Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 (edited) Hello and welcome to Mariah Carey's Discography Rate! This year @suburbannature decided to give me the opportunity to host this rate, so thank you King I decided that this year we gonna rate only her studio albums and 1 compilation album (The Rarities (only 1st CD)). So yeah... I hope at least 10 people will participate Rules Rate each song from 1 to 10. Decimals are allowed but only to 1 decimal place (7.8 is fine, but 7.82 is not). You can give ONE song 11 and 0, but only once in each album (for example, if you gave X songs 11 and 0 from the album "Mariah Carey", you can’t rate any of her other songs with 11 and 0 from this album). Rate only songs that are on the list. Comments are optional. Send your ballot to me via DM. DUE DATE: December 10th Song List Mariah Carey (1990) Vision of love There's Got to be a way I don't wanna cry Someday Vanishing All in your mind Alone in Love You need me Sent from up Above Prisoner Love takes time Emotions (1991) Emotions And you don't remember Can't let go Make it happen If it's over You're so cold So blessed To be around you Till the end of time The wind Music Box (1993) Dreamlover Hero Anytime you need a friend Music box Now that I know Never forget you Without you Just to hold you once again I've been thinking about you All I've ever wanted Merry Christmas (1994) Silent night All I want for Christmas is You O Holy Night Christmas (Baby please come home) Miss you most (at Christmas time) Joy to the world Jesus born on this day Santa Claus is comin' to town Hark! The Herald Angels Sing / Gloria (in excelsis Deo) Jesus oh what a wonderful child Daydream (1995) Fantasy Underneath the stars One sweet day Open arms Always be my baby I Am free When I saw you Long ago Melt away Forever Daydream interlude Looking in Butterfly (1997) Honey Butterfly My all The Roof (back in time) Fourth of July Breakdown Babydoll Close my eyes Whenever you call Fly away (butterfly reprise) The beautiful ones Outside Whenever You Call ft. Brian McKnight The Roof (When I Feel the Need) ft. Brandy Rainbow (1999) Heartbreaker Can't take that away (Mariah's theme) Bliss How much After tonight X-Girlfriend Heartbreaker da brat & missy eliot Vulnerability (interlude) Against all odds (take a look at me now) Crybaby Did I do that? Petals Rainbow (interlude) Thank God I found you Glitter (2001) Loverboy remix Lead the way If we Didn't mean to turn you on Don't stop (funkin' 4 jamaica) All my life Reflections (care enough) Last night a DJ saved my life Want you Never too far Twister Loverboy cameo Charmbracelet (2002) Through the rain Boy (I need you) The one Yours You got me I only wanted Clown My saving Grace You had Your chance Lullaby Irresistible (West side connection) Subtle Invitation Bringin' on the heartbreak Sunflowers for Alfred Roy Through the rain remix The Emancipation of Mimi (2005) It's like that We belong together Shake it off Mine Again Say Somethin' Stay the night Get your number One and only Circles Your girl I wish you knew To the floor Joy ride Fly like a bird Don't Forget about us Makin' it last all night (what it do) So lonely (one & Only Pt.II) We belong together remix Secret Love Sprung E=MC2 (2008) Migrate Touch my body Cruise Control I stay in love Side effects I'm that Chick Love story I'll be lovin' U long time last Kiss Thanx 4 nothin' O.O.C. For the record Bye bye I wish you well Heat 4real4real Memoirs of an imperfect angel (2009) Betcha Gon' know (the prologue) Obsessed H.A.T.E.U. Candy bling Ribbon Inseparable Standing O It's a wrap Up out my face Up out my face (the reprise) More than just friends The impossible The impossible (the reprise) Angel (the prelude) Angels cry Languishing (the interlude) I