base talk Better discography - Lady Gaga or Miley Cyrus?

[yeezytaughtme]

 

 

 

[Xtianlofbritney]

Miley

[KatyPrismSpirit]

The Fame Monster alone is better than Miley's entire catalog.

[Maroonx]

Gaga for Discography/timeless

Miley for Covers

 

Both are amazing though, I was torn.

[Blue Rose]

rating by projects in the OP, Gaga is 3/9 while Miley is 6/9

but I think I prefer Gaga overall 

[Danes]

Lady Gaga's is better overall.

[Gladiator]

how come album covers are always asked about in polls like this? what does that really matter? just wondering.

 

anyway, I think Gaga has a stronger, more timeless discography overall.

[shoganai]

Go find a job

[yeezytaughtme]

13 minutes ago, shoganai said:

Go find a job

I have a steady 10-12 hour daily job, how about you find one you broke, hoeless virgin

[Power love]

20 minutes ago, shoganai said:

Go find a job

 

6 minutes ago, yeezytaughtme said:

I have a steady 10-12 hour daily job, how about you find one you broke, hoeless virgin

[magazine]

Gaga

Both mommas are legends and better than all of your faves 

[Selegend]

Gaga albums are WAY better. With all due respect to Cyrus that is a legend as an ex disney act but her only album that comes close to anything Gaga is Plastic Hearts, Gaga's album are on a whole other level. The Fame, Fame Monster, Born This Way. And even Gaga's worsts like Joanne and Chromatica only loses to Plastic Hearts, they're better than all of the others Cyrus albums. 

 

Voted for Miley on album covers tho, i've never noticed how fresh most of them still look. 

[Diesel is Desire]

Miley sweetie

[Big Bad Wolf]

Overall for their legacies in music alone, it's Gaga. 

 

But if we're being for real, Dead Petz is better than anything Gaga has put out. Musically, it's far more superior and brilliant than Gaga's highs even Born This Way. It's truly a magnificent album.

[Marry The Gods]

Lady Gaga for all. 

[Kimi]

tfm is a masterpiece and alone better than mileys entire discography.

[mons†er]

Gaga has a better discography and her music is truly timeless. she showcases more range and excels in each genre.

However, Miley has Bangerz and Plastic Hearts which are both better than all of Gaga's discography except TFM. 

Miley's covers have also gotten better over time while gaga's has gotten worse and worser.

[Kayseri Mantisi]

Miley for all.

[Janet]

5 minutes ago, mons†er said:

Gaga has a better discography and her music is truly timeless. she showcases more range and excels in each genre.

However, Miley has Bangerz and Plastic Hearts which are both better than all of Gaga's discography except TFM. 

Miley's covers have also gotten better over time while gaga's has gotten worse and worser.

Bangers… better than Born This Way? Umm

[shoganai]

1 hour ago, yeezytaughtme said:

I have a steady 10-12 hour daily job, how about you find one you broke, hoeless virgin

Doing stupid posts on atrl daily doesn’t count as job, sorry

[mons†er]

5 minutes ago, Janet said:

Bangers… better than Born This Way? Umm

BTW has a lot of filler for me. I also don't think the music is as strong as it is on BANGERZ.

[wish]

Gaga had a masterpiece in the beginning of her career but her albums really fell off after 2013.
 

Miley’s music has remained adventurous & exciting for a much longer time. Longevity >>>

[Somnambulist]

In what universe are Mileys album covers better than Gagas? The Fame Monster and Chromatica alone   I always loved the BTW and ARTPOP covers too, though I know they're controversial. 

Miley has really grown on me over the years, and I truly think her later years will have better material than her prime young pop material- she's really matured as an artist in my opinion.

That being said, right now Gaga easily.

[Erreur2 La Nature]

To me Lady Gaga has higher highs and lower lows. Each album is worse than the previous one, while Miley keeps getting better with time in my opinion.

[Kayseri Mantisi]

7 minutes ago, wish said:

Gaga had a masterpiece in the beginning of her career but her albums really fell off after 2013.
 

Miley’s music has remained adventurous & exciting for a much longer time. Longevity >>>

So true. 

 

And I feel like Miley can do all of Gaga's albums (a better version of them actually) but Gaga can never do an album that sounds like Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz for example.