Cantaloupe. Posted July 5, 2017 Author Posted July 5, 2017 1 minute ago, Fenrir said: I'm the only one that's scored!? Yes.
Golden Hour Posted July 5, 2017 Posted July 5, 2017 5 hours ago, Dom said: OMG, all slay, but that Camilla one - wow :O On 7/2/2017 at 6:38 PM, talent said: love all of these but @Bad Things and @Wonderlust. really hit my aesthetic g spot... go off Thanks girls!
Cantaloupe. Posted July 5, 2017 Author Posted July 5, 2017 1 minute ago, Bad Things said: When's round 3? After round 2.
Golden Hour Posted July 5, 2017 Posted July 5, 2017 1 minute ago, Cantaloupe. said: After round 2. Fair enough
Hurem Posted July 5, 2017 Posted July 5, 2017 Why is it taking longer for judges to score the entries than it does for contestants to make them?
Rian. Posted July 5, 2017 Posted July 5, 2017 4 hours ago, Hurem said: Why is it taking longer for judges to score the entries than it does for contestants to make them? People are busy
Rian. Posted July 5, 2017 Posted July 5, 2017 I did minimal judging this week, I was reeeaaally busy. I saw more things than I wrote down but I think it reflects in my score. If you have any questions about the score pls ask me
Fenrir Posted July 6, 2017 Posted July 6, 2017 1 hour ago, Hurem said: Anything? Just waiting on Melon to post. All judges have submitted.
Cantaloupe. Posted July 6, 2017 Author Posted July 6, 2017 1 minute ago, Fenrir said: Just waiting on Melon to post. All judges have submitted. I just got online.
Cantaloupe. Posted July 6, 2017 Author Posted July 6, 2017 Round 2 ResultsFenrir: Spoiler Bad Things - 8.5/10 - Don't like that you put HAVANA at the top and then on the side too (or the random number in the top left corner nn). Very aesthetically pleasing overall though. Hurem - 7.5/10 - Be One what? I want to love this but there's just something about it I don't like. I think it would've been better if it was a textless cover tbh. Riri - 7.5/10 - I like the aesthetic you were going for. I love the album title and the font. Something about the Nicki pic you chose just doesn't fit right with the whole cover though .. It (or something else) throws the whole cover off for me and makes it look weird. 2 Rih collabs and 1 Bey? I'd be in heaven if that was NM4. Wonderlust - 9/10 - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy teas. I love the color. Kind of want to Google those track names to see what they say. Marn - 8/10 - I actually like this quite a bit. I love the two fonts you chose. I think Now or Never should've been bigger (or at least just as big) than Denis' name on the cover though. talent - 7.5 - I don't get the cover at all. I want to love and appreciate it but I don't get it. Is Mary Florence's alter-ego? Long lost sister? Is one of them "Mary" and the other Florence? Am I overthinking this probably? Down: Spoiler Bad Things: 9/10 YAS BISH, simple but beautiful! That image of Camz (love that it's black and white), that font, but mess at none of her songs getting played on Spotify, flopping already I could've done without the side "Havana" text though. It wasn't needed bew bew. Hurem: 8.5/10 Love the image, don't like the text. Takes away from the cover and makes it look a bit cheap. I wish the blue in her eyes was a bit stronger. Riri: 6.5/10 This is cute bebe, but it would've been stronger if you kept Nicki's natural look in the pic instead of making it pink as well. Not a big fan of the 4 corner shapes either, maybe if they were a bit smaller it could've worked. Loving the tracklist though, #6 sounds like a Grammy winner. Wonderlust: 9.3/10 Bitch, this could've been a FULL slay! But you don' goofed and made the tracks almost transparent and hard to read, that's a NO-NO! Marn: 9.5/10 WOO!! You came outta nowhere and SNATCHED! I personally love this entry! The font, the placement, the picture you chose, and most of all, I LOVE that you included the back cover as well, A SLAY! The only thing I would've done different, was removing the advisory label from the tracklist cover and making the red in "Denis Stoff" brighter and more vibrant! Talent: 8/10 This is so trippy but I live for it, It's so her! I just wish you used a different font for the album title and moved it a bit more to the left. I also can't help but to feel that something is missing...I just can't put my finger on it. It works though, maybe I'm just being picky. Rian: Spoiler Bad Things - 8/10 Love the cover. Reminds me of Dua Lipa A LOT tho. Great entry overall. Hurem - 7.5/10 Great picture. The font kinda ruins it tho. Could've been without font at all tbh. Bey would do that imo. Riri - 4/10 Don't like the name, the cover or anything for that matter tbh. It looks really fan made, like those instagram barbz Like .. Nicki would never do those corner things