[CAROLINE WON] Caroline v. Kelela: Who will get the higher P4K score?

[PhoebeBuffay]

Caroline had my attention with "Amanaemonesia" but her solo work hasn't truly cliked with me with the exception of a few songs. Not to judge or anything it's just the truth for me. I like almost every Kelela song but after all it's all about personal taste

[Supervillain]

Hopefully Caroline since her album is better  

[Ice Cream Skies]

Kelela - 8.4 BNM

 

Feels a bit low if you ask me. We'll see if Caroline can outdo it. 

[Ice Cream Skies]

After listening to Desire I think Caroline might take it.

[Polgg48]

looping caroline album atm and feeling like easy 8 for her, idk how p4k would react on non-highlight album tracks or focus on certain amazing produced tracks in there.

 

that being said, it's either 8.2 to 8.6 range dancing around kelela score. both AOTY contenders gays win so much this week

[Ewan Chaos]

Haven't listened to Desire yet, but I see them going the Dirty Projectors/Amber Coffman route and giving them the same score.

[Phaunzie]

Kelela like who else would it be, she always produces quality content.

[Ice Cream Skies]

16 hours ago, Ice Cream Skies said:

After listening to Desire I think Caroline might take it.

CAROLINE WON!

 

8.7 

 

https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/caroline-polachek-desire-i-want-to-turn-into-you/

 

Final vote count before Caroline's review came in:

30 - Kelela

10 - Caroline

Edited February 14, 2023 by Ice Cream Skies

[fauxtography]

On 2/12/2023 at 4:25 AM, theblackestday said:

Kelallah we hope.

 

i cackled way too hard at this but mostly because it even exists

[kyliefever2002]

 

[Contessa]

The basement joke

[kandicha]

well we are truly blessed to get two such great albums back to back