Kill Me Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 If Taylor whips out her guitar and leans into it as her shtick she can sneak into the finale on American Idol or X-factor ala Grace Vanderwaal. But a mid vocalist with a strong relatable personality will win in the end(not Bey). Someone like Kelly or Miley...
John Slayne Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Gaga has the vocal ability to win, but the audience/judges would vote her out somewhere in top 10 because she too 'weird' or some excuse like that. I can actually see Taylor winning, but not because she's a great singer but because she's the poster white girl, these competitions are all about image let's be real and Taylor is relatable to white people. Madonna wouldn't get past her audition. Whitney would win. Mariah, Ariana, and Rihanna could too. Beyonce would go top 2.
Pinksus Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 16 hours ago, Bentley said: Beyoncé would lose to a white guy because she’s not relatable, I could see this happening so easily The girl bring the house down with some masjestic performance to lose to some white guy with a guitar singing a bland acoustic version of Stay With Me / Thinking Out Loud / etc
louis58 Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Miley would eat, she's the best at making covers sound like her own songs
Rotunda Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 50 minutes ago, John Slayne said: Gaga has the vocal ability to win, but the audience/judges would vote her out somewhere in top 10 because she too 'weird' or some excuse like that. Gaga would lose because she’d insist on performing songs she loves rather than talent show staples
John Slayne Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 7 minutes ago, Rotunda said: Gaga would lose because she’d insist on performing songs she loves rather than talent show staples 'or some excuse like that'
Rotunda Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 2 minutes ago, John Slayne said: 'or some excuse like that' Oh didnt realize you were going to be annoying
John Slayne Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 9 minutes ago, Rotunda said: Oh didnt realize you were going to be annoying i'm sorry, i didn't mean to come across as rude
Steve Johnson Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 1 hour ago, Pinksus said: Stay With Me / Thinking Out Loud / etc Great songs.
FSXP Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 (edited) Depends on the show. Taylor is not making beyond the auditions for XF and if she did, she’s first out but I can see her go far on American Idol. Rihanna would go pretty far on both but lose midway. Gaga would make it farther on XF but she would lose on AI cause she’s “too pretentious” and unwillingly to appease the public. Adele would go top 2 for both and win cause of voice and personality and music taste. Dua and Billie mid way on both but the younger crowd like them more than the older crowd didn’t. Ari would be top 4 but not quite top 2 cause she’s talented but not taking it serious. Beyoncé would probably win XF but make top 2 AI and lose cause she’s “too perfect” and slayed everything and didn’t struggle for the public to connect. Edited May 16, 2023 by FSXP
Freakshowvato Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Beyonce, Adele, Ariana, Demi would either win or get very far.
Freakshowvato Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 1 hour ago, Bussea said: Selena would win If she were still alive, yes
shyboi Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Britney top 3 ( we all know she can sing if she really wants) Beyoncé winner Gaga Top 10 Taylor top 5 Ariana Second place
BrokenMachine Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Based in just singing? P!nnk definitely would make it high
BrokenMachine Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Also, we know those 'singing' competitions rarely involve singing as their priority, it's mostly about charisma or how the audience likes a performance, or how they look, or if the song chosen is the right one, etc. I mean, Simon Cowell denied Tori Kelly just because he didn't like her singing tone, when that's pretty subjective, her singing talent was there, and overtime she has become one of the best vocalists out there. To add some contrast, someone like Melanie Martinez who goes out of breath every two words made it to the top 6 of The Voice, so yeah, it would depend which 'singing competition' it is to know how far our MPGs would make it
LatinFreak Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 MY fave would be an early out. She'd be told she sounds like a goat... again.
MadMax12 Posted May 17, 2023 Posted May 17, 2023 Gaga would be Misha B. The most talented/diverse performer but not liked by the public. She would go far but not win. Katy Perry would be Little Mix. Appeals to all the kids, marketed to be relatable and accessible to the public. She would win for her visuals and personality, and playing the game the smartest. Adele would be Rebecca Ferguson. Good voice but boring as a performer always doing the same style.
Recommended Posts