poll Bigger: Gaga ‘08-‘11, Britney ‘98-‘01, or Taylor ‘20-‘23?

[unclefloprry]

Even Justin Bieber and One Direction's peaks are bigger and more impressive.

[PoisonedIvy]

1 minute ago, unclefloprry said:

love this delusional world where swifties live. Could you give me what you smoke? 

It’s called oxygen, that’s what you inhale when you step out into the real world! You should try it  

[GraceRandolph]

Why can’t the basement that they are running the music industry out of just collapse already?

[Redporus]

Rita Ora for both 

[Alexz]

10 minutes ago, Steve Johnson said:

Don’t worry, there is no humanity left anymore. 

No wonder Taylor appeals to the souless so much.

[Maroonx]

I'd say Taylor and Britney for these two polls. x

[St. Charles]

I like how the results are so close for pop culture moment!

[Steve Johnson]

4 minutes ago, Alexz said:

No wonder Taylor appeals to the souless so much.

Thanks for streaming. 

[Chris]

Did we not just have a thread like this a while back?

[gatito]

the amount of copium in this thread is reaching unprecedented levels 

britney had NO competition back then, pretty much like taylor is on a league of her own right now

[DevilsRollTheDice]

I think it’s also important to remember the audience for this question. The most dedicated chunk of Taylor’s fanbase is not the demographic of ATRL unlike Gaga and Brit. All things considered, it’s even impressive how widely beloved Taylor is here.
 

All massive peaks, but by every measurable stat it’s clearly Taylor. 

[Trainwreck]

Neither Britney or Gaga were the most successful during their peaks, they were always overshadowed by a bigger album/single/tour. Which artist has Taylor-level of power right now? Adele? Ed Sheeran? I don't think so 

[Wildcat]

 

[Electrasour]

It's the meltdowns over Taylor for me  can't believe there are still people downplaying her success in the year 2023

 

Anyway, Taylor for most impressive peak and Britney for biggest pop culture moment, no doubt 

[wastedpotential]

37 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said:

Gaga stood up for gay rights a decade before YNTCD and she’s not conventionally attractive. 

Good ******* byeeeeee 

 

This is such a wild thing to say about an artist you STAN to excuse their middling success

 

It's giving Bradley improvising that Gaga was ugly in the bathtub scene 

 

 

[RideOrDie]

13 minutes ago, Chris said:

Did we not just have a thread like this a while back?

this question is asked like every week on here

[charot]

Britney and Gaga - GP/Universal, PEAK Pop Culture, Monoculture/Inescapable

Taylor - Fan Driven, Algorithm/Bubble Era

Edited November 8, 2023 by charot

[CaptainMusic]

Taylor’s is most impressive but Gaga felt the biggest culturally to me, she really was everywhere.

 

I was too young to truly remember Britney’s peak but she didn’t feel as dominant (in the UK).

[panochita]

Taylor, successful tour, movie tour, albums tracks making it to the whole top10 of bb, album opening with a million, etc

[Maleficent]

I kinda want to spank Kelly Clarkson to see if she giggles while it jiggles

[St. Charles]

15 minutes ago, Wildcat said:

 

Mess at the comments there all saying the question was asked many times before as well.

[ThousandMiles]

Taylor / Britney 

[Erreur2 La Nature]

This thread is made every week and the result is never the same, that's hilarious

[By the Water]

Taylor has the album sales, the hit singles, the highest grossing tour of all time, a box office smash, social media engagement, tabloids and even the Halloween costumes. It's time to give it up

[discotitzz]

53 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said:

Gaga stood up for gay rights a decade before YNTCD and she’s not conventionally attractive. 

This is one of the weirder copes I’ve seen 

 

OT: Taylor for both