base talk Midnights (Taylor) vs Endless Summer Vacation (Miley)

[Josh]

 

Two very mid pop albums neither albums are beloved by ATRL but which do you prefer? 

[Space Cowboy]

Midnights has like 5 good songs at least, while ESV has like 2 

[Rei]

Midnights by far.

 

K bye for now, Sunshine. <3

[Power love]

Miley

[Rev8]

I like mostly everything on ESV

however I also like songs on Midnights..but its downside is that it has too much songs and that gives it fillers naturally

[ImsoLOUD]

Endless Summer Vacation 

[wowsignal14]

how are they even comparable esv has one good song lol 

[luckythisway]

% of songs Downloaded to my Library

 

Midnights: 10/20 = 50%  

ESV: 6/13 = 46% 

 

 

[Life Savers]

ESV is entirely fillers other than Flowers and River.

[Venus XCX]

Midnights 3am edition bonus tracks alone > ESV

[CottageHore]

Both are very boring and forgettable albums. Only one of them is obscenely overrated though. 

[MonsterNavy]

I vibe with ESV more tbh

I have never listened to Midnights past it first 2 weeks

[PoisonedIvy]

Miley doesn’t have a single album better than a Taylor album except Plastic Hearts (better than Lover and Debut) or Dead Petz (better than everything except Speak Now, Red, and folk+more but y’all aren’t ready for that discussion  )

 

I love Miley but ESV is ACTUALLY mid. I do love Jaded, Rose Colored Lenses, Violet Chemistry, Handstand, and Island though  

Edited June 13, 2023 by WeFoundTrouble

[ttsmu]

Flowers alone is way better than Midnights.

 

So Miley>>>>>>

[Taylucifer]

RCL is the only good song on ESV so i choose Midnights

[Sylpher]

Midnight's dream pop and atmospheric pop just doesn't hit as hard as ESV's more rock and dance genre.

[kimberly]

% of songs Downloaded to my Library

 

Midnights: 12/23 = 52%

ESV: 7/12 = 58%

 

also Violet Chemistry kinda clears everything on Midnights.

[Rotunda]

Honestly the only song on Midnights that I need to revisit is YOYOK. There are other songs I like, but that is…a masterpiece.

 

ESV has 4 songs that I think are essentials for me (Rose Coloured Lenses, Thousand Miles, River, You). 
 

I say this as someone who uses Taylor a lot more than I use Miley.

[Don]

Midnights by far

[1989]

Midnights by far. I like Miley, and there’s a couple of good songs on ESV, but it kind of is the epitome of a mid album propped up by those few good songs, it’s a real step back for her in my opinion. Midnights isn’t Taylor’s best album, but 75% of it ranges from incredible to good, there’s really only about three songs I never revisit. 

[Alldeezy]

hmm I like them both, I probably use only 4 songs from both albums, however Violet Chemistry alone makes ESV win. 

[Gladiator]

While Midnights is an album that I could really do without in Taylor's discography, it does have a handful of songs that I enjoy immensely. Meanwhile, I have not listened to Endless Summer Vacation since it was released and probably never will return to it again.

Edited June 13, 2023 by Gladiator

[ugo]

I have not listened to ESV since that leak 

 

 

[Escape]

River alone >

[Maroonx]

They are both great. I would however go with Midnights on this one.