make her past releases chart on the Billboard 200 and neither could Eminem who has been quite a stellar album seller for an entire decade, especially during his The Real Slim Shady-The Eminem Show-8 Mile-Encore run where he was selling albums like hot cakes (over 1 million copies in two-three days as I recall) but Taylor wouldn't have had that much competition to achieve this and as a Taylor stan on here told me, regardless of this rule she'd only miss out on 48 weeks. Would she have beat them with the old rule? Hmm, I don't think the Eras Tour impact would last another year when the tour is done but I could be wrong. But it's still a major achievement that should be treated as such even in the streaming era. I don't think we have any other artist who has peaked so long into their career and it's really rare (with Whitney being the case in 1992 and Michael Jackson peaking years after starting his solo career as well) and I don't think we will in quite some time. Edited February 26 by BrandNewBrandon 1 4
False God Posted February 26 Posted February 26 41 minutes ago, BrandNewBrandon said: Now, I'll be the first to comment something negative about Taylor but I'll have to disagree that this isn't a big accomplishment. It's not as historic as her fans make it out to be though considering Billboard didn't allow for albums at 18+ months to chart on the general chart up until 2010, which meant that Whitney's gigantic peak with her fourth album couldn't make her past releases chart on the Billboard 200 and neither could Eminem who has been quite a stellar album seller for an entire decade, especially during his The Real Slim Shady-The Eminem Show-8 Mile-Encore run where he was selling albums like hot cakes (over 1 million copies in two-three days as I recall) but Taylor wouldn't have had that much competition to achieve this and as a Taylor stan on here told me, regardless of this rule she'd only miss out on 48 weeks. Would she have beat them with the old rule? Hmm, I don't think the Eras Tour impact would last another year when the tour is done but I could be wrong. But it's still a major achievement that should be treated as such even in the streaming era. I don't think we have any other artist who has peaked so long into their career and it's really rare (with Whitney being the case in 1992 and Michael Jackson peaking years after starting his solo career as well) and I don't think we will in quite some time. Stop the what if's and nitpicking lol. Charts always change! Stop being so bitter and accept defeat lol! 7
woohoo Posted February 26 Posted February 26 4 hours ago, By the Water said: Here's a breakdown of those weeks: Midnights - 68 weeks 1989 - 60 weeks Fearless - 58 weeks Lover - 54 weeks folklore - 30 weeks Taylor Swift - 17 weeks Red - 17 weeks 1989 (Taylor's Version) - 17 weeks Speak Now - 15 weeks reputation - 12 weeks evermore - 11 weeks Red (Taylor's Version) - 9 weeks Speak Now (Taylor's Version) - 9 weeks Fearless (Taylor's Version) - 4 weeks Beautiful Eyes - 2 weeks folklore: lpss - 1 week Total: 384 weeks in the top 10 Holddd up!! There’s a folklore LPSS album and what is beautiful eyes? I’m running to google
Støned Posted February 26 Posted February 26 5 hours ago, By the Water said: 1989 - 60 weeks Fearless - 58 weeks Lover - 54 weeks I’m soo ready for the meltdowns of Lover haters in 7 weeks..
