base talk Bigger 2nd era: OIDIA vs Fearless vs Like a Virgin

[KillingYourCareer]

I voted for the Britney one for all three.

 

[unclefloprry]

OIDIA

[nostalgic]

Like a Virgin > OIDIA > Fearless 

[40000000000000]

like a virgin was by far bigger, but OIDIA wins in thr singles department thanks to stronger

[SlowGinFizzzz]

59 minutes ago, brenda-walsh said:

Like A Virgin > OIDIA >>>>>>> Fearless

 

[Solaria]

Like a Virgin for all

[Wewee]

Like A Virgin for all  

[HardBambi]

The American wannabes, democrats and republicans alike, have dropped their political and religious beliefs and just wanted to be Madonna during the like a virgin era:

 

 

[Madonno]

Lol

2 diamonds singles against Fearless

The answer is obvious,  Like a Virgin for all

[stevyy]

Madonna and it ain't even close. 

[GreatestLoveofAll]

Well Whitney's Whitney has all three beat so 

 

Better Album: OIDIA is pop perfection to me 

Biggest: LAV for all the records is set and its impact. it also wins best singles too tho love story is taylor's best song

[Eternium]

7 hours ago, holyground13 said:

Oooo this one is actually intruging.

 

All three have great singles runs (and some of my favourite music of all time).

 

OIDIA was probably the biggest on release, as it did so well in it's first week and Britney was everywhere. However, LAV had huge longevity and had huge impact on both the music industry and Madonna's career. And then Fearless was huge as well, and you could say it had the longest longevity with TV but that's technically a separate album / era.

 

Overall, LAV wins for me though.

Honestly, nothing can compare to the longevity of an 80s album thanks to the introduction of multiple new formats (vinyls to cassettes to CDs, etc). Streaming might make it easy, though, if charts don’t start weeding out all of the fake streams and passive listening.

7 hours ago, leyaris11 said:

Thanks, lady gaga fan. 

Such a weak attempt when @Century was objectively correct.

 

Success: LAV > OIDIA > Fearless

Quality: OIDIA > Fearless > LAV

Singles: OIDIA > LAV > Fearless

[Oktober Knight]

You're either delusional or uneducated about musical history if you don't think LAV was the biggest album. 

[blueberries]

fearless aka the one that's remembered today

[Mystic Boy]

26 minutes ago, blueberries said:

fearless aka the one that's remembered today

 

OT: LAV and it's not even close