want to know what love is Merry Christmas II You (2010) Santa Claus is coming to town intro Oh Santa! O little town of bethlehem/Little drummer boy Christmas time is in the air again The first Noel/Born is the King interlude When Christmas comes Here comes Santa Claus Charlie Brown Christmas O come all ye faithful/Hallelijah Chorus O holy night One child Auld land syne (NYA) Oh Santa! (Jump Smokers Edit) Me. I am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse (2014) Cry. Faded Dedicated #Beautiful Thirsty Make it look good You're mine (eternal) You don't know what to do Supernatural Meteorite Camouflage Money ($*/…) One more try Heavenly It's a wrap Betcha gon' know The art of letting go Caution (2018) GTFO With you Caution A no no The Distance Giving me life One mo' gen 8th grade stay long love you Portrait Runway The Rarities (2020) Here we go around again Can you hear me Do you think of me Everything fades away All I live for One night Slipping away Out here on my own Loverboy I pray Cool on you Mesmerized Lullaby of Birdland Save the day Close my eyes 2020 Other Singles When I Feel It There Goes My Heart There For Me Skydiving Help Me Make It Through the Night Right to Dream When You Believe Endless Love I Know What You Want U Make Me Wanna Big Energy Remix Fantasy Remix I'll Be There Infinity Somewhat Loved Fall In Love at Christmas I Don't I Still Believe Thank God I Found You/Make It Last My All/Stay Awhile Always Be My Baby ft. Xscape Anytime You Need a Friend C&C Club Version Joy to the World Celebration Mix Fantasy Sweet Dub Mix Cant Take That Away Morales Club Mix Edit My All Morales Club Sweetheart Miss You Almost Home Edited December 28, 2022 by Saddy
Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Author Posted November 2, 2022 (edited) Participants 1. @Saddy 2. @JoAddams 3. @BenAmuro 4. @Miss Show Business 5. @Nightingale 6. @Kiss It Better 7. @Devin 8. @SinnerCity 9. @DemDam92 10. @GraceRandolph 11. @Zaynsus 12. @killer_rose 13. @Ken Lee 14. @Pecinta Mariah 15. @That Bad Eartha 16. @Keter 17. @ONOPKA 18. @Limitless 19. @Pop culture 20. @Reverie 21. @sparrowblue 22. @jacklovesyou1 23. @°ColdFire° 24. @Quicksand 25. @suburbannature 26. @xfreshkidxx 27. @SJane 28. @James_Dean 29. @Ivory. 30. @Pikachoo 31. @Bacardo Royale 32. @Melancholy 33. @xrosup 34. @Curiosity 35. @Rocket Edited December 19, 2022 by Saddy
Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Author Posted November 2, 2022 (edited) Top 246-201 246. Betcha Gon' Know ft. R. Kelly | Score: 2.528 245. Oh Santa! (Jump Smokers Edit) | Score: 3.628 244. Did I do that? | Score: 4.003 243. Up Out My Face (The Reprise) | Score: 4.167 242. I Pray | Score: 4.472 241. Heavenly (No Ways Tired/Can't Give Up Now) | Score: 4.789 240. Sunflowers For Alfred Roy | Score: 4.844 239. It's A Wrap ft. Mary J. Blige | Score: 4.853 238. Close My Eyes (Acoustic) | Score: 5.008 237. Standing O | Score: 5.033 236. Fall In Love at Christmas | Score: 5.061 235. Santa Claus Is Coming To Town | Intro | Score: 5.153 234. To The Floor | Score: 5.175 233. X-Girlfriend | Score: 5.177 232. Somewhat Loved | Score: 5.219 231. Help Me Make It Through the Night |Score: 5.256 230. Save The Day | Score: 5.294 229. The Beautiful Ones ft. Dru Hill | Score: 5.319 228. Auld Lang Syne (The New Year's Anthem) | Score: 5.344 227. O Little Town Of Bethlehem/Little Drummer Boy (Medley) | Score: 5.428 226. 