Jump to content

The Taylor Swift Discography Rate || Winner Revealed!


Recommended Posts

Posted

Glad Midnights is getting lashed - it's what it deserves 

  • Replies 5.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • hoax

    583

  • 1989

    517

  • Incandescent Glow

    362

  • By the Water

    232

Posted
  On 2/22/2023 at 3:28 AM, 1989 said:

That’s all for today, see you all tomorrow for the next mess reveal :gaycat4:

Expand  

Thank you sis! :clap3:

Posted
  On 2/22/2023 at 1:00 AM, 1989 said:

 

h8DktM9.jpg

 

137. Ronan - 6.717
 

 

Expand  

An absolutely gorgeous but heartbreaking song.

Posted

pictures to burn is cute but kinda forgot it existed. 

Posted (edited)

number of remaining songs by album (up to #125)

taylor swift: 4/14 (29% still in)

fearless: 12/26 (46% still in)

speak now: 14/17 (82% still in)

red: 24/30 (57% still in)

1989: 12/16 (75% still in)

reputation: 9/15 (60% still in)

lover: 11/18 (56% still in)

folklore: 16/17 (94% still in)

evermore: 13/17 (76% still in)

midnights: 15/21 (71% still in)

 

survival rank:

(=) 1. folklore

(+2) 2. speak now

(-2) 3. evermore

(+3) 4. 1989

(-2) 5. midnights

(-1) 6. reputation

(-2) 7. red

(+1) 8. lover

(-1) 9. fearless

(=) 10. taylor swift

Edited by Lorenzo22
Posted
  On 2/22/2023 at 2:11 AM, 1989 said:

 

XisQgAm.jpg

 

131. The Archer - 6.817
Lovers(10): TMRA, Tusk, AbeHicks, JoanneActII, sparrowblue, Quicksand, jacobhalkohit, NordicGuy, greento, 

Haters(1): inshadesofcool, jacklovesyou1, KillingYourCareer, SleepingTigers, Taylor fanboy

Comments:

Fifteen: cute 

wastedpotential: This was fine until Midnights came out and most of the album blew it out of the water.

 

Expand  

NOOOOOOOOOOOO :jonny2: 

Posted
  On 2/22/2023 at 3:44 AM, Lorenzo22 said:

number of remaining songs by album (up to #125)

taylor swift: 4/14 (29% still in)

fearless: 12/26 (46% still in)

speak now: 14/17 (82% still in)

red: 24/30 (57% still in)

1989: 12/16 (75% still in)

reputation: 12/15 (60% still in)

lover: 11/18 (56% still in)

folklore: 16/17 (94% still in)

evermore: 13/17 (76% still in)

midnights: 15/21 (71% still in)

 

survival rank:

(=) 1. folklore

(+2) 2. speak now

(-2) 3. evermore

(+3) 4. 1989

(-2) 5. midnights

(-1) 6. reputation

(-2) 7. red

(+1) 8. lover

(-1) 9. fearless

(=) 10. taylor swift

Expand  

reputation unfortunately has nine songs left.

 

Looking out for you sis before they call you a puta stan and redirect their anger to you after the 1939 era backlashes.

Posted

DWOHT

MA&THP

Maroon

Lavender Haze

Love Story 

White Horse 

I Did Something Bad

No Body, No Crime

 

 

at least only 2 of my fave TS songs are out so far :dancehall:

Posted
  On 2/22/2023 at 3:51 AM, Taylor fanboy said:

reputation unfortunately has nine songs left.

 

Looking out for you sis before they call you a puta stan and redirect their anger to you after the 1939 era backlashes.

