poll better sophomore album: guts vs. melodrama

[80x100]

[Eclass]

Melodrama for all

[Axelios]

Melodrama for all. But Melodrama is one the best albums of its decade in general.

[whitehotforever]

olivia, sweetie

[Jotham]

Melodrama for all but GUTS is still a solid album.

[flower moon]

melodrama is million times more creative and interesting than anything olivia aburrido will ever push out

[Kayseri Mantisi]

Melodrama is album of the life. GUTS is album of the week or month maybe. Not even comparable.

[BlackoutZone]

Someone really voted for Guts being lyrically better

[WitnessOblivia]

GUTS is cute, but Melodrama is amazing.

[ks_dollar]

Melodrama sweaty 

 

 

 

Melodrama is the only album I've ever  bought a vinyl record for, and I don't even own a vinyl player

 

Melodrama is that good

[greento]

The set up 

[Kiss It Better]

melodrama sweetie

[truthteller]

melodrama is a strong 8 to 9 while guts is a 7 to 8 kinda girl

Edited September 8, 2023 by truthteller

[Sabrina Carpenter]

comparing that to Melodrama is insulting 

[Freakshowvato]

Is this even a comparison hahaha… Melodrama is a mature masterpiece. Guts is a fun angsty teen project

[KatyPrismSpirit]

both are milestone records. melodrama wins by a slight margin but GUTS is amazing too. GUTS is the best album since folklore.  

[Kanes]

The one with The Louvre.

[mypaintoyou]

Melodrama sweetie I’m so sorry they doing you like this 

[Folklore89sm]

Melodrama is definitely overrated but I think it’s slightly better than Guts (for now at least). I’m really pleasantly surprised with Guts though, it’s a lot better than Sour.

[*.Digambar.*]

Melodrama is better especially lyrically. Lorde is far far ahead in that aspect. 

[BussC,XOXO]

the set up