Jump to content

Bigger career: Taylor Swift or Britney Spears?


Bigger career?  

452 members have voted

  1. 1. Bigger career?

    • Taylor Swift
      343
    • Britney Spears
      107


Recommended Posts

Posted

The landslide :dies:

  • Replies 426
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Josh

    43

  • Enrique523

    32

  • Blackout2006

    29

  • Axelios

    18

Posted

Comparisons like these drive me insane because there is FAR more nuance and complexity than ATRL cares to discuss when you compare completely different artists and people who are performing in different time periods.

 

Excuse me for going on a RANT here... Read if you please. Or don't. :fan:
 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Thus, it is outrageously unfair and futile to compare these two artists. They are far too different for a fair comparison to be made. Both have and lack different strengths... But most arguably, Britney's interpersonal struggles make ANY career comparison to someone like Swift, enormously unfair. :sorry:

Posted

Spears is a 90’s fad so Taylor wins by default. 

Posted (edited)

Taylor made it past 5 years and serves quality albums 

Edited by VioletsandRoses
Posted
  On 4/18/2023 at 3:11 AM, Trent W said:


Oh Z-lists, Halsey is the only one that has a relevant career who has also stanned/supported Britney.

 

The only relevant person Taylor has influenced is Olivia and as I already said she made her hate her after coming after her.

 

God I don’t wanna come as a Taylor hater since Im a fan but some of her fans are soooo soo delusional

Expand  

They are giving me monsters circa 2009/2010.

Posted
  On 4/19/2023 at 8:16 AM, Miss Show Business said:

Comparisons like these drive me insane because there is FAR more nuance and complexity than ATRL cares to discuss when you compare completely different artists and people who are performing in different time periods.

 

Excuse me for going on a RANT here... Read if you please. Or don't. :fan:
 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Thus, it is outrageously unfair and futile to compare these two artists. They are far too different for a fair comparison to be made. Both have and lack different strengths... But most arguably, Britney's interpersonal struggles make ANY career comparison to someone like Swift, enormously unfair. :sorry:

Expand  

 

Thank you! There are smart users in this forum after all.

Posted
  On 4/19/2023 at 8:16 AM, Miss Show Business said:

Comparisons like these drive me insane because there is FAR more nuance and complexity than ATRL cares to discuss when you compare completely different artists and people who are performing in different time periods.

 

Excuse me for going on a RANT here... Read if you please. Or don't. :fan:
 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Thus, it is outrageously unfair and futile to compare these two artists. They are far too different for a fair comparison to be made. Both have and lack different strengths... But most arguably, Britney's interpersonal struggles make ANY career comparison to someone like Swift, enormously unfair. :sorry:

Expand  

The most nuanced and mature answer I've seen in this thread. Thank youf or exactly putting my thoughts into words

Posted (edited)
  On 4/16/2023 at 10:57 AM, Cleanromantic said:

Taylor in every way possible. I understand the Britney stans already melting down though, she should be compared to artists who had a similar typical pop star shelf life like Katy and Gaga and not with someone on Taylor's level.

Expand  

If you compare the albums released 8 years into their careers we have 1989... and then we have blackout and Joanne which add for a miserable 9m sales and are lucky to pull 1m daily streams combined

 

now watch a legion of gay men older than Taylor herself come out of the woodwork talking about "impact" 

Edited by ethansdelicate
adding concise information
Posted

Janet Jackson Snack GIF - Janet Jackson Snack Eat - Discover ...

Posted

truthfully, idk. britney's career was big on arrival and slowly declined over time (sadly)

and taylor's career only gains momentum every year

Posted
  On 4/18/2023 at 2:59 PM, Monkey_Juice said:

 

 

Like I said Toxic > Taylor Swift

 

hihi.thumb.gif.cba8a8e590c68a6c1ed9f610e

Expand  

What king of delusion is this ? 

658293849_6874741.thumb.GIF.e70306b28594

Posted
  On 4/18/2023 at 12:04 AM, Badgalbriel said:

Melanie went top 3 because of pure sales :deadbanana:

Expand  

But Taylor's fanbase is big enough to do that and more, which is my point. Even if the GeePee moves on to the new "it" girl. Her fanbase can still keep Taylor relevant, because they have the ability to, unlike pop girls from before.

Posted
  On 4/18/2023 at 2:59 PM, Monkey_Juice said:

Sorry but I don't believe in scientology or whatever you, Taylor and the swifties are into.

 

Like I said Toxic > Taylor Swift

 

hihi.thumb.gif.cba8a8e590c68a6c1ed9f610e

Expand  

Comments like this is why Britney has been losing against everyone except Katy. 
 

 

  On 4/19/2023 at 7:12 AM, Mystic Boy said:

The landslide :dies:

Expand  

I screamed! lol

Posted
  On 4/20/2023 at 3:17 AM, TheHiveMind said:

Comments like this is why Britney has been losing against everyone except Katy. 
 

Expand  

you act like this means anything or as if this validates you somehow :rip: this is ATRL, no one cares and moves on 

Posted

I really don't understand the comparison like...They're just two completely different types of artists

Posted

200.gif

Here are some of treats for everyone. Hope

you enjoy them.

Unknown User
Posted

Taylor

Posted

Britney's first era alone is bigger than any Tay swift era. ATRL is just high on Tay's current success. 

Posted
  On 4/21/2023 at 11:47 PM, TouchinFree said:

Britney's first era alone is bigger than any Tay swift era. ATRL is just high on Tay's current success. 

Expand  

:rip: the delusion :bibliahh:

Posted
  On 4/22/2023 at 1:54 AM, Wewee said:

:rip: the delusion :bibliahh:

Expand  

Self awareness is key. It's a start for you. 

Posted
  On 4/21/2023 at 11:47 PM, TouchinFree said:

Britney's first era alone is bigger than any Tay swift era. ATRL is just high on Tay's current success. 

Expand  

Just like 21 is bigger than any Madonna era, TFM is bigger than any Mariah era etc 

hihi.thumb.gif.cba8a8e590c68a6c1ed9f610e

Unknown User
Posted

Taylor obv. Anyone saying anything else is smoking extremely cheap crack

Posted

Taylor is bigger in career in general. But Britney had bigger pop culture impact, the entire end 90s and early 2000s pop culture was unrivalled and can't be compared to any time else, it was something special, peak of tabloids, peak of scandals, peak of pop drama, peak of fashion iconic moments. 

Posted
  On 4/19/2023 at 8:39 PM, Love Again said:

The most nuanced and mature answer I've seen in this thread. Thank youf or exactly putting my thoughts into words

Expand  

:clap3:

Posted
  On 4/20/2023 at 6:51 AM, PerfectSacrifice said:

I really don't understand the comparison like...They're just two completely different types of artists

Expand  

 

both american sweethearts only Taylor slightly less iconic (slightly) both beautiful queens tbh

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.