poll Bigger: Beautiful Girls vs Replay vs Birthday Sex

[GoodGuyGoneGhetto]

Which late 00’s R&B/Pop act has the bigger and better classic?
 

 

 

 

 

Spoiler

@Rev8 @Taylor fanboy @lonnie @naval23

 

Edited November 12, 2023 by GoodGuyGoneGhetto

[lonnie]

Biggest: Beautiful Girls >>>>>> Replay >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Birthday Sex (Birthday Sex wasn't as big as the other unfortunately)

Best: Birthday Sex >>>> Beautiful Girls >>>>>>>>>> Replay

[Erreur2 La Nature]

I've never heard Birthday Sex so I can't judge this one.

 

Bigger: Beautiful Girls

Better: Replay

[Just a Gay on ATRL]

Birthday Sex > Beautiful Girls > Replay quality wise

 

BG > Replay > BS for classic ranking

[All Guns Blazing]

Beautiful Girls for both

[Gladiator]

Beautiful Girls is the biggest, but Replay is the better track.

[Rev8]

Replay seems to be the most global on a first glance

Birthday Sex is the most local

BG is inbetween (with more globalish stats)

 

 

 

: ~~~

 

Beautiful Girls - 685m streams and 1.1b views

Replay - 804m streams and around~275m views

Birthday Sex - 419m streams and 200m views

 

BG has 59M playlist reach

Replay has 38M playlist reach

BS has 16M reach

 

 

For their daily streams/views:

BG - 385k / 426k

Replay - 514k / 71k

BS - 286k / 56k

 

 

 

 

So I guess Jeremih has the least popular one, even tho it had big sales in the US (it did awful everywhere else tho)

Sean was charting inside the Top 10, in the most countries (22) along the only one that was in a overall country Year-End chart (one of which is the Top 10 of Europe)

while Iyaz was a bit short with 19 countries Top 10s

 

So even if Replay has the edge over Beautiful Girl, it might end up bigger (or even it out) in the future

Edited November 12, 2023 by Rev8

[Marry The Gods]

Beautiful Girls was bigger but Birthday Sex is the better song. I was also obsessed with this song in summer 2009

 

 

[JoAddams]

Birthday Sex 

[okgo]

Bigger: BG

Best: BS

 

 

 

[Devin]

birthday sex >>>>>>>>>>>

[Taylor fanboy]

I can’t pick between BG and Replay as to which was bigger at the time but all three were major hits—Birthday Sex to a lesser extent here in Philippines because it was too explicit at the time. It has the “coolest” factor though.

 

Anyone else remembers Jojo’s Beautiful Girls? A GAG!

 

Replay is my personal fave.

Edited November 12, 2023 by Taylor fanboy

[Anti-Hero]

Beautiful Girls is the biggest, Definition of my 2007 

 

Next is Replay 

[naval23]

Beautiful Girls is definitely the biggest - a global smasha 

 

Birthday S** the least

 

The GP got this one right 

[Odette Violet]

Replay >>>>>

 

 

2000's music, truly one of the best era