4real4real | Score: 5.458 225. Supernatural | Score: 5.506 224. Through The Rain Remix | Score: 5.511 223. One Child | Score: 5.639 222. Jesus Born On This Day | Score: 5.664 221. Skydiving | Score: 5.665 220. Makin' It Last All Night (What It Do) | Score: 5.669 219. One More Try | Score: 5.692 218. Charlie Brown Christmas | Score: 5.700 217. How much | Score: 5.717 216. Portrait | Score: 5.719 215. U Make Me Wanna | Score: 5.753 214. O Come All Ye Faithful/Hallelujah Chorus ft. Patricia Carey | Score: 5.767 213. Last Kiss | Score: 5.800 212. Lullaby of Birdland | Score: 5.822 211. I Don't ft. YG | Score: 5.828 210. Infinity | Score: 5.829 209. Whenever You Call ft. Brian McKnight | Score: 5.850 208. Angels Cry | Score: 5.881 207. The Roof (When I Feel the Need) ft. Brandy | Score: 5.894 206. Right to Dream | Score: 5.931 205. You Need Me | Score: 5.933 204. Thank God I Found You | Score: 5.939 203. Big Energy Remix | Score: 5.972 202. Loverboy (Firecracker - Original Version) | Score: 5.973 201. Santa Claus Is Comin' To Town | Score: 5.989 Top 200-101 200. There's Got To Be A Way | Score: 6.019 199. The Impossible (The Reprise) | Score: 6.058 198. The First Noel/Born Is The King Interlude (Medley) | Score: 6.092 197. Don't Stop (Funkin' 4 Jamaica) | Score: 6.094 196. Here Comes Santa Claus (Right Down Santa Claus Lane) /Housetop Celebration | Score: 6.108 195. Love Story | Score: 6.117 194. Can You Hear Me | Score: 6.136 193. Vulnerability (Interlude) | Score: 6.142 192. Can't Take That Away (Mariah's Theme) (Morales Club Mix Edit) | Score: 6.175 191. Heat | Score: 6.183 190. Twister | Score: 6.200 189. One and Only | Score: 6.206 188. Secret Love | Score: 6.208 187. There For Me | Score: 6.225 186. After Tonight | Score: 6.244 185. Silent Night | Score: 6.278 184. One Night | Score: 6.308 183. Thanx 4 Nothin' | Score: 6.319 182. You Had Your Chance | Score: 6.411 181. Camouflage |Score: 6.419 180. So Lonely (One & Only Pt. II) | Score: 6.424 179. I Wish You Well | Score: 6.442 178. Bye Bye | Score: 6.467 177. We Belong Together Remix | Score: 6.489 176. Cruise Control | Score: 6.506 175. If We | Score: 6.511 174. Just To Hold You Once Again | Score: 6.512 173. Reflections (Care Enough) | Score: 6.531 172. Inseparable | Score: 6.542 171. There Goes My Heart | Score: 6.556 170. I Only Wanted | Score: 6.558 169. Languishing (The Interlude) | Score: 6.561 168. Mesmerized | Score: 6.569 167. So Blessed | Score: 6.570 166. O Holy Night (Live) | Score: 6.578 165. I've Been Thinking About You | Score: 6.581 164. The Impossible | Score: 6.583 163. Irresistible (West Side Connection) | Score: 6.611 162. Side Effects | Score: 6.617 161. Joy to the World (Celebration Mix) | Score: 6.631 160. You're So Cold | Score: 6.636 159. Money ($*/…) | Score: 6.642 158. The Wind | Score: 6.643 157. Almost Home | Score: 6.645 156. My All (Morales "My" Club Mix) | Score: 6.658 155. Cool On You | Score: 6.659 154. Hero | Score: 6.678 153. Against All Odds (Take A Look At Me Now) | Score: 6.697 152. Get Your Number | Score: 6.711 151. One Mo' Gen | Score: 6.725 150. Jesus Oh What A Wonderful Child | Score: 6.728 149. My Saving Grace | Score: 6.729 148. Cry. | Score: 6.733 147. I Wish You Knew | Score: 6.744 146. More Than Just Friends | Score: 6.781 145. Hark! The Herald Angels Sing / Gloria (In Excelsis Deo) | Score: 6.792 144. Up Out My Face | Score: 6.795 143. Ribbon | Score: 6.806 142. Your Girl | Score: 6.817 141. Angel (The Prelude) | Score: 6.822 140. Sweetheart | Score: 6.858 139. Meteorite | Score: 6.859 138. Thirsty | Score: 6.875 137. I Want To Know What Love Is | Score: 6.878 136. Lullaby | Score: 6.892 135. Want You | Score: 6.894 134. Never Forget You | Score: 6.922 133. Now That I Know | Score: 6.931 132. I Am Free | Score: 6.953 131. O.O.C. | Score: 6.956 130. Rainbow (Interlude) | Score: 6.969 129. The Art Of Letting Go | Score: 6.978 128. To Be Around You | Score: 7.000 127. Sent From Up Above | Score: 7.008 126. Stay Long Love You | Score: 7.025 125. Out Here On My Own | Score: 7.047 124. Miss You | Score: 7.056 123. When I Feel It | Score: 7.058 122. With