poll Best Taylor Swift Producer: Max Martin/Shellback vs Jack Antonoff vs Aaron Dessner

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

 

 

 

Which main producer is her best?

 

Try ranking them:
Nathan Chapman

Max Martin/Shellback

Jack Antonoff

Aaron Dessner

[Intuition]

All are great but Dessner is probably my least fave out of the options .

[The Music Industry]

Aaron Dessner > Nathan Chapman > Jack > Shellback/Martin 

 

Come at me gays 

[Virgos Groove]

Aaron >>>

[Solaria]

Whoever produced …Ready for HIT

[ontherocks]

Antonoff and Dessner. Martin and Shellback are cookie cutter, disposable & generic pop tards. 

[Breakdown]

I'm sorry but Max & Shellback deserve it for Style, Wildest Dreams and All You Had to Do Was Stay alone already.

I have to randomly and controversially add: The TVs won't hold a candle to them, not to a single 1989 or Reputation track.

[EtherealCat]

dessner > antonoff > chapman > martin/shellback

[Beyonceist]

Whoever produced reputation aka her best album to date

[ultraviolence.xx]

unsure how to vote. a lot of my favorite taylor songs have come from hack, but also a LOT of skips. hmmm.

[Carter]

ahhhh if only aaron produced rep 

[burninredhot]

Voting max/shellback over the other 3 is just laughable

 

[wastedpotential]

Aaron clears with ease, let's not kid around

[bestfiction]

Jack > Aaron > others

[Dear Reader]

Jack > Aaron > others [2]

[ariananext]

Aaron > Jack > Max > others

Edited March 29, 2023 by ariananext

[Rev8]

It's probably between Martin/back and Antonoff

however, Jack has made some really questionable stuff too - so no

[Big Bad Wolf]

I like her songs with Max Martin & Shellback they just feel like big pop numbers that I think work really well for her and are very enjoyable. 
 

Didn’t Jack do Clean tho? I’ve always loved that one. So I’d say he’s second after them

[dussel_06]

[Johnny Jacobs]

Idk who produced willow but him

[wastedpotential]

4 minutes ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

Didn’t Jack do Clean tho? I’ve always loved that one. So I’d say he’s second after them

Imogen Heap co-produced Clean

[wastedpotential]

1 minute ago, Johnny Jacobs said:

Idk who produced willow but him

That was Aaron Dessner, and is an excellent example of how perfect his productions are 

[West Coast]

as much as i hate jack it's him 

[sasashite]

Jack is the most versatile out of those 3 but Midnights was a miss (Taylor’s fault since she decided to go back to the mediocre pop stuff presented on Lover and Reputation).

 

Aaron is my favorite particularly, although we know he’s gonna give us another version of Folklore.

 

Nathan made a lot of great music but those songs worked mainly because of Taylor’s songwriting.

 

The only great production by Max Martin was Style and maybe New Romantics. He’s the last for sure.

[Brooklyn Baby]

Aaron Dessner

Max Martin

Nathan Chapman

Jack Antonoff