Expand  

thank you! the percentage is correct just forgot to update the #s 

Posted
  On 2/22/2023 at 12:25 AM, 1989 said:

Well there’s also the ever present possibility I missed someone, but yeah it didn’t have a lot of 10s in general :!ohno:

Expand  

I gave it 10:heart:

Posted
  On 2/22/2023 at 4:32 AM, Aiya said:

I gave it 10:heart:

Expand  

Doing the Lord’s work, truly :heart:

Posted
  On 2/21/2023 at 10:52 PM, 1989 said:

 

QQ0HPKc.jpg

 

150. Sweet Nothing - 6.498
 

Lovers(10): AbeHicks, a_d_22, Shendelzare, The Argonaut, NMIXX,

Haters(1): Taylor fanboy, By The Water, creativity., 4real, Allday, Brando, Aiya, 

 

 

 

Expand  

This is just a tragic display of how little taste y’all have and I’m glad I slept through this terror attack on Sweet Rotys! :chick3:

 

  On 2/22/2023 at 1:00 AM, 1989 said:

 

h8DktM9.jpg

 

137. Ronan - 6.717
 

 

 

Expand  

Just tragic lack of taste :deadbanana2: it’s a beautiful song. 

 

  On 2/22/2023 at 1:15 AM, 1989 said:

 

z9x6UUz.jpg

 

136. I Did Something Bad - 6.721
 

Stans(11): jacklovesyou1,

Lovers(10): AbeHicks, Miles., feelslikeadream, Navy4life, Supernatural, Allday, Sanguine, Taylor fanboy, 

Haters(1): sparrowblue, Brando, Velvet Night,

Haters(0): inshadesofcool, 4real,

 

 

 

Expand  

Not this leaving before King of my Turds :biblio:

 

  On 2/22/2023 at 1:50 AM, 1989 said:
z9x6UUz.jpg

 

133. So It Goes… - 6.753
 

Stans(11): JoanneActII, Ayanaa

Lovers(10): eli’s_rhythm, Hunter_13, Prison, Taylor fanboy, pinkbowvintage, 

Haters(1): yeezytaughtme, Brando, By The Water, AbeHicks,

Haters(0): Kyungsooswift, Michael196, Holy Ground

Comments:

wastedpotential: Filler
Fifteen: this one is so underrated

 
Expand  

A BOP!

 

  On 2/22/2023 at 2:11 AM, 1989 said:

 

XisQgAm.jpg

 

131. The Archer - 6.817
Lovers(10): TMRA, Tusk, AbeHicks, JoanneActII, sparrowblue, Quicksand, jacobhalkohit, NordicGuy, greento, 

Haters(1): inshadesofcool, jacklovesyou1, KillingYourCareer, SleepingTigers, Taylor fanboy

Comments:

Fifteen: cute 

wastedpotential: This was fine until Midnights came out and most of the album blew it out of the water.

 

 

Expand  

This trash finally leaving :clap3:too high tho. 
 

  On 2/22/2023 at 2:29 AM, 1989 said:

 

HqfZgRs.jpg

 

129. Epiphany - 6.844
 

Stans(11): Supernatural 

Lovers(10): 1989, SleepingTigers, Tusk, Sanguine, Brando, The Argonaut, JoanneActII, Ethereal Cat, 

Haters(1): Taylor fanboy, creativity., Shendelzare, Miles., Quicksand

Comments:

wastedpotential: Really haunting production and lyrics, but I don’t listen often.

Fifteen: this song always makes me emotional the pandemic memories it brings

greento: Beautiful song, appreciated it even more after watching the long pond sessions

 

 

 

Expand  

I mean folklore had to leave at some point but this makes me sad. Such a good song :jonnycat:

 

  On 2/22/2023 at 3:08 AM, 1989 said:

 

QQ0HPKc.jpg

 

126. Bejeweled - 6.915
 

Lovers(10): The Argonaut, Pink Whitney 

Haters(1): feelslikeadream, luckythisway, Taylor fanboy, creativity.,

Comments:

wastedpotential: Cute but basic pop song, but the video really elevated it for me.

Fifteen: queen **** :gaycat2:

 

 

Expand  

Before Labyrinth and Anti-Hero? I’m gonna be sick!

 

 

 

Today was just horrible taste all around. Some of you need to take a hearing test :biblionny:

Posted

Peak Now punching :jonny5:

Posted

Is dress still in ? It should’ve been out before Sig

Posted (edited)

2 of my 10’s out in a row wtf :deadbanana4:

meanwhile songs like Labyrinth, Hoax, This Love & the lakes are all still in :rip: 

Edited by Pink Whitney
Posted

NBNC, epiphany, bejeweled, IDSB,  the lucky one, 22, & the archer all getting PURGED

 

 spacer.png

 

y’all will PAY for robbing babe & so it goes of their rightful top 100 positions though 

Posted

There was a lot of... choices last night. But this...

