DoubleRainbow! Posted November 28, 2023 Author Posted November 28, 2023 40 minutes ago, rihannafan said: Why are you lying? In 2015, both Rihanna and Katy did Rock in Rio and Rihanna's set was much bigger and more popular (also she closed the festival IIRC) https://www.bet.com/article/696p8v/rihanna-celebrates-record-breaking-show-in-rio you're missing the point? even if Rih's show was bigger, Katy's fanbase in LatAm was always bigger in the region
By the Water Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 POM debuted at #1, Roar sold 550k first week, Prism had a bigger debut than any Rihanna album, the Prism tour outgrossed any Rihanna tour. It's pretty clear what the answer is for now. Maybe things will change if Rihanna ever comes back but all of these numbers clearly point towards Katy
Sex with Rih Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 10 minutes ago, By the Water said: POM debuted at #1, Roar sold 550k first week, Prism had a bigger debut than any Rihanna album, the Prism tour outgrossed any Rihanna tour. It's pretty clear what the answer is for now. Maybe things will change if Rihanna ever comes back but all of these numbers clearly point towards Katy So all the artists that have debited at no.1 have a bigger fanbase than Rihanna?? Do you also know that GGGB was blocked by a T-pain album(that nobody remembers)from number 1? Does this mean T-pain has a bigger fanbase than Rihanna. How much of those numbers are actual fans?? What we know for sure is that Rihannas fanbase is still streaming her music making her the 5th most streamed female this year while Katy is nowhere to be seen. 2
rihannafan Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 17 minutes ago, Sex with Rih said: So all the artists that have debited at no.1 have a bigger fanbase than Rihanna?? Do you also know that GGGB was blocked by a T-pain album(that nobody remembers)from number 1? Does this mean T-pain has a bigger fanbase than Rihanna. How much of those numbers are actual fans?? What we know for sure is that Rihannas fanbase is still streaming her music making her the 5th most streamed female this year while Katy is nowhere to be seen. Exactly. Fanbase is about consistency, which is what Rihanna does best.
motherpills Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 dua being here when she's released two albums is sending me a bit....what peak are we talking about?
nostalgic Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 Rihanna clears but Katy was also quite popular once upon a time.
By the Water Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 35 minutes ago, Sex with Rih said: So all the artists that have debited at no.1 have a bigger fanbase than Rihanna?? Do you also know that GGGB was blocked by a T-pain album(that nobody remembers)from number 1? Does this mean T-pain has a bigger fanbase than Rihanna. How much of those numbers are actual fans?? What we know for sure is that Rihannas fanbase is still streaming her music making her the 5th most streamed female this year while Katy is nowhere to be seen. One of Rihanna's biggest albums being blocked by a T-pain album no one remembers only reinforces that her fanbase was never that big
needs Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 I vote Rihanna for the consistency she had. There's clearly a fanbase there when your albums consistently sell every year.
Sex with Rih Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 1 hour ago, By the Water said: One of Rihanna's biggest albums being blocked by a T-pain album no one remembers only reinforces that her fanbase was never that big So T-pain has a bigger fanbase?
Mystic Boy Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 As surprising as it gets it's Miss Perry for both She had bigger opening sales at her peak whether it's singles or albums. Rihanna never had those. it was always a la Dua Lipa,slow climb to huge hits. She waited until her 7th album to debut #1. 1
Credit Posted November 28, 2023 Posted November 28, 2023 songs of artists with a fan base aren't supposed to take six months to take off rihanna since she got a number 2 debut recently, probably
eli's_rhythm Posted November 29, 2023 Posted November 29, 2023 On 11/28/2023 at 9:14 AM, Garbaj said: Yes. she def had era as prolific as Teenage Dream, now don't get me wrong the Teenage Dream era was LEGENDARY and POP PERFECTION, but be serious and realize that it was released during a time period where pop was close to being DEAD, so it's not surprising that she managed to score 5 #1 singles... but even during her hiatus Rihanna runs BULLETS around Katy and makes ALL of her work look AMATURE and REPETITIVE. chart peaks, def don't compare to longevity and impact :)) How was pop dead Every pop girl was smashing around 2009-2012. Gaga, Britney, Rihanna, Beyonce, Taylor, Adele, Katy, Kesha, Nicki and P!nk were all popping off basically simultaneously. That said, Rihanna's peak era was also 2010-2012. The only difference between the LOUD/TTT/Una era and the TD era was that Rihanna released a bunch of albums and Katy was sticking to one era. If you look at their imperial phases next to each other, Rihanna's peak was bigger - she was able to shift even more albums and singles in the same time period. 3
EndofASadMovie Posted November 29, 2023 Posted November 29, 2023 The OBVIOUS answer is Katy. Katy had a bigger fanbase and the stats proved it.
Marianah Adkins Posted November 29, 2023 Posted November 29, 2023 I think its Katy. I know alot of ppl who are or were Katycats (as in they love her) whereas idk anyone irl who is an open Navy. One thing about Rih tho is that the GP always loved her. She doesnt have diehards (until recently) but ppl know who she is and are always perched at what she does. Undoubtedly, Rih is the bigger celebrity. 2 1
unclefloprry Posted November 29, 2023 Posted November 29, 2023 (edited) In Latinamerica Dua > Rihanna > Katy Katy was never able to do venues of +20k here. I think only in Brazil. Edited November 29, 2023 by unclefloprry
unclefloprry Posted November 29, 2023 Posted November 29, 2023 18 hours ago, Credit said: songs of artists with a fan base aren't supposed to take six months to take off rihanna since she got a number 2 debut recently, probably Why y'all only care about a local chart from that redneck country. The world doesn’t move around Trump's house There are global charts on every platform, almost every country has its local chart. Move on
RobynYoBank Posted November 30, 2023 Posted November 30, 2023 I’m tempted to go with Katy, though none of their fanbases have ever shown up when it mattered, to be honest. 1
Bey_Rihstan Posted November 30, 2023 Posted November 30, 2023 On 11/28/2023 at 8:18 AM, Gaia said: Rihanna despite her constant massive hits had pretty terrible album and single debuts. Rihanna's albums out-debuted Katy's albums globally several times. We're talking about the same woman that went Gold in the UK first week 5 times in a row. + Umbrella set iTunes sales records at the time.
Strawberry Bubble Posted December 4, 2023 Posted December 4, 2023 katycats. I'm from Latin America, and the Navy was basically non-existing during her peak. As for Dua... Let's just say I haven't met a Dua Lipa fan in real life. Everyone likes her, but I don't know if they really buy her stuff.
xxxlamb Posted December 4, 2023 Posted December 4, 2023 On 11/28/2023 at 8:54 AM, Artistofthedecade said: Biggest album debut Katy - 286k Rihanna - 238k Dua - 66k (so far) Biggest tour Katy - 204M Rihanna - 140M Dua - 101M Katy >> Rihanna >>> Dua the thing is we will never knw how Anti would have done without the album giveaway and leak its obvious it would have done more than 238k but by how much dunno
Recommended Posts