base talk Do Sabrina Carpenter and Tate McRae have what it takes to become Superstars?

[AvadaKedavra]

People been suggestin both, as the Newcomers with the Bigger Chances of Stardom.
What are your thoughts? Do they have WHAT it takes to be MAIN POP GIRLS
or are Atrlers-Popstans highly desilusional?




Theyre also suggestin
PinkPantheress / Chapell Ronan / Doechii / Maisie Peters / Holly Humberstone / Renee Rapp / Faouzia / Victoria Monet / Madison Beer.....
as the next "It Girls"












 

Edited October 11, 2023 by AvadaKedavra

[magazine]

One is not like the other!

[Power love]

Sabrina for sure has more potential than ever before. I think her next era is going to go well for sure if she plays her cards right. 

[Saintlor]

No, but they're the best out of the new generation of non-A list singers

 

They have gems but there's nothing special about them

Edited October 11, 2023 by Saintlor

[Selegend]

Tate has more than Sabrina. Her persona feels more unique than Sabrina's. 

 

i LOVE sabrina tho and e-mails was one of my most played album those past 2 years. 

[CandleGuy]

Tate could become a MPG if she nails the follow ups to Greedy.

 

The rest of them, no chance.

[JoJo]

Sabrina has the fanbase and is the most recognizable one here, so I think she has the best path to MPG status.

 

Tate’s Greedy is about to become a smash, but the GP doesn’t know her at all. Maybe that’ll change.

 

I’m rooting for Chappell Roan the most. Her music is so good and refreshing.

[Angelo]

If they have what it takes…it should have happen years ago during their debut. Not everyone can be Madonna, Britney, Gaga, Beyonce, Taylor and now Olivia. 

[KBax]

I feel like Tate could be MPG if she plays her cards right. Greedy was a step in the right direction, so hopefully the album can serve some sexy bops. She can sing and she can dance, she has it. Now show us what you got miss Mcrae!

[KatyPrismSpirit]

Tate does

Sabrina doesn't, she comes across desperate and has like what? 7 albums already... lmao

[AvadaKedavra]

Thanks for your comments sugar cubes 

I like Sabrina but like you all say she has like 4-5 albums and she's still struggling  I love her cause she's very classy and sophisticated But i wonder....Is not the blonde cute lady spot taken by Taylor Swift?

Tate Mcrae. The only problem i have with her is her voice. Feels very camila esque and not distinctive enough.
Also....what is her style? Whats her persona? Is Tate filling any niche?

Here some observations With the others:

PinkPantheress.  Im rooting for her the most but i wonder if her cutesy voice has commercial viability.  
ChapellRonan : She's LGBTI and i think is very hard for lesbian artists to smash today. Dont have big hopes for her. The GP is homophobic. Catchy Music
Doechi looks iconic but her stage name is weak
Maisie Peters : It is me or She looks like Katy Perry sometimes????
Holly Humberstone : Stage name is too long



Yes ATRL is desilusional 

Edited October 11, 2023 by AvadaKedavra

[Antikythera]

no, but the bar is so low they might become stars just because there are no more born popstars out there

[AvadaKedavra]

8 minutes ago, Antikythera said:

no, but the bar is so low they might become stars just because there are no more born popstars out there

Billie, Olivia, Dua,Doja Cat,SZA and Ice Spice are shaking on their boots with these newcomers 

[sourprint]

i love tate maybe renee ? can achieve success too next yr but idk she feels niche to a certain public

 

not rly certain bout sabrina

[Bussea]

never heard of tate but no to sabrina. she’s so boring 

[wantedyoutogrow]

not every artist is meant to be a superstar and that is okay

[Antikythera]

1 hour ago, AvadaKedavra said:

Billie, Olivia, Dua,Doja Cat,SZA and Ice Spice are shaking on their boots with these newcomers 

none of those are real popstar, none of them can dance, none can perform... they are from that time when everyone wants to be conceptual and deep = lazy everything else.

[Georgette]

Sabrina for sure. She has the looks ,talent ,team , growing fanbase and popularity to be the next MPG. I feel she is just one smash hit away from becoming a MPG

 

 As for Tate,there is still a lot more to be done. Greedy doing well isn't enough 

 

Some other girls ,I'm on the look out for are Pinkpanthress and Tyla

Edited October 11, 2023 by Georgette

[Maroonx]

Any of them can make it with a good PR team and label behind them. x

 

[glitch]

Idk why people keep trotting out the same "Sabrina still hasn't made it after 5 albums" excuse when her last album was her biggest. And her tour was pretty successful too. Not everyone smashes out the gate and she's established a fanbase.

 

Tate could take off, it all depends on how she follows up this song.

[Power love]

2 hours ago, Angelo said:

it should have happen years ago during their debut. Not everyone can be Madonna, Britney, Gaga, Beyonce, Taylor and now Olivia. 

Huh, Doja, Rihanna and Pink all didn’t smash hard on their first eras yet all 3 are bigger than half the list you mentioned.

[Power love]

10 minutes ago, glitch said:

Idk why people keep trotting out the same "Sabrina still hasn't made it after 5 albums" excuse when her last album was her biggest. And her tour was pretty successful too

[@michael]

No

[vale9001]

6 minutes ago, Power love said:

Huh, Doja, Rihanna and Pink all didn’t smash hard on their first eras yet all 3 are bigger than half the list you mentioned.

Uh?

Pink First pop album Is her bigger album probably. It's true Rihanna really exploded just with her 3rd album, but First two albums already had at least 2-3 bigger hits than Sabrina Carpenter ever had, and that was 2005-2007 so basically her third album came in the first 2 years of her career.

Edited October 11, 2023 by vale9001

[Bosque]

Tate McRae is way, way bigger than Sabrina Carpenter. Once again, Atrl is fanatically out of touch. I still don't think she's MPG material though