PoisonedIvy Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 4 minutes ago, fentypark said: is that why TIWYCF whooped taylor’s ass when she tried to sing it? Sure is Let it all out baby girl It won’t make Rihanna a good vocalist but you can vent as long as you need to 1
burninredhot Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 (edited) 1 hour ago, Miley Cyrus said: Omg the songwriting narrative surrounding her is extremely forced and exaggerated. Her fans took that narrative and ran 1 million miles with it lol. Like it’s so exhausting to see. Shake It Off Me! Ready For It Need to calm down Like this is y’all’s songwriting fave..? If you think Taylor shouldn't be appreciated cuz she has a handful of duds in her discography then ig it's time we all unstan our favs cuz none of their discographies is perfect from A to Z Edited September 1, 2023 by burninredhot
fentypark Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 20 minutes ago, Redstreak said: That doesn’t even make sense as a response 💀 you know albums, the main thing a musician has, are not live vocals right? but the vocals coming from their throat have to be recorded and the ability of said vocals limits what can be done with them… hence the lack of vocal complexity and texturing in her music… idk what’s not clicking
fentypark Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 5 minutes ago, WeFoundTrouble said: Sure is good to see swifties can occasionally not be delusional
EmailMySwift Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 8 minutes ago, Sonny said: It’s her pathetic fanbase and the praise while she’s doing the bare minimum. Bare minimum? Writing songs, recording music, doing music videos, and performing every night for damn near 3 hours is doing the bare minimum while being on your 10th album? What else is she supposed to do, shoot herself out of a rocket? Or is this about not wearing a deli as a dress or writhing with a tranquilzed snake?
Taylor fanboy Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 Something in the wind shifted during the middle of 1989. reputation fixed that immensely and impeccably… but something happened in the spring of 2019, and then it went from worse to Worser that summer of the same year. I guess THAT!
Enrique523 Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 1 hour ago, burninredhot said: If you think Taylor shouldn't be appreciated cuz she has a handful of duds in her discography then ig it's time we all unstan our favs cuz none of their discographies is perfect from A to Z Right? To specifically use a couple of meh songs from her discography and ignoring all the rest is such blatant bad faith. Taylor is a great songwriter and only OTHs are pretending otherwise.
Komet Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 Not this turning into a Tay vs Rih vocals-off, I think I've truly seen everything now Although I have to give that to my girl Rih; what she lacks in range and control, she makes up for in vocal color and overall charisma.
Enrique523 Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 1 hour ago, EmailMySwift said: Bare minimum? Writing songs, recording music, doing music videos, and performing every night for damn near 3 hours is doing the bare minimum while being on your 10th album? What else is she supposed to do, shoot herself out of a rocket? Or is this about not wearing a deli as a dress or writhing with a tranquilzed snake? Right?? Taylor is literally the hardest working pop girl out there, there's no competition.
LOTF Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 55 minutes ago, istan4badgalriri said: omg you guys are literally brainwashed I know, right? It's so scary lmfao
lonnie Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 36 minutes ago, greento said: rihtired stans really got nowhere else to be other than in Taylor's threads Literally every fanbase is commenting 33 minutes ago, WeFoundTrouble said: Rihanna is right down here in the C Tier with Taylor and Katy. Both Rih and Katy are better singers than Taylor, as is pretty much everyone else that isn't Selena Gomez, y'all need to let this go.
Taylor fanboy Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 Just now, Komet blu said: Not this turning into a Tay vs Rih vocals-off, I think I've truly seen everything now Although I have to give that to my girl Rih; what she lacks in range and control, she makes up for in vocal color and overall charisma. What do you mean with Rihanna’s Vocal Color sis? Is that synesthesia that you have? 1
lonnie Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 Literally every fanbase says something in this thread but somehow it's the one navy member that sets things off for swifties 1
Sonny Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 8 minutes ago, EmailMySwift said: Bare minimum? Writing songs, recording music, doing music videos, and performing every night for damn near 3 hours is doing the bare minimum while being on your 10th album? What else is she supposed to do, shoot herself out of a rocket? Or is this about not wearing a deli as a dress or writhing with a tranquilzed snake? Pleaaaaase, her lyrics and music are very basic, her music videos are all her posing in front of a green screen and all she does is strut around a stage for 3 hours with mediocre/bad vocals. 1 1
airplane Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 35 minutes ago, WeFoundTrouble said: Don’t get them started they’re gonna post the Love on the Brain performance they’ve been holding onto for nearly a decade. Rihanna has several widely praised vocal performances available on youtube while your fave has none. 1
Komet Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 2 minutes ago, Taylor fanboy said: What do you mean with Rihanna’s Vocal Color sis? Is that synesthesia that you have? https://www.dummies.com/article/academics-the-arts/music/voice/defining-tone-in-singing-179050/ 1 1
