poll Better self-titled debut: Madonna vs. Taylor Swift

[differentkindahigh]

1 hour ago, GraceRandolph said:

Gaga was compared to Madonna for years on here and no one said it was unfair. If TS fans want to say she's a legend then compare her to legends.

Exactly, and then Gaga fell off and Madonna remained

Let's not get stupid though. The reason Gaga was compared to Madonna initially was NOT because Gaga's inital success.

Now that this stuff is going on I expect the same thing to happen to Taylor. She has 3-4 years max before she is the new gaga.

Edited November 5, 2023 by differentkindahigh

[stevyy]

6 hours ago, Mr. Mendes said:

Jesus Christ y'all are going insane with this. And I say that as a massive stan of both and have been for years each.

 

Y'all are gonna beat this Madonna vs. Taylor **** to death when it truly is one of the most asinine comparisons that one could make. Just because the two of them are peers sales wise doesn't mean that there's anything to be comparing here really. They are two fundamentally different artists who occupy to fundamentally different spaces within the pop world and it really does a huge disservice to the both of them to constantly attempt to compare the two of them simply because of record sales. 

 

They've both forged massive legacies for themselves and they seem quite happy to coexist with their massive legacies without holding themselves and what they've achieved side by side with each other. Stans need to start taking that lead. 

They are peers sales wise?

 

how? Madonna has sold more than 200 million albums. Taylor has sold 60-70 million. 

[Lover]

[fa77ot]

madonna, sweetie