poll Confessions vs American Life

[poki]

Hey. Which do you prefer?

[poki]

This one alone outsold

 

 

[Sheep]

Both albums are praiseworthy so why would set American Life up like this. 

[Tropical]

As Madonna so wisely sang in the American Life title track, "F*ck it."

 

COADF is cute but American Life is far more cohesive and introspective. It's a more interesting album from Madonna artistically, but I am comparing two godly A-Tier albums here that artists like Taylor and Rih will never touch.

[Big Bad Wolf]

Confessions. Hate AL. Get Together alone

[Elusive Chanteuse]

Confessions by far 

[Reverse Warholian]

AL is underrated but Confessions >>>

[Katamari]

sorry alone kind of clears tbh

[nostalgic]

I would take Die Another Day over the entirety of COADF but it's still the better album - bop after bop after bop. 

[1989]

American Life by far. AL is in Madonna’s top five albums, meanwhile COADF has always been one of her most overrated albums. 

[Holiest Dreams]

American Life has higher highs (Nothing Fails, Xstatic Process, Easy Ride, Love Profusion) but COADF is much better as a whole project.

[brooklyndaddy]

I prefer American Life as a whole. The production is so cool and I love the themes she explores. I understand how it rubs people the wrong way both sonically and thematically but I love it. The glitchy weirdness but pop conviction of songs like Hollywood and I’m So Stupid are so unique while I feel other artist can pull off Hung Up and Sorry (although they are absolute bangers) 

[xxxlamb]

42 minutes ago, Tropical said:

As Madonna so wisely sang in the American Life title track, "F*ck it."

 

COADF is cute but American Life is far more cohesive and introspective. It's a more interesting album from Madonna artistically, but I am comparing two godly A-Tier albums here that artists like Taylor and Rih will never touch.

like why bring up Rih or Tay...

 

seriously why was this needed?

 

just say your dick is small and keep it moving  

 

[Gorjesspazze9]

Confessions. but American life has some of her best 2000's songs. like Nothing Fails and Love Profusion

[Chris]

American Life.

[smoore95GAGA]

The one that’s listenable 

[Achilles.]

Confessions, but Nothing Fails is better than everything except Hung Up and the two FL tracks. 

[secretgarden]

Confessions is such a boring ass album really only carried by the first three tracks EXTREMELY overrated amongst popper sniffing power bottoms. American Life on the other hand single-handedly took down the entire Bush administration and reinstated global peace on earth! Not bad for a flop album

[Taylor fanboy]

AMERICAN LIFE

[LikeaRebel]

I adore both but AL wins by an inch. 

[Tropical]

2 hours ago, xxxlamb said:

like why bring up Rih or Tay...

 

seriously why was this needed?

 

just say your dick is small and keep it moving  

 

You sound upset. Please stay on topic. 

 

---

 

Obvi COADF was always going to sweep and this thread was a set-up but alas, American Life is GOD TIER.

[Carla Rosón]

Get Together alone washes entire discographies

 

American Life (album) is such an underrated gem though

[blueberries]

confessions

[GlamSlam]

Confessions by far.

[Asparagus Spears]

Obviously American Life. But I also love get together. That track alone is one of her best