Timber Posted May 15, 2023 Posted May 15, 2023 For example X-factor, American Idol, The Voice, etc... Would they make it top 20, top 10, top 5, #1, or perhaps rejected on the first round? Remember that in these competitions your voice has to shine, no backing track vocals to help you. Here's an example of an x-factor winner sounds like compared to one of our MPGs so you can have a reference:
Saintlor Posted May 15, 2023 Posted May 15, 2023 Beyonce would easily win, Mariah too Ariana probably (but her live performances can be shaky, I get she's improved now though) Taylor would not get past the audition, but it doesn't matter since there's more to being a successful artist than belting vocals
KFC Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Katy and Taylor don't make it past the auditions Ariana, Billie and Dua are the first three eliminated, the order depends on which one has a shaky performance first Gaga and Rih are midseason outs. Gaga's voice carries her for a few weeks but ultimately the public don't connect with her and vote her OUT. Rih outlasts several more talented singers based on her ability to connect with the audience but ultimately falls short of the finale. Adele and Bey are top 2 with Bey winning because she's able to switch up her performances whereas Adele stood behind a mic for the duration of the competition
MingYouToo Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 24 minutes ago, HotFriedChicken said: Katy and Taylor don't make it past the auditions Ariana, Billie and Dua are the first three eliminated, the order depends on which one has a shaky performance first Gaga and Rih are midseason outs. Gaga's voice carries her for a few weeks but ultimately the public don't connect with her and vote her OUT. Rih outlasts several more talented singers based on her ability to connect with the audience but ultimately falls short of the finale. Adele and Bey are top 2 with Bey winning because she's able to switch up her performances whereas Adele stood behind a mic for the duration of the competition Bey is gonna give us But also Whew Beyonce in the XFactor would be such a slay, she'd be the only XFactor act to break out as big if not bigger than Harry. --- OT: Ariana would probably also win!
Bentley Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Rihanna is Sanjaya. Beyoncé would lose to a white guy because she’s not relatable, Gaga is too theatrical she would place like 5th. Katy would get cut in Hollywood
Jessie Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Seeing as how Gaga’s ballads are a singing competition staple at this point I could definitely see her winning one; she knows how to emote and connect to an audience and can sing different genres with ease
Power love Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 I think Britney & Xtina would win. If this is base off talent. 1
Ger Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 1 hour ago, HotFriedChicken said: Ariana, Billie and Dua are the first three eliminated 34 minutes ago, Jude said: Ariana would win the competition.
Blue Monday Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 I actually feel like Beyoncé, Gaga, Ariana and Billie would all do really well.
Polgg48 Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Kelly wins any show she wants avril won’t cut from pre-audition round or instant 4 reds
Demi Lovallah Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 4 hours ago, HotFriedChicken said: Katy and Taylor don't make it past the auditions Ariana, Billie and Dua are the first three eliminated, the order depends on which one has a shaky performance first Billie would outlast Katy?
Blade Runner Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Kelly would win. Again. Just now, HASHTAGPOW said: Katy Perry, Top 5 funniest audition on X Factor
MusicLoverDude Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Taylor knows how to play guitar so she could just whip it out and win. WGWG
loveisdead9582 Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 4 hours ago, HotFriedChicken said: Katy and Taylor don't make it past the auditions Ariana, Billie and Dua are the first three eliminated, the order depends on which one has a shaky performance first Gaga and Rih are midseason outs. Gaga's voice carries her for a few weeks but ultimately the public don't connect with her and vote her OUT. Rih outlasts several more talented singers based on her ability to connect with the audience but ultimately falls short of the finale. Adele and Bey are top 2 with Bey winning because she's able to switch up her performances whereas Adele stood behind a mic for the duration of the competition I… see absolutely no lies.
Dula Peep Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Beyoncé would be the shocking elimination of the season like Jennifer Hudson
GGD Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 Gaga, Bey and Adele are the tops. But Ed Sheeran wins in the end. Katy Perry is in the audience.
popmusicisdead Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 (edited) i feel like Katy Perry would be the Kellie Pickler of the season. she'd make it to the live shows based on her personality alone and get booted halfway through. Edited May 16, 2023 by popmusicisdead
wsurferwayne Posted May 16, 2023 Posted May 16, 2023 (edited) taylor will do quite well in american idol if she stick to country/ folk, besides she can possibly win since AI and XF is based on public votes and she just had the likeability and relatability factor with the voters katy will possibly do a katie waissel (bottom 2/3 multiple times before being eliminated) gaga will either do a kitty brucknell or saara alto (depending on her performances) Edited May 16, 2023 by wsurferwayne
Recommended Posts