or that circle. And the pic is also distorted. The tracklist is ... cute. Wonderlust - 8.5/10 A concept Love the cover and the tracklist. Why is it so gray tho? Did you not buy the album? Marn - 8/10 The font is really the only thing I don't like and mainly on the back cover. Love the fact that you even did one! Great work Marn talent - 8/10 I totally get what you were going for. love the idea and the tracklist. LiMe: Spoiler Bad Things - 7/10 - Simple, but nice. I think it could do without the text on the side. Hurem - 7/10 - Solid cover, nice symmetry. I wish the blueness of the water had a tint of green to it though – and also the colouring of the eyes to be more vibrant. Riri - 6/10 - It’s an alright entry, a little cheap though. I think you should focus stripping your designs back a bit, you know the whole less is more concept. I really like the name you chose for the album, though it would have been nice to see the cover reflect that – maybe photoshopping an image Nicki swimming in a pool of pink sugar. Something simple but eye catching, none of this shape border thing you got going on. Wonderlust - 8.5/10 - Different and minimalistic. I’m having trouble critiquing it because it’s just an image, a background and some text, but I feel like this is an aesthetic that the artist you chose would use. So in that sense it’s a fitting design. Marn - 7.5/10 - If you had a simple text running down the black column in the center, this entry would have been a 10/10 tbh. Sadly the font is what ruins it for me, the black border/drop shadows should have been the same colour as the darkest colour in the image, so that it feels cohesive/together – though even then, I would have stayed away from the use of drop shadows/borders. Talent - 7.5/10 - It’s a nice entry, not sure how I feel about the image you chose to incorporate, since it makes her hands look stiff and rather strange when she’s ‘floating’ there. Idk, would have been a great entry if the addition was incorporated more smoothly. This round's scores: Spoiler 1. Wonderlust - 8.83 2. Marn - 8.25 3. Bad Things - 8.13 4. talent - 7.75 5. Hurem - 7.63 6. Riri - 6 Averages: Spoiler 1. Wonderlust - 17.962. Hurem - 15.833. talent - 15.354. Marn - 14.75 5. Riri - 136. Bad Things - 8.13 @Bad Things @Hurem @Riri. @M A R N ✮ @Wonderlust. @talent@Fenrir @DOWN @Rian. @LiMe
talent Posted July 6, 2017 Posted July 6, 2017 cantaloupe did warn me it was a little out there im still ok with my scores though
Wondy Lust Posted July 6, 2017 Posted July 6, 2017 Quote Why is it so gray tho? Did you not buy the album? when the album isn't available in your country and you somehow have the album in your local files (idk how they got there, someone must've left them there by mistake) the tracks will appear grey when you go to the version spotify has (which is the case with most japanese releases that are on spotify but not available to nz). That or they're unreleased, and since i'm having it released in August, I thought it would be logical to grey them out since they're unavailable! Quote Kind of want to Google those track names to see what they say. something something dont do dat Omg, but I loveeeeddddddd Bad Things album, it reminds me of another album cover I love although I don't remember which one and honestly thought they would win this round. It hits me in all the right spots ~ Congrats to everyone tho!
Cantaloupe. Posted July 6, 2017 Author Posted July 6, 2017 13 minutes ago, Wonderlust. said: something something dont do dat Y'all want round 3 now or wait till tomorrow?
Rian. Posted July 6, 2017 Posted July 6, 2017 28 minutes ago, Wonderlust. said: when the album isn't available in your country and you somehow have the album in your local files (idk how they got there, someone must've left them there by mistake) the tracks will appear grey when you go to the version spotify has (which is the case with most japanese releases that are on spotify but not available to nz). That or they're unreleased, and since i'm having it released in August, I thought it would be logical to grey them out since they're unavailable! something something dont do dat Omg, but I loveeeeddddddd Bad Things album, it reminds me of another album cover I love although I don't remember which one and honestly thought they would win this round. It hits me in all the right spots ~ Congrats to everyone tho! It's okay sis, I didn't take off any points for that Maybe it reminds you of this?
Queen. Posted July 6, 2017 Posted July 6, 2017 so what is the next round? because i know i ain't eliminated.
Cantaloupe. Posted July 6, 2017 Author Posted July 6, 2017 10 minutes ago, Riri. said: so what is the next round? because i know i ain't eliminated. There aren't any eliminations.
Recommended Posts