base talk Thank U, Next vs WWFA,WDWG vs Future Nostalgia.

[GoodGuyGoneGhetto]

 

Edited May 8, 2023 by GoodGuyGoneGhetto

[truthteller]

edgy gays vs bratty gays vs basic gays

[magazine]

TUN for all 

[zasderfght]

Bigger/iconic/classic are all relative and subjective, and it hasn't even been a full decade since these albums dropped, but I will say WWFA, WDWG and thank u, next are in a league of their own. Future Nostalgia is a fun pop album, but WWFA, WDWG and thank u, next are definitely what I'd consider concept albums and that elevates the material over a fun pop album.  

[FSXP]

Bigger Era: Future Nostalgia 

 

More Iconic: Thank U Next

 

Classic: WWFA, WDWG

 

I think Future Nostalgia is as an era is the biggest. Multiple hits and was a global smash. 

 

TUN is the most iconic imo.

 

Billie’s will be the biggest classic.

[99sandthe2000s]

[Big Bad Wolf]

I voted Billie for all. But TUN is my favorite out of these. 

[ariesgroove]

5 minutes ago, FSXP said:

Bigger Era: Future Nostalgia 

 

More Iconic: Thank U Next

 

Classic: WWFA, WDWG

i second this 

[Josh]

Ariana for all 

[M!X]

I think Billie easily wins for everything even tho I enjoy the other 2 much more.

 

FN is gp/spotify driven and tun is kinda overrated in terms of success/impact here. Ariana's biggest and most known era was clearly My Everything

 

Billie on the other side established herself as a gen-z icon with this album. She scored, hits, acclaim, sales, good touring receipts, just overall era had everything covered and will be most remembered out of those

[ariananext]

Albums as in body of work I would say WWAFA > TUN >> FN, the first two are well known beyond the hits, while FN was very singles centered.

 

Singles wise it's a bit hard, because all TUN singles were hits, while the other two have both hits and misses, although Bad Guy, DSN and Levitating are all bigger than TUN and 7R.

 

I think they're all iconic, maybe FN is slightly less recognizable by the GP because they don't really know Dua that well compared to the other two. Biggest classic should be WWAFA but I also feel like it's kind of forgotten? 

[burninredhot]

FN clears but WWAFA feels more iconic. TUN can't compare tho

[shyboi]

WWGFAWDWG clears in every single way, followed by FN. 

 

TUN shouldn't even be there lmao

[KatyPrismSpirit]

23 minutes ago, 99sandthe2000s said:

Pow

[Thinking Of You]

Ariana is the last female pop artist whose era was actually a pop culture phenomenon. It was gigantic on all ends. It was the combination of her being the tabloid celebrity at the time with the hits. It definitely was very reminiscent of an old-school era.

 

Therefore, she wins the first two. But, Billie wins the classic album.

Edited May 8, 2023 by Thinking Of You

[B-Luke]

Biggest: Billie

Most iconic: Ariana

Classic: Billie

[shyboi]

1 hour ago, truthteller said:

edgy gays vs bratty gays vs basic gays

 

who is who 

[Beyonnaise]

WWAFA for all

 

Pop forum gays are biased toward Future Nostalgia though

[Heldenzeit]

WWFAWDWG for all three 

[k4rmabutterfly]

Future Nostalgia is the bigger era. 

[Cloröx]

WWAFAWDWG for all. TUNA is the most forgotten, I don’t know why people saying it’s the most iconic, the close one probably TUN music video but the hype was gone like a week.

[bad guy]

WWAFA for all. It not only made Billie a household name but it skyrocketed her to a level of fame that hadn’t been seen since Gaga. Her image/style has been imitated, as has her music, and the album was a breath of fresh air for that time. It’s one of the biggest eras in the last decade globally not to mention all the acclaim + the sold out stadium tour (until Covid came). 

 

TUN was big in the moment but kinda fizzled out and FN is just a Spotify singles playlist at this point instead of an album.

 

WWAFA > TUN > FN.

[Jesse James]

WWFA,WDWG for all. The other two are only recognized by gay stans

[Power love]

I feel like Billie is already kind of forgotten.

 

 I’m going to give it to Ariana & Dua.

[Trent W]

WWAFA is the biggest era

 

FN is a classic album/era too but it really wasn’t as big

 

TUN had a great start but the era only lasted like 3-4 months and is now forgotten