Bosque Posted February 26 Posted February 26 Oh some people are going to be popping blood vessels about this 1
Popular Post Bosque Posted February 26 Popular Post Posted February 26 (edited) 2 hours ago, BrandNewBrandon said: Now, I'll be the first to comment something negative about Taylor but I'll have to disagree that this isn't a big accomplishment. It's not as historic as her fans make it out to be though considering Billboard didn't allow for albums at 18+ months to chart on the general chart up until 2010, which meant that Whitney's gigantic peak with her fourth album couldn't make her past releases chart on the Billboard 200 and neither could Eminem who has been quite a stellar album seller for an entire decade, especially during his The Real Slim Shady-The Eminem Show-8 Mile-Encore run where he was selling albums like hot cakes (over 1 million copies in two-three days as I recall) but Taylor wouldn't have had that much competition to achieve this and as a Taylor stan on here told me, regardless of this rule she'd only miss out on 48 weeks. Would she have beat them with the old rule? Hmm, I don't think the Eras Tour impact would last another year when the tour is done but I could be wrong. But it's still a major achievement that should be treated as such even in the streaming era. I don't think we have any other artist who has peaked so long into their career and it's really rare (with Whitney being the case in 1992 and Michael Jackson peaking years after starting his solo career as well) and I don't think we will in quite some time. No offense but are you kind of stupid? Dark Side of The Moon charted in its 742nd week on the Billboard 200 in 2009. The same Billboard 200 chart also shows: Call Me Irresponsible in its 83rd week (that's more than 18 months), It's Time in its 105th week (that's more than 18 months), Daughtry in its 148th week (I'm almost certain that's more than 18 months), and Off The Wall in its 170th week (is that more than 18 months? I'm not sure). Ironically for you, Taylor Swift's debut album spent its 162nd week on the chart at #39 in that exact week, in 2009 (which was before 2010, I believe). Billboard also had a special interview with Roger Waters on 05/05/2006 to celebrate the fact that their album spent over 1,500 weeks combined on two of their charts, namely the Billboard 200 and Top Catalogue Pop Albums. I don't know much about algebra but as far as I know, 742 weeks and 1,500 weeks are both more than 18 months. In fact, another famous soundtrack album by an artist you mentioned in your post (Whitney Houston) has officially spent 141 weeks on the Billboard 200. I'm pretty sure that 141 weeks is a longer time than 18 months. It's kind of crazy that you're in every single thread related to Taylor (as well as many threads that have nothing whatsoever to do with Taylor) spouting absolute nonsense that can easily be disproved within 4 seconds by anyone who has access to Google. Are all your posts some kind of elaborate performance art piece, because I'm struggling to come up with any other explanation why you are continuously exposing yourself to well-deserved lashings like this. The soundtrack stayed at number one for 20 non-consecutive weeks on the Billboard 200 chart, and spent eight consecutive weeks atop the Top R&B Albums chart, remaining on the charts for a total of 141 weeks and 122 weeks, respectively https://www.billboard.com/music/music-news/roger-waters-revisits-the-dark-side-58519/ https://books.google.de/books?id=hUd1o0aCe10C&pg=PT32&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false By the way, Whitney Houston's fourth studio album is called "My Love Is Your Love" and it spent 87 weeks on the Billboard 200 chart before falling off naturally, and 87 weeks is more than 18 months. Eminem's album with most longevity is Curtain Call btw, none of the albums that you mentioned, and that album has spent over 650 weeks on the Billboard 200 Edited February 26 by Dephira 10 5
fridayteenage Posted February 26 Posted February 26 i remember during evermore's run some ppl were like "HA she's over this time!" she keeps coming back stronger than a 90s trend
Lemon Posted February 26 Posted February 26 9 minutes ago, fridayteenage said: i remember during evermore's run some ppl were like "HA she's over this time!" she keeps coming back stronger than a 90s trend It’s actually ironic to think evermore aka probably her best album so far being indicative of someone being over.
Smilers Posted February 26 Posted February 26 3 hours ago, BrandNewBrandon said: Now, I'll be the first to comment something negative about Taylor but I'll have to disagree that this isn't a big accomplishment. It's not as historic as her fans make it out to be though considering Billboard didn't allow for albums at 18+ months to chart on the general chart up until 2010, which meant that Whitney's gigantic peak with her fourth album couldn't make her past releases chart on the Billboard 200 and neither could Eminem who has been quite a stellar album seller for an entire decade, especially during his The Real Slim Shady-The Eminem Show-8 Mile-Encore run where he was selling albums like hot cakes (over 1 million copies in two-three days as I recall) but Taylor wouldn't have had that much competition to achieve this and as a Taylor stan on here told me, regardless of this rule she'd only miss out on 48 weeks. Would she have beat them with the old rule? Hmm, I don't think the Eras Tour impact would last another year when the tour is done but I could be wrong. But it's still a major achievement that should be treated as such even in the streaming era. I don't think we have any other artist who has peaked so long into their career and it's really rare (with Whitney being the case in 1992 and Michael Jackson peaking years after starting his solo career as well) and I don't think we will in quite some time. The catalog rule only affects the total weeks on the chart and not the total weeks in the top 10. None of Eminem’s albums were still sitting in the top 10 after 50 weeks, let alone 18 months like what you’re arguing for it to have any effect. 4 2
Recommended Posts