poll No One vs. If I Aint Got You: better alicia classic?

[Asscatchem]

which one is the better classic by Alicia Keys?

[rebeltwat]

Please

[HappierJealousy]

I still hear IIAGY frequently in my country, especially on TV talent show.

Meanwhile No one is completely forgotten can’t believe it’s among the top 100 biggest hits in Billboard history

It should be Fallin VS IIAGY here

Edited October 11, 2023 by HappierJealousy

[Nightingale]

No One for me personally

[naval23]

No One easily but groupthink will say "If I Ain't Got You"

 

The "oh oh ohs" at the end are just 

[Likingstars]

Girl, the piano riff on IIAGY alone >>>>>

[JoeAg]

the one that isn’t a horrible dated mess/arguably the worst pop hit single of the aughts

 

so If I Ain’t Got You, which is actually good 

[Matthew4815]

If I Ain't Got You by far 

[Yoko]

both are aggravating asf her hits always have the tendency to sound like that. i’ll give the edge to No One since i’ve heard it far less. 

[50thStateofMind]

If I Ain't Got You by 1000000000000 miles

[every1blinks]

No One. Culture bent, shifted, reset, etc

[Galaxy]

I'll take these two instead

 

 

[Devin]

Both are great but If I Ain’t Got You >>>>

[Mania]

If I Ain't Got You, I haven’t listened to No One in years.

[Soda Pop Queen]

12 minutes ago, Yoko said:

both are aggravating asf her hits always have the tendency to sound like that. i’ll give the edge to No One since i’ve heard it far less. 

it's probably due to her screeching and howling lol I picked If I Ain't Got You because her voice sounded less wear and tear. By the time her 3rd album came out with No One, she had howled her voice out so it sounded peculiarly hollow. Also, I liked the music was better in her first few years.

Edited October 11, 2023 by Soda Pop Queen

[Taste of Honey]

If I Ain't Got You. No One was played SO much back when it came out in 2008.

[jakeisphat]

IIAGY and it isn’t close 

[JonginBey]

If I Ain’t Got You is the correct answer.

[loveisdead9582]

IIAGY and it’s not close. No One’s vocals killed it for me. It’s a cute song but the delivery just didn’t do it. 

[EriKills]

No One is better by FAR

[*.Digambar.*]

No one is one of her worst songs. If I ain't got you by farrrr

[Valance]

3 hours ago, Galaxy said:

I'll take these two instead

 

 

This. TEOF is her artistic peak

[I54X]

If I ain't got you is a once in a lifetime song. Truly her best song ever. 

[Power love]

I had to YouTube what (No one) sounded like. 
 

If i ain’t got you i didn’t have to do that! 

[Darius]

If I Ain't Got You