base talk Rank Their Sophomore Albums: Selena, Ariana, Lorde, Halsey, Doja, Dua, Billie, Olivia

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Rank These Sophomore Albums:

 

Revival

My Everything

Melodrama

hopeless fountain kingdom

Hot Pink
Future Nostalgia

Happier Than Ever

GUTS

[Achilles.]

1. Melodrama

2. Revival

3. Future Nostalgia

4. Happier Than Ever

[Brooklyn Baby]

Melodrama

GUTS

Future Nostalgia

Happier Than Ever

Hot Pink

hopeless fountain kingdom

My Everything

Revival

[Khal]

Melodrama

HTE

Guts

FN

My Everything

Hot Pink

Revival

Halsey

[ScorpiosGroove]

Ultraviolence > all of these combined 

[unclefloprry]

FN
HTE
HFK
Melodrama
Revival
My Everything
Hot Pink
Guts

[Brooklyn Baby]

2 minutes ago, ScorpiosGroove said:

Ultraviolence > all of these combined 

Well that's why she wasn't included. She would demolish 

 

[Post Malone]

GUTS best

Billie worst

[Kyoto]

HTE best

SOUR 2.0 worst

[Kayseri Mantisi]

Melodrama is the best album on this list and it's not even comparable.

 

It's wrong that Future Nostalgia is currently winning. That's an objectively WRONG take. The poll ISN'T asking which album was bigger in charts.

 

[Both Sides Now]

Happier Than Ever

Melodrama

Future Nostalgia 

GUTS

—————

Revival

Hot Pink

hopeless fountain kingdom

My Everything

[selena_lavigne]

1. Revival

2. Future Nostalgia

3. My Everything

4. Melodrama

5. Happier Than Ever (A Year Without Rain)

6. Hot Pink

-------------

7. GUTS

8. Hopeless Fountain Kingdom

Edited November 7, 2023 by selena_lavigne

[Tylerbv]

1. Melodrama

—huge gap—-

2. GUTS

3. happier than ever

 

I could take or leave the rest.

[Alex]

Hot Pink > Future Nostalgia > Melodrama > Happier Than Ever

 

idc about the rest

[zasderfght]

For people listing albums outside the thread, wow, you're so cool for listing an album that's not in this thread. 

 

OT: 

 

I have not listened to hopeless fountain kingdom, but... 

 

1. GUTS 

2. Future Nostalgia

3. Melodrama

4. Happier Than Ever

5. Revival 

6. My Everything 

7. Hot Pink 

[perfillusion]

Oh wow so many good albums and then there’s GUTS  

 

Best: Melodrama

[GentleDance]

Lorde best

Halsey worst

[BlossomSoul]

Worst is EASILY Halsey

[Big Bad Wolf]

A certain blues singer ends these 2dollar hookers….Hot Pink is the best on here though 

[Big Bad Wolf]

2 minutes ago, BlossomSoul said:

Worst is EASILY Halsey

Not too much. 100 Letters is somewhat pop perfection….and I HATE Halsynthesia

[khalyan]

FN is the easy winner, all of the other albums have a noticeable weakness. But Halsey is the definitive worst 

[Cain]

Melodrama, Happier Than Ever, Future Nostalgia and GUTS are the best

 

The other ones can have a mid-off

[rickycabello123]

Romance ended all these mids

[AvadaKedavra]

Melodrama : Havent heard this one but people act like is a masterpiece and i believe them. 
Future Nostalgia : Is like Commercial Music but it has Edge. 

Guts/Happier Than Ever : Could been better. Some good songs and some duds. For all the expectations they didnt live to the hype. 
My Everything By Ariana : Not a big artistic statement but has some bangerz and also some of the R&B flavored tracks are interesting
Revival by Selena Gomez : Not a big artistic statement but has some legit catchy commercial tracks

Halsey Hopelessfountainkingdom : Havent heard this record
Hot Pink By Doja Cat : Havent heard this one

[GraceRandolph]

Best: Future Nostalgia

Worst: Melodrama