base talk Girl group vocals: BLACKPINK vs (G)I-DLE

[Josh]

BLACKPINK: 

Members:
Jisoo
Jennie

Rosé
Lisa

 

vs

 

(G)I-DLE

Members:
Miyeon
Minnie

Soyeon

Yuqi

Shuhua

Edited June 12, 2023 by Josh

[byzantium]

I love Blackpink, but I feel like most kpop groups have better lead vocalists than Blackpink.  That said, I find jisoo abd rose’s vocals far more interesting so they are better suited for pop music .

[Flower]

Mamamoo and NMIXX ended both.

[GentleEarthquake]

(G)i-dle 

[Subzero]

Love both but out of BP, only Rose & Jennie's voices are pleasant to my ear while GI has 3 vocalists with voices/tones I enjoy, so they I guess they win 

[Taylena]

I don't think you can clearly say one group is better.  If Miyeon were a Blackpink member like she has supposed to then no doubt BP would be better vocally.