poll Better self-titled debut: Madonna vs. Taylor Swift

[Wonderland]

2 of the most powerful women in pop music, who each had groundbreaking self-titled debut albums.

 

But which in your opinion has the edge?

 

Edited November 5, 2023 by Wonderland

[Mr. Mendes]

Jesus Christ y'all are going insane with this. And I say that as a massive stan of both and have been for years each.

 

Y'all are gonna beat this Madonna vs. Taylor **** to death when it truly is one of the most asinine comparisons that one could make. Just because the two of them are peers sales wise doesn't mean that there's anything to be comparing here really. They are two fundamentally different artists who occupy to fundamentally different spaces within the pop world and it really does a huge disservice to the both of them to constantly attempt to compare the two of them simply because of record sales. 

 

They've both forged massive legacies for themselves and they seem quite happy to coexist with their massive legacies without holding themselves and what they've achieved side by side with each other. Stans need to start taking that lead. 

Edited November 5, 2023 by Mr. Mendes

[sasashite]

Only one has the iconic line "Go and tell your friends that I'm obsessive and crazy, that's fine I'll tell mine you're gay"

[naval23]

Holiday alone sweetie

 

Teardrops could never

[tiagol88]

5 minutes ago, Mr. Mendes said:

Jesus Christ y'all are going insane with this. And I say that as a massive stan of both and have been for years each.

 

Y'all are gonna beat this Madonna vs. Taylor **** to death when it truly is one of the most asinine comparisons that one could make. Just because the two of them are peers sales wise doesn't mean that there's anything to be comparing here really. They are two fundamentally different artists who occupy to fundamentally different spaces within the pop world and it really does a huge disservice to the both of them to constantly attempt to compare the two of them simply because of record sales. 

 

They've both forged massive legacies for themselves and they seem quite happy to coexist with their massive legacies without holding themselves and what they've achieved side by side with each other. Stans need to start taking that lead. 

So madonna or taylor?

[Gladiator]

They both are generally subpar albums, though I hope the TS TV improves on that. Her vocals are the weak point for me; songwriting is obviously better than Madonna's, but Madonna's album as a whole I would say edges over it.

Edited November 5, 2023 by Gladiator

[Leppie]

 

[Jooj]

Physical Attraction is better than any Taylor Swift (artist) song 

[Gorjesspazze9]

Lucky Star & Holiday>>>>>>>

[Homebrand]

Borderline is better than the entirety of the other album 

[Year of Shadow]

The one that stans actually care about. 

Edited November 5, 2023 by Hey Dude

[Shimenawa]

Madonno!

[differentkindahigh]

"Following the release of the album, Madonna was dismissed by some critics. They called her voice sounding as "Minnie Mouse on helium", while the other detractors suggested that she was "almost entirely helium, a gas-filled, lighter-than-air creation of MTV and other sinister media packagers."[119] Madonna said: "From the very beginning of my career, people have been writing **** about me and saying, 'She's a one-hit wonder, she'll disappear after a year'."[120]

 

She responded to the comment "Minnie Mouse on helium" by doing a photoshoot with Alberto Tolot, where she flirted with a giant Mickey Mouse toy, putting its hand inside her dress and looking at it with an admonishing glare. Author Debbi Voller noted that "such provocative imagery at a young age of her career, could have hurt her too much. But it went on to shut those twerps who dared to take a swag at her voice again."[121] "

[Treason]

Madonna sweetie. Let's stop these setups

[thequeenofpopmadonna]

Swifties have nothing to do all day??? much bored?

Stop bringing madonna to make your idol look good.

It won't get you there. Period. 

What has madonna done wrong to you Or your idol anyway? 

Paving the way and innovating the industry for your idol?

Edited November 5, 2023 by thequeenofpopmadonna

[Punky Rooster]

Why the Madonna v Taylor thing? They are completely different, from different eras and aren't peers in any sense of the word other than being female. Madonna is 30 years older, Taylor is music for high school girls and newly separated single mothers who like white wine on a Sunday, I don't know a lot of her material? Madonna ruled the physical era, Taylor rules the streaming era, so that's not even a comparison. 

 

Pit Taylor against Shania Twain or Faith Hill?, that would at least make some sense.

 

In saying that, the album that has Think of Me on it wins.

[adylovestaylorandjb]

Teardrops on my guitar is alone better than that album. Tv will promote this album to global audience which it always deserved

[thequeenofpopmadonna]

dont get mad because madonna is the pop queen and yours wont ever.

[BANKS]

it’s getting scary…..

[FreeXone]

This is getting weird but clearly  Madonna that album has ICONIC HITS 

[Støned]

I respect Madonna, but Taylor Swift (the album) made me discover a lot of hidden gems in the country genre as a teen, so my vote goes to Taylor.

 

Madonna (self titled) is legendary tho.

[GraceRandolph]

5 hours ago, Mr. Mendes said:

Jesus Christ y'all are going insane with this. And I say that as a massive stan of both and have been for years each.

 

Y'all are gonna beat this Madonna vs. Taylor **** to death when it truly is one of the most asinine comparisons that one could make. Just because the two of them are peers sales wise doesn't mean that there's anything to be comparing here really. They are two fundamentally different artists who occupy to fundamentally different spaces within the pop world and it really does a huge disservice to the both of them to constantly attempt to compare the two of them simply because of record sales. 

 

They've both forged massive legacies for themselves and they seem quite happy to coexist with their massive legacies without holding themselves and what they've achieved side by side with each other. Stans need to start taking that lead. 

Gaga was compared to Madonna for years on here and no one said it was unfair. If TS fans want to say she's a legend then compare her to legends.

[GlamSlam]

The one with memorable songs (and song titles)

 

Holiday

Borderline

Lucky Star

Burning Up

Everybody

[Raptus]

6 hours ago, Wonderland said:

 

Madonna having better cover without photoshop existence in 1983

Edited November 5, 2023 by Raptus

[needs]

Are we for ******* real