 

  On 2/22/2023 at 12:38 AM, 1989 said:
140. No Body, No Crime (feat. HAIM) - 6.656
Expand  

This is the true crime. This song is so incredible. It's in my overall top 30. :ace:

Posted

Not epiphany being the first folklore gone, it’s #2 or #3 on the album for me :redface:

 

the archer leaving too :redface: it’s literally a perfect song

 

so glad nbnc is out now, sooooo overrated, I was scared itd overstay

 

ronan should have stayed longer, it’s genuinely such a good song 

Posted

Ugh it’s getting serious :coffee2:

 

still all my 0s are still in… but 11s as well 

Posted

Good to see I Made Jesus Mad go :gaycat4:

 

I'm actually surprised about Bejesus too, I thought that had more supporters. I know 22 would have ranked a lot higher if we'd been rating the original and not the tragic version. 

 

It was a shame to see The Holy One leave, especially since no one else gave it a low score for the correct reason (the unabashed Joni Mitchell praise).

 

Scripture to Learn deserved better, but I get that there are some pop bumpkins who don't understand its country appeal. 

 

I will say though, every time @1989 was teasing a song from reputation my stomach dropped in fear that you losers with bad taste had voted out Praying With Our Hands Clasped, but so far, she perseveres!

Posted

epiphany first out from folklore and not even top 20 :biblio:

Posted

Two of my 10s out, undeservedly. Especially ‘Tell Me Why’ 

:biblio: 

 

 

Posted

NYD and Bejeweled (one of the good songs on Mid) out :deadbanana4:

yall are truly confused

 

 

  On 2/22/2023 at 3:44 AM, Lorenzo22 said:

number of remaining songs by album (up to #125)

taylor swift: 4/14 (29% still in)

fearless: 12/26 (46% still in)

speak now: 14/17 (82% still in)

red: 24/30 (57% still in)

1989: 12/16 (75% still in)

reputation: 9/15 (60% still in)

lover: 11/18 (56% still in)

folklore: 16/17 (94% still in)

evermore: 13/17 (76% still in)

midnights: 15/21 (71% still in)

 

survival rank:

(=) 1. folklore

(+2) 2. speak now

(-2) 3. evermore

(+3) 4. 1989

(-2) 5. midnights

(-1) 6. reputation

(-2) 7. red

(+1) 8. lover

(-1) 9. fearless

(=) 10. taylor swift

Expand  

not Mid having more songs in than Rep :jonny2: yall need a new pair of EARS

Posted (edited)

I went to bed last night before the last 4 eliminations but I see nothing of value was lost nn. 

 

Ngl I was shook at BejEWeled being that low. I thought the recency bias would for sure guarantee a Top 100 placement. The song was bottom 3 on first listen for me but it's such a grower and the music video helped a loooot. I gave it a 7.5 knowing damn well it deserves less but I can't make the music not bop etc. :oh:

 

Epiphany, Carolina, IDSB, F&APV, TLO, SIG, Ronan, and Babe remain the true crimes of this round :redface:

Edited by State of Grace.
Posted
  On 2/22/2023 at 3:44 AM, Lorenzo22 said:

number of remaining songs by album (up to #125)

taylor swift: 4/14 (29% still in)

fearless: 12/26 (46% still in)

speak now: 14/17 (82% still in)

red: 24/30 (57% still in)

1989: 12/16 (75% still in)

reputation: 9/15 (60% still in)

lover: 11/18 (56% still in)

folklore: 16/17 (94% still in)

evermore: 13/17 (76% still in)

midnights: 15/21 (71% still in)

 

survival rank:

(=) 1. folklore

(+2) 2. speak now

(-2) 3. evermore

(+3) 4. 1989

(-2) 5. midnights

(-1) 6. reputation

(-2) 7. red

(+1) 8. lover

(-1) 9. fearless

(=) 10. taylor swift

Expand  

Speak Now rising through the ranks, we love to see it :clap3:

 

Saddened to see Babe and Bejeweled go this early, but since y'all already forced out Starlight and Paris (better songs from the same albums), I am not exactly surprised.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.