Best girl group from the UK? Sugababes, Spice Girls or Girls Aloud

[popmusicisdead]

nothing will ever touch Sugababes musically 2000-2005. too bad since it went downhill when Mutya left. 

[Bloodflowers.]

Sugababes > Spice Girls >>>>>>>> Whites aloud

[AidanUnderYou]

Girls Aloud easily have the best and most interesting music. They created some really forward thinking pop songs of their time. The Xenomania production was excellence, like Biology doesn't even have a real structure and Sexy! No No No just sounds weird in the best way. And these songs became hits. Something Kinda Ooh is also THAT bop. They were in the lane of what hyper pop is achieving long before it was even a thing. They weren't your typical cookie cutter cheesy girl group which is why they'll always be my favourite. Surprised they're not getting more respect in this thread.

 

I mean, they released 20 consecutive Top 10 singles over 7 years and the single to break their streak peaked at #11 and then they broke up. Their stats are insane.

[HASHTAGPOW]

Sugababes. Too Lost in You >>> 

[raven]

If we’re talking iconicity, spice girls win but in terms of quality discographies, my personal ranking would be:

 

Sugababes (with Mutya) > Girls Aloud > Spice Girls

 

Sugababes and GA are very close though - I just listen to the former more. 

[Nashe]

6 hours ago, Gwendolyn said:

I forgot about that, I think Push the Button and About You Now we're quite successful; I dont think the groups ever truly reached as high as they did in the UK 

Overload

Freak Like Me

Right Round

Hole In The Head

Too Lost In You

Push The Button

About You Now

 

were all hits in mainland Europe and partly even Australia

 

also Denial, Stronger, In The Middle, Ugly found success in a few countries too

[reymiu]

28 minutes ago, Nashe said:

Overload

Freak Like Me

Right Round

Hole In The Head

Too Lost In You

Push The Button

About You Now

 

were all hits in mainland Europe and partly even Australia

 

also Denial, Stronger, In The Middle, Ugly found success in a few countries too

Sugababes had hits in Southeast Asia too - their music got decent plays on MTV Asia

 

Round Round

Too Lost in You

Push the Button

About You Now

[reymiu]

Anyway looks like Sugababes is winning by a landslide...

 

Push the Button, About You Now & Too Lost in You really stood the test of time and remain iconic to this day. Plus, Freak like Me - Round Round - Overload all gained pop cult classic status.

 

Spotify

Push The Button: 123M plays

About You Now: 125M plays

Too Lost in You: 50M plays

 

 

[Supervixen]

Spice Girls > Bananarama >>>>>>> the rest

[iaintiffin]

Eternal deserve some recognition.

[Technicolor]

Girls Aloud. HIT after HIT 

[eli's_rhythm]

Sugababes’ best songs are above the rest, but GA just had so many hits and fun moments that I have to go with them.

[Unreachable101]

1. Spice Girls

2. All Saints

3. Sugababes

 

the rest of the groups have all been very local

[KLatz]

It's close between Girls Aloud and Sugababes, but due to the sheer amount of bops I love from them, I gotta give it to Girls Aloud. They really served until the end