Jump to content

ATRL Radio - Round 4 Page 7


Recommended Posts

Posted

Will post results + comments today. If The Color Game critiques are a merry-go-round, then this is a rollercoaster doing loops and 180* turns at 500MPH with no seatbelts 

 

When Ratchet Met Clank . . . Again

  • Replies 214
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • poki

    58

  • fountain

    37

  • prézli

    32

  • Alldeezy

    24

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

RYQrclv.png

 

Hey everyone! R1 results are here!

 

SAFE

 

#3 - Mariah Carey - Emotions by fountain!

SCORE: 8

Emotions (Mariah Carey song) - Wikipedia

SCORES:

9.5

8.5

8 x2

6

COMMENTS:

* Not bad. The whistle notes are amazing. Mariah has stronger options, especially for this decade, but still a good choice. 

 

#4 - Natalie Imbruglia - Torn by musicloverdude!

SCORE: 7.325

Natalie Imbruglia – Torn / Wishing I Was There (2001, CD) - Discogs

SCORES:

10 x2

8.3

1

COMMENTS:

* The worst song ever. :michael:

* Now THIS is a timeless classic! Forever iconic. You win. 

* That’s the same case when it comes to „Crush” - cute, overplayed pop song. But when it comes to emotions - Natalie ATE. It is some kind of song which brings you calm and relief. Brillant.

 

#5 - Livin' Joy - Dreamer by dejmieeen!

SCORE: 7.2

Dreamer — Livin' Joy | Last.fm

SCORES:

8.5

7.3

7

6

COMMENTS:

* I wish I liked this more but the production didn't mix well with the vocals that sounded off-key at times. It can be a bop in the right context but in a decade that is full of SO many eurodance bops there were definitely better options to go with.

 

#6 - Monica - Angel of Mine by fierceE!

SCORE: 6.75

Angel of Mine - Wikipedia

SCORES:

9

7.5

6

4.5

COMMENTS:

* Easily Monica's best hit

 

#7 - I Think I'm Paranoid - Garbage by technicolor!

SCORE: 6.075

I Think I'm Paranoid - Wikipedia

SCORES:

7 x2

6

4.3

COMMENTS:

* Pretty cute, I think I might prefer it to the other Garbage song but they’re pretty level for me. I’m not familiar with either which is interesting.

* Much better than previous song by Garbage. It’s a little bit Harder and it makes it more interesting. But I think I don’t like the vocals.

 

#8 - Jennifer Paige - Crush by sugarshine!

SCORE: 6.025

Crush - Single by Jennifer Paige | Spotify

SCORES:

10

5 x2

4.1

COMMENTS:

* Timeless classic.

* Definitely the most boppy and catchiest out of this bunch. It’s an ear worm but quite dated tho. 

* Pop essential, classic me think. But firstly - It’s overplayed, secondly - this song is cute but nothing special tbh. 

 

@Julia Fox @Allday @sugarshine @Technicolor @MusicLoverDude

@fiercE @dejmieeen @fountain @Raphy23 @prézli

 

The mixed reactions

 

When Ratchet Met Clank . . . Again

 

Didn't expect the Natalie shade

 

When Ratchet Met Clank . . . Again

 

 

Top 2 and bottom 2 SOON :wave: What do you predict?

  • Like 1
Posted

* The worst song ever. :michael:

* Now THIS is a timeless classic! Forever iconic. You win. 

 

When Ratchet Met Clank . . . Again

  • Haha 1
Posted

RYQrclv.png

 

TOP 2!

 

Congratulations to @Raphy23!

#1 - Oasis - Champagne Supernova

SCORE: 9.5

Champagne Supernova - Wikipedia

SCORES:

10 x2

9 x2

COMMENTS:

* At first I thought you were a fool for not sending Wonderwall but this song is also really good 

 

#2 - TLC - Waterfalls by @prézli!

SCORE: 8.825

Waterfalls (TLC song) - Wikipedia

SCORES:

9.5

9

8.8

8

COMMENTS:

A classic that can get played at the grocery store and still sound great. 

 

TOP RADIO

 

HEAD RADIO

Q0HQVAA.png

SCORE: 8.055

 

 

LIPS 106

WX5NNuT.png

SCORE: 5.715 :redface:

 

LOW + ELIMINATION:

 

Spoiler

#9 - TLC - No Scrubs by Julia Fox!

