base talk Gaga vs Taylor - more talents? ATRL decides

[Solaria]

ATRL decides, who between these ladies has more talents and is more versatile? Let's decide! 

 

Edited June 8, 2023 by Love Again

[wish]

Neither

[Taylucifer]

Gaga

Taylor

Gaga

[halcyonday]

Gaga stomps on everything besides song writing

[Steve Johnson]

I've never seen you making Dua vs ----,more talented, more successful thread. 

Fir this question, Taylor. 

[preyiv]

Gaga for all

[PoisonedIvy]

You are better than this sis  

[Solaria]

Just now, Steve Johnson said:

I've never seen you making Dua vs ----,more talented, more successful thread. 

Fir this question, Taylor. 

Aaah you mad 

 

[Solaria]

Just now, WeFoundTrouble said:

You are better than this sis  

I'm really not actually

 

[halcyonday]

Just now, WeFoundTrouble said:

You are better than this sis  

you're just mad your fave gets stomped on

 

[Nico Robin]

Are you bored sis? Anyways… GTG

[Solaria]

Look at the Gaga stompage already

 

[Jjang]

Gaga has more tricks up her arsenal but Taylor uses her talent much more substantially. I feel like Gaga never reaches the full extent of what she can produce because she’s stuck writing formulated Pop music for the most part. 

[Solaria]

1 minute ago, Jjang said:

Gaga has more tricks up her arsenal but Taylor uses her talent much more substantially. I feel like Gaga never reaches the full extent of what she can produce because she’s stuck writing formulated Pop music for the most part. 

Midnights is formulated pop music to the highest extent, all of the songs sound like AI generated Taylor songs and could have fit on any of her past albums 

 

[Sazare]

Vocals: Lady Gaga

Songwriting: Lady Gaga

Acting: Lady Gaga

Business Acumen: taylor

[Solaria]

1 minute ago, Sazare said:

Vocals: Lady Gaga

Songwriting: Lady Gaga

Acting: Lady Gaga

Business Acumen: taylor

Better eye for visual imagery: Gaga

Performing: Gaga

[Venice B]

Gaga is more talented but her talent doesn't always come through in her works, if that makes sense? Like Joanne and Chromatica are really mid albums, I feel like she has too many ideas and doesn't know how to filter and execute them. Taylor on the other hand is more consistent and knows how to work around her ideas and deliver solid projects.

 

But Gaga is the better vocalist and actress. Is Taylor even an actress though? I don't think that's a fair comparison  

[Taylena]

Both are more talented than artists that rely on playlists and endless payola to promote their mediocre and generic pop songs. 

Edited June 8, 2023 by Taylena

[Klein]

3 minutes ago, Sazare said:

Vocals: Lady Gaga

Songwriting: Lady Gaga

Acting: Lady Gaga

Business Acumen: taylor

Inability to release a good album in 12 years : Lady Gaga 

 

 

[Katamari]

 

13 minutes ago, Steve Johnson said:

I've never seen you making Dua vs ----,more talented, more successful thread. 

Fir this question, Taylor. 

he knows if you put gaga and taylor in a room by themselves they would make an album or two while the same cant be said about dua (love ha tho)

 

 

ot: both very talented American singer-songwriters. gaga picks better singles and has more interesting tour and live performance concepts tho so her  i guess

 

[Solaria]

3 minutes ago, Klein said:

Inability to release a good album in 12 years : Lady Gaga 

 

 

 Chromatica is her most acclaimed album to date and has a Grammy, the people in the music industry said it was a good album

 

Edited June 8, 2023 by Love Again

[MotoPapi]

Taylor for all.

 

Gaga is a jack of all trades, master of none.

[Klein]

1 minute ago, Love Again said:

 Chromatica is her most acclaimed album to date and has a Grammy, the music industry said it was a good album

 

The Grammy is for a song, not an album.

 

So her most acclaimed album to date has the same Metacritic score as Lover? Really puts things into perspective.

 

[Solaria]

1 minute ago, Klein said:

The Grammy is for a song, not an album.

 

So her most acclaimed album to date has the same Metacritic score as Lover? Really puts things into perspective.

 

You’re right, Lover’s score should be 10 points lower actually

 

[Klein]

1 minute ago, Love Again said:

You’re right, Lover’s score should be 10 points lower actually

 

What kind of argument is that? 

 

Chromatica's score should be 13 points lower