base talk Which SM girl group has the best discography?

[Josh]

f(x)

 

 

Girls' Generation

 

AESPA

 

Red Velvet

 

 

Edited June 14, 2023 by Josh

[playboi]

fx and it’s not even close

[Forever Winter]

Singles - Girls' Generation

Bsides - Red Velvet

[K$Ellie]

aespa by far

[Delirious]

RV and it's not even close.All killer no filler (Except their most recent releaseS)

[Taste of Honey]

My favorite SM groups are Red Velvet, Girls Generation and S.E.S(which, of course, aren’t here.  No shade though.)

[Josh]

2 minutes ago, Taste of Honey said:

My favorite SM groups are Red Velvet, Girls Generation and S.E.S(which, of course, aren’t here.  No shade though.)

I chose the ones that ATRL would most likely recognize most of ATRL wasn't even born during S.E.S's career

[Taste of Honey]

4 minutes ago, Josh said:

I chose the ones that ATRL would most likely recognize most of ATRL wasn't even born during S.E.S's career

I’m well aware of that, hence the no shade part of the comment. 

[illia]

It's a tie between Red Velvet and f(x)

[MonsterNavy]

f(x) > SNSD's title tracks/classics alone and japanese discography > aespa 

[Sweet Sexy Savage]

f(x)’s critical peak is unmatched, but RV’s almost tugged them a bit with Bad Boy + Psycho

[youresotoxic]

Red Velvet of course  their korean AND japanese releases are perfect

Edited June 14, 2023 by youresotoxic

[Nightingale]

Mostly based off of singles since I don’t know most of their albums like that

 

1. SNSD

2. SES

3. Red Velvet

4. aespa

5. f(x)

[johnny_9ss]

there is only one correct answer...

 

 

[Taylena]

 

 

I present this masterpiece.  

 

[Joyride]

Red Velvet

[AxelFox]

Red Velvet has higher highs in terms of singles but overall f(x) >>>>>>
 

Girls generation have some of the worst kpop girl group music, it's almost boy group level and aespa is not a lot better to be fair. 

[Zack]

Red Velvet 

 

[xfreshkidxx]

SNSD > FX 

 

The other 2 are complete garbage. 

[Popboi.]

Red Velvet and then SNSD

[byzantium]

Easily SNSD.  Everyone else is competing for second.

[Sanguine]

f(x) (best discog in K-Pop ever) > Aespa (mostly hits on hits so far) > Red Velvet (overall more good stuff than Aespa because longer discog but they fell off hard this decade) >>>>>>>> SNSD 

Edited June 14, 2023 by Sanguine

[Taylor fanboy]

It’s f(x)

 

4 Walls alone blow out anything else in the water for both girl and boy groups, not just K-Pop.

 

[Antisocialites]

God Velvet ofc

[JonginBey]

Red Velvet is the only correct answer.