SCORE: 5.35 

No Scrubs - Wikipedia

SCORES:

8

7.4

5

1

COMMENTS:

* So, yeah the song is a 90s classic, but if we’re being real the hook is honestly pretty annoying. Like, after just listening to this song now, I could very happily not hear it again for another year. Or longer.

* This song songs both modern and old-school in the same time, so I think this is what a masterpiece should be. But to be fair - it’s not my favourite TLC song, so „only” 8.

 

Which means

#10 - Garbage - When I Grow Up by Allday!

SCORE: 3.8

Garbage: When I Grow Up (Music Video 1999) - IMDb

SCORES:

6

3.2

3 x2

COMMENTS:

* This is cute. Easy to listen to but doesn’t really stand out to me too much, though. But maybe because I don’t recognise it so I’m not feeling the nostalgia. But I like it anyway. 

* At the beginning sounds like one of those boring slow alternative songs, I am surprised that it doesn’t sound like this at all. It screams 90’s but in the way I don’t like. Meh. 

 

Sadly we have to say goodbye to @Allday :emofish:

@Julia Fox @Allday @sugarshine @Technicolor @MusicLoverDude

@fiercE @dejmieeen @fountain @Raphy23 @prézli

 

Posted (edited)

Didn't expect No Scrubs at #9 but hello Waterfalls #2!

 

vVZV96v.gif

 

And Oasis WOW didn't expect that! :clap3:

 

vKRIXNG.gif

Edited by PoKiTaurus
Posted

Yeah deserved win for Oasis, if I was on the other team and was scoring that song I also would have given it a 10. Masterpiece. I’m pleasantly surprised to see that it was well received since I didn’t think it would be to most ATRLers taste!

 

Also happy to be top 3, yes Mariah yes bop yes whistle yes classic 

Posted

I can never past the first round on these games :weeps:  but I was against so many classics so I knew i'd be out.

 

 

guess ya lucky i'd probably would of ended up sending a Tom song anyways if it was 2010s related. 

Posted

I have 3 ideas, bit I am not 100% satisfied with any… Gosh, I need some inspiration :(

Posted
7 hours ago, PoKiTaurus said:

Didn't expect No Scrubs at #9 but hello Waterfalls #2!

 

AH, THANK YOU @Julia Fox. No Scrubs was my first choice, Waterfalls was my back-up. :ahh: 

Posted

Torn is the worst song ever. I hate it to death.

Posted

Sent.

Posted
3 hours ago, prézli said:

AH, THANK YOU @Julia Fox. No Scrubs was my first choice, Waterfalls was my back-up. :ahh: 

Mess :skull: you are welcome I guess

  • Thanks 1
Posted
10 hours ago, fountain said:

Yeah deserved win for Oasis, if I was on the other team and was scoring that song I also would have given it a 10. Masterpiece. I’m pleasantly surprised to see that it was well received since I didn’t think it would be to most ATRLers taste!

 

Also happy to be top 3, yes Mariah yes bop yes whistle yes classic 

It's one of my fave songs ever, but I was super worried sending it in for this reason. but I just went with my gut.

 

Also I missed the voting :'( 

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm so confused on the scoring, why is there only 4 points on all the songs except Mariah's?

Remix :monkey:

Posted

Wait why does Mariah have 5 votes :rip:

 

When I did it on Excel every song had 4 votes so the math is correct 

Posted

Was tactical with my choice. :bird:

Posted
17 hours ago, prézli said:

Torn is the worst song ever. I hate it to death.

nnnnn love your brutal honesty. 

 

But hey, the song makes me happy and I'll sneak it into a lineup of songs from the 2020s because I just really enjoy it. Glad it worked out for me and glad you did well with Waterfalls

  • Thanks 1
Posted

I'm so so so sorry for joining this even though I can't participate :chick3: Normally i'm not like this but I thought it would be from Discord and I also kinda don't have time, sorry

Posted

Submitted :katie2:

Posted

PTE

Posted

I'll submit later today once I get off work 

Posted

wait this sounds fun r u still sign ups?

  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

Can I take Kayseri's place

Posted

I-

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.