Best girl group from the UK? Sugababes, Spice Girls or Girls Aloud

[Josh]

 

 

Edited February 10, 2023 by Josh

[Legend E]

Sugababes. Mutya alone >

[Nashe]

the actual Sugababes xx

 

[uusagii]

Who's the one in the middle in that Sugababes pic? She was never a member? Is it an edit?

[Graves]

For me personally?

 

Sugababes (with Mutya) > Girls Aloud > Sugababes (without Mutya) > Spice Girls

[Hector]

All Saints & Bananarama after the Spice Girls. And Misteeq as well. 

Edited February 10, 2023 by Hector

[Josh]

1 minute ago, Nashe said:

the actual Sugababes xx

 

Thanks I wasn't sure which lineup to choose cause I didnt know which was the original lineup

[conquxror]

All Saints >>>>>>>>
 

 

[Virgos Groove]

Girls Aloud > Sugababes >>> Spice Girls.

[sunbathinganimal]

Just now, ATWK said:

Girls Aloud > Sugababes >>> Spice Girls.

[andresg770]

The All Saints and Mini Viva erasure tho  

[abrantino]

Sugababes & The Saturdays >> the rest

[WEEKND]

 

Them other hoes could never 

[JBJT2786]

 

 

Mis-teeq>>>>>>

[Avantpop]

Sugababes - artistry and innovation
Girls Aloud - timeless bops and immaculate production
Spice - Girls 

[The Slayer]

Little Mix.

 

However, if I am choosing from that list, Sugababes.

[Phaunzie]

Best? GA, the avant garde and experimental Chemistry alone demolishes the others careers in terms of sheer artistry. Only Americans will choose Sugababes.

[WEEKND]

This used to have me in a CHOKEHOLD 

 

 

 

 

 

 

THE SHEER AMOUNT OF BOPS 

 

 

u HAD to be there

[Abracadabra]

Sugababes and Girls Aloud have the best discographies

[Body Talk]

I always preferred the Sugababes, they have the highest highs but may also have some of the lowest lows...

[BraveNewSeth]

Girls Aloud, followed closely by the Sugababes

[The7thStranger]

Spice Girls. You knew their names, you knew what they were about, they wrote their own material, and transcended the manufactured framework in which they met.

 

That being said, Sugababes and Girls Aloud have some great tracks.

[Nashe]

7 hours ago, Gwendolyn said:

Girls Aloud and Sugababes run MILES ahead of Spice Girls - it's a true shame they came out right when the cool Britannia era had ended, both could've been so successful in Europe

Sugababes were very successful in Europe though?

[iaintiffin]

Spice Girls, they waaaaaaaaay more iconic, successful and WW than the others listed.

 

Spice Girls can still sell out stadiums which the others couldn't even do at the height of their fames.

[Heartbreak Prince]

Spice Girls are iconic but were very short lived and Sugababes, while big for a while, these days are lazy flops with a huge bully, a Q-anon homophobe and miscellaneous as members now.

 

Girls Aloud were 5 iconic ladies who changed the face of British pop. They’ll always be the best.

Edited February 11, 2023 by Heartbreak Prince