poll Lover vs Midnights

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

 

Which album is superior?

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

[Brooklyn Baby]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Lover: 7 / Midnights: 13

Edited March 19, 2023 by Taeyong

[Ampersand13]

Midnights and it ain’t particularly close I’m afraid (still really enjoy Lover though!)

[Feanor]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

 

Lover wins, Midnights has the better album cover tho.

[State of Grace.]

these women having a mid off

 

but 3AM put Midnights above Lover I fear

Edited March 19, 2023 by State of Grace.

[Sad Serenade]

Lover for all. 

[Relampago.]

Lover for both and it’s not close

[Fuecoco]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S***

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Midnights: 12 | Lover: 6

Edited March 19, 2023 by Fuecoco

[Axelios]

Midnights by far, it'a much more consistent album.

[the good guy_duh]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

                                                                    London Boy / Karma (both fun trashy bops ngl, but sonically Karma has the edge)

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Lover: 6 Midnights: 11

 

Midnights (as a whole) clears, I fear.

Loser is such an inconsistent album, full of filler songs and noise.

However, Daylight and Afterglow (ft. The Archer) are highkey better than any Midnight song. 

 

[justin464]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante Sh*t

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Only the Young / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Midnights: 12

Lover: 8

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Lover - 11

Midnights - 7

[Fuecoco]

1 minute ago, OnlyManInTheWorld said:

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Cheater, you can’t choose both!  Lol

[WildHeart]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Lover 9 / Midnights 8

[blown away]

Midnights for both.

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris (I really dislike that song, ME! at least is fun in a camp way)

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

[roso]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

8 / 12

 

3AM clears

[JoJo]

Lover: 11

Midnights: 9

 

3 a.m edition carried Midnights 

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

[Gladiator]

Midnights made me appreciate Lover much more than I did, for a long time. 

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon - Maroon is one of my absolute favorite songs.

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris - THESE ARE AMONG HER WORST SONGS IN HER CAREER AND I HATE THEM BOTH, BUT I HATE PARIS MORE.

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

[State of Grace.]

16 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

jail 

[305]

I Forgot That You Existed /Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind (this was hard)

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

7 vs 13

[Riverbank]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

12 vs 7

 

Lover clears 

[David Smith2]

Lover 4 all 

[ProudLBS]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

[rebeltwat]

Midnights by far

[Cruel Summer]

Midnights by far for both 

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing (tie)

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

6 vs 15, Midnights clears