base talk Best album between Katy Perry and Lady Gaga?

[yeezytaughtme]

 

 

vs.

 

 

Edited September 18, 2023 by yeezytaughtme

[Devin]

Best: The Fame Monster and Teenage Dream

[yeezytaughtme]

1 minute ago, Devin said:

Best: The Fame Monster and Teenage Dream

Devin what's upp

 

 

 

[Aqua]

Best: Born This Way

Worst: Smile

Best overall: Gaga

[Sheep]

BTW>TD=TFM>>>>>>>the rest

Prism is my least favorite album out of these(it has some great tracks tho still)

 

They both deliver pretty consistent qualitea but I voted for Gaga overall.

[Tylerbv]

Gonna get flack but my fave is Joanne, followed by Prism, and then Chromatica  

[Gladiator]

Gaga has the better discography. Born This Way is the best, but ARTPOP for me is the worst.

 

Born This Way > Teenage Dream > Joanne > Chromatica > The Fame Monster > Prism > One of the Boys > Smile > Witness > The Fame > ARTPOP

Edited September 18, 2023 by Gladiator

[kimberly]

Best: Teenage Dream

Worst: Witness

Overall: Gaga

[PMKARDASHIAN]

Best: TFM

Worst: Joanne

Overall: Katy 

[Eternium]

There’s never been a more clear top 4 (TFM, TF, BTW and TD) so I have to say, I’m shocked at some of your lists.  

[Roberto]

Gaga's worst album is better than Katy's best one, so, literally, no competition here. 

[4Real]

Katy still hasn't put out a great album yet sadly.

 

Best: Born this way

Worst: Artpop

[zasderfght]

Best: The Fame Monster... by a landslide

Worst: Smile... by a landslide

[Summerboy95]

Best: BTW

Worst: Smile

Overall: Gaga by miles

[OreGuy]

Best: Born This Way

Worse: Smile (soooo uninspired)

Overall: Gaga

[Homebrand]

Katy's albums overall are actually better and more consistent for me. 

[naval23]

When an album has Poker Face, Just Dance, Eh Eh and Paparazzi alone, it just sets the bar so high 

 

 

[BGKC]

Best album: BTW

Worst: Smile 

Beat overall: Gaga

[Winged]

Lady Gaga has only one listenable album 

 

Katy by default 

[Bears01]

The best album isn’t listed as an option and that’s A Star Is Born

 

ASIB>>>>>>>>>>>Katys discography>the rest of Gagas work 

[blown away]

The Fame Monster > Teenage Dream > Born This Way > Chromatica > The Fame > Prism > Joanne > Witness > One Of The Boys > ARTPOP > Smile

[Alldeezy]

The Fame Monster/The Fame > PRISM > Teenage Dream > Born This Way > Chromatica > ARTPOP > One Of The Boys > Witness > Smile > Joanne 

[eli's_rhythm]

Born This Way > The Fame > TFM > Teenage Dream > ARTPOP > Prism > OOTB > Smile > Chromatica > Witness > Joanne

 

Overall it’s Gaga, but not by a landslide.

[ohwow]

i love the way born this way became recognized as gaga's best work, because it actually is

like there's about 10 great or solid pop songs on it, which is a lot

[superben]

Best : Teenage Dream

Worst: Smile