lonnie Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 (edited) 5 minutes ago, Komet blu said: https://www.dummies.com/article/academics-the-arts/music/voice/defining-tone-in-singing-179050/ Not dummies.com OT: This thread remains a grand exaggeration. Taylor is mostly inoffensive and so whatever hate she's gotten is nothing compared to what others (Madonna, Janet, Britney, Rih, Bey etc) got. The most criticism she's gotten is for being an ecoterrorist, nazis and alt-right members using her for symbolic purposes while she remained quiet, and her dullness and overall plainness. Most of it is not bad nor as ugly as it has been for others. Like what is this massive hate the girl gets when she pretty much has the public, critics, various awards committees at the palm of her hand? Edited September 1, 2023 by lonnie
Redstreak Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 20 minutes ago, fentypark said: but the vocals coming from their throat have to be recorded and the ability of said vocals limits what can be done with them… hence the lack of vocal complexity and texturing in her music… idk what’s not clicking Because you’re not explaining why anyone should care 💀
airplane Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 (edited) 26 minutes ago, WeFoundTrouble said: Sure is Let it all out baby girl It won’t make Rihanna a good vocalist but you can vent as long as you need to And Taylor Swift will continue to remain a mediocre and monotone excuse of a “singer” who will continue to serve nothing but blandness and mediocrity along with her tragically embarrassing stiff dances Rihanna destroys her in the performance department while Taylor has to conceal her lack of talent with props and gimmicks Edited September 1, 2023 by airplane
PoisonedIvy Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 4 minutes ago, lonnie said: Literally every fanbase is commenting Both Rih and Katy are better singers than Taylor, as is pretty much everyone else that isn't Selena Gomez, y'all need to let this go. 2 minutes ago, airplane said: Rihanna has several widely praised vocal performances available on youtube while your fave has none. Rihanna can be better than Taylor all day long if y’all want but that still doesn’t lift her out of the C Tier right beside Taylor. The distinction between: Taylor > Rih > Katy > Britney > JLo > Selena versus Rih > Taylor > Katy > Britney > Jlo > Selena is irrelevant. They all are weak vocalists and I’m not about to sit here and split hairs over women whose primary talents are not their vocal performances. It is a waste of my time and yours.
PoisonedIvy Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 (edited) 4 minutes ago, airplane said: And Taylor Swift will continue to remain a mediocre and monotone excuse of a “singer” who will continue to serve nothing but blandness and mediocrity along with her tragically embarrassing stiff dance moves Must eat you up inside to watch her succeed in spite of this being your opinion of her Keep the fumes coming, her “stiff dance moves and mediocre vocals” aren’t going anywhere since enough people find them enjoyable enough to have continued to see her on tour since 2010+ in droves the likes of which your fav will never see due to her unprofessionalism and terrible touring reputation Edited September 1, 2023 by WeFoundTrouble
burninredhot Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 12 minutes ago, lonnie said: Literally every fanbase says something in this thread but somehow it's the one navy member that sets things off for swifties Probably cuz one of yall always ends up in these threads talking about how she "can't sing" and obviously seeing the girl in their icon swifties can't tolerate the lack of self awareness and reply
unclefloprry Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 Her stans as we can see in this thread. 3
lonnie Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 Just now, WeFoundTrouble said: Rihanna can be better than Taylor all day long She is. Why are y'all so upset about accepting this? It really shouldn't be a big deal, especially since Taylor stans firmly believe and stan her writing abilities. So what does accepting that Rihanna is a better singer cost y'all? 2 minutes ago, WeFoundTrouble said: but that still doesn’t lift her out of the C Tier right beside Taylor. The distinction between: Taylor > Rih > Katy > Britney > JLo > Selena versus Rih > Taylor > Katy > Britney > Jlo > Selena is irrelevant. They all are weak vocalists and I’m not about to sit here and split hairs over women whose primary talents are not their vocal performances. It is a waste of my time and yours. And these tiers aren't real. Jazmine Sullivan and Adele aren't in the same "tier". The capabilities, strengths and weaknesses of the singers you have listed are not the same. Rihanna does have issues with breath control and her upper register, but she's certainly a better singer than Taylor and Selena. There's no splitting hairs about it, nor should it even be a topic of discussion. Taylor is a bad singer, she's an awful dancer, and overall lackluster performer. While Rihanna isn't necessarily the best vocalist, she certainly has more strengths as a singer and performer than Taylor and that's okay to admit. You don't have to lump her in an imaginary tier to justify any of this.
lonnie Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 2 minutes ago, burninredhot said: Probably cuz one of yall always ends up in these threads talking about how she "can't sing" and obviously seeing the girl in their icon swifties can't tolerate the lack of self awareness and reply Go through this thread (or other Taylor related threads) and you'll literally find members of various fanbases/stans of multiple artists. Not that I mind tussling with swifties, but it's very obvious that y'all are more upset with Rih stans making comments about Taylor than you are about anyone else
Recommended Posts