you | Score: 7.061 121. Through The Rain | Score: 7.072 120. When I Saw You | Score: 7.097 119. You Got Me | Score: 7.100 118. Bringin' On The Heartbreak | Score: 7.106 117. It's A Wrap | Score: 7.111 116. I Stay In Love | Score: 7.114 115. All I've Ever Wanted | Score: 7.122 114. Loverboy Remix | Score: 7.133 113. Petals | Score: 7.189 112. Joy Ride | Score: 7.206 111. Always Be My Baby ft. Da Brat, Xscape | Score: 7.208 110. You're Mine (Eternal) | Score: 7.228 109. Say Somethin' | Score: 7.278 108. Migrate | Score: 7.283 107. Christmas Time Is In The Air Again | Score: 7.286 106. Betcha Gon' Know (The Prologue) | Score: 7.289 105. Last Night A DJ Saved My Life | Score: 7.290 104. Endless Love | Score: 7.292 103. Joy To The World | Score: 7.294 102. All I Live For | Score: 7.319 101. Sprung | Score: 7.321 Top 100-41 100. Yours | Score: 7.322 99. Looking In | Score: 7.331 98. I'll Be There | Score: 7.333 97. Can't Take That Away (Mariah's Theme) | Score: 7.347 96. Whenever You Call | Score: 7.378 95. Make It Happen | Score: 7.381 94. Here We Go Around Again | Score: 7.386 93. Make It Look Good | Score: 7.394 92. Open Arms | Score: 7.406 91. Long Ago | Score: 7.411 90. One Sweet Day | Score: 7.419 89. Vanishing | Score: 7.425 88. All In Your Mind | Score: 7.456 87. Anytime You Need a Friend (C&C Club Mix) | Score: 7.464 86. A No No | Score: 7.492 85. When Christmas Comes | Score: 7.494 84. You Don't Know What To Do | Score: 7.495 83. And You Don't Remember | Score: 7.517 82. Clown | Score: 7.556 81. Oh Santa! |Score: 7.567 80. Alone In Love | Score: 7.569 79. Mine Again | Score: 7.575 78. Boy (I Need You) | Score: 7.583 77. Fly Away (Butterfly Reprise) | Score: 7.600 76. I Know What You Want | Score: 7.602 75. Loverboy Cameo | Score: 7.633 74. Subtle Invitation | Score: 7.642 73. Close My Eyes | Score: 7.650 72. Till The End Of Time | Score: 7.656 71. The One | Score: 7.681 70. Thank God I Found You/Make It Last | Score: 7.686 69. Prisoner | Score: 7.692 68. Dedicated | Score: 7.708 67. Fantasy (Sweet Dub Mix) | Score: 7.719 66. Outside | Score: 7.761 65. I Don't Wanna Cry | Score: 7.769 64. My All/Stay Awhile | Score: 7.786 63. Didn't Mean To Turn You On | Score: 5.800 62. Heartbreaker Remix | Score: 7.806 61. All My Life | Score: 7.811 60. Music Box | Score: 7.822 59. For The Record | Score: 7.828 58. Faded | Score: 7.836 57. Never Too Far | Score: 7.869 56. I'll Be Lovin' U Long Time | Score: 7.883 55. Without You | Score: 7.903 54. Someday | Score: 7.931 53. Stay The Night | Score: 7.947 52. When You Believe | Score: 7.961 51. Daydream Interlude | Score: 5.989 50. Love Takes Time | Score: 7.989 49. H.A.T.E.U. | Score: 7.992 48. O Holy Night | Score: 7.997 47. Fly Like A Bird | Score: 8.022 46. Fantasy Remix | Score: 8.028 45. Don't Forget About Us | Score: 8.033 44. Circles | Score: 8.050 43. Forever | Score: 8.053 42. Bliss | Score: 8.117 41. If It's Over | Score: 8.164 Edited December 27, 2022 by Saddy
Pristine Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 this give me an excuse to listen ha entire catalog. remind me sis I will submits even just to bump butterfly songs
Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Author Posted November 2, 2022 2 minutes ago, Pristine said: this give me an excuse to listen ha entire catalog. remind me sis I will submits even just to bump butterfly songs Sure
Solaria Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 Melt Away coming for No.1. The other girls need to give it up already
suburbannature Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 Yesssssss we are guaranteed pretty graphics with Saddy leading
suburbannature Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 One suggestion - we need remix and misc/unreleased sections.
Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Author Posted November 2, 2022 Just now, suburbannature said: Yesssssss we are guaranteed pretty graphics with Saddy leading
Guest Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 23 minutes ago, Saddy said: Hello and welcome to Mariah Carey's Discography Rate! This year @suburbannature decided to give me the opportunity to host this rate, so thank you King I decided that this year we gonna rate only her studio albums and 1 compilation album (The Rarities (only 1st CD)). So yeah... I hope at least 10 people will participate Rules Rate each song from 1 to 10. Decimals are allowed but only to 1 decimal place (7.8 is fine, but 7.82 is not). You can give ONE song 11 and 0, but only once in each album (for example, if you gave X songs 11 and 0 from the album "Mariah Carey", you can’t rate any of her other songs with 11 and 0 from this album). Rate only songs that are on the list. Comments are optional. Send your ballot to me via DM. DUE DATE: December 10th Song List Reveal hidden contents Mariah Carey (1990) Vision of love There's Got to be a way I don't wanna cry Someday Vanishing All in your mind Alone in Love You need me Sent from up Above Prisoner Love takes time Emotions (1991) Emotions And you don't remember Can't let go Make it happen If it's over You're so cold So blessed To be around you Till the end of time The wind Music Box (1993) Dreamlover Hero Anytime you need a friend Music box Now that I know Never forget you Without you Just to hold you once again I've been thinking about you All I've ever wanted Merry Christmas (1994) Silent night All I want for Christmas is You O Holy Night Christmas (Baby please come home) Miss you most (at Christmas time) Joy to the world Jesus born on this day Santa Claus is comin' to town Hark! The Herald Angels Sing / Gloria (in excelsis Deo) Jesus oh what a wonderful child Daydream (1995) Fantasy Underneath the stars One sweet day Open arms Always be my baby I Am free When I saw you Long ago Melt away Forever Daydream interlude Looking in Butterfly (1997) Honey Butterfly My all The Roof (back in time) Fourth of July Breakdown Babydoll Close my eyes Whenever you call Fly away (butterfly reprise) The beautiful ones Outside Whenever You Call ft. Brian McKnight The Roof (When I Feel the Need) ft. Brandy Rainbow (1999) Heartbreaker Can't take that away (Mariah's theme) Bliss How much After tonight X-Girlfriend Heartbreaker da brat & missy eliot Vulnerability (interlude) Against all odds (take a look at me now) Crybaby Did I do that? Petals Rainbow (interlude) Thank God I found you Glitter (2001) Loverboy remix Lead the way If we Didn't mean to turn you on Don't stop (funkin' 4 jamaica) All my life Reflections (care enough) Last night a DJ saved my life Want you Never too far Twister Loverboy cameo Charmbracelet (2002) Through the rain Boy (I need you) The one Yours You got me I only wanted Clown My saving Grace You had Your chance Lullaby Irresistible (West side connection) Subtle Invitation Bringin' on the heartbreak Sunflowers for Alfred Roy Through the rain remix The Emancipation of Mimi (2005) It's like that We belong together Shake it off Mine Again Say Somethin' Stay the night Get your number One and only Circles Your girl I wish you knew To the floor Joy ride Fly like a bird Don't Forget about us Makin' it last all night (what it do) So lonely (one & Only Pt.II) We belong together remix Secret Love Sprung E=MC2 (2008) Migrate Touch my body Cruise Control I stay in love Side effects I'm that Chick Love story I'll be lovin' U long time last Kiss Thanx 4 nothin' O.O.C. For the record Bye bye I wish you well Heat 4real4real Memoirs of an imperfect angel (2009) Betcha Gon' know (the prologue) Obsessed H.A.T.E.U. Candy bling Ribbon Inseparable Standing O It's a wrap Up out my face Up out my face (the reprise) More than just friends The impossible The impossible (the reprise) Angel (the prelude) Angels cry Languishing (the interlude) I want to know what love is Merry Christmas II You (2010) Santa Claus is coming to town intro Oh Santa! O little town of bethlehem/Little drummer boy Christmas time is in the air again The first Noel/Born is the King interlude When Christmas comes Here comes Santa Claus Charlie Brown Christmas O come all ye faithful/Hallelijah Chorus O holy night One child All I want for Christmas is you Auld land syne (NYA) Oh Santa! (Jump Smokers Edit) Me. I am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse (2014) Cry. Faded Dedicated #Beautiful Thirsty Make it look good You're mine (eternal) You don't know what to do Supernatural Meteorite Camouflage Money ($*/…) One more try Heavenly It's a wrap Betcha gon' know The art of letting go Caution (2018) GTFO With you Caution A no no The Distance Giving me life One mo' gen 8th grade stay long love you Portrait Runway The Rarities (2020) Here we go around again Can you hear me Do you think of me Everything fades away All I live for One night Slipping away Out here on my own Loverboy I pray Cool on you Mesmerized Lullaby of Birdland Save the day Close my eyes 2020 Reveal hidden contents Just a quick FYI, your picture says “ARTL” instead of “ATRL”
Guest Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 1 minute ago, suburbannature said: One suggestion - we need remix and misc/unreleased sections. That makes the rate soooo long tho
Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Author Posted November 2, 2022 Just now, suburbannature said: One suggestion - we need remix and misc/unreleased sections. I actually wanted and still want to add it but I'm afraid people will give up cuz it's going to be over 200 songs
Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Author Posted November 2, 2022 1 minute ago, Limitless said: Just a quick FYI, your picture says “ARTL” instead of “ATRL” OMG thanks for letting me know
Guest Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 1 minute ago, Saddy said: OMG thanks for letting me know For sure! P.S. I’d love to participate! I’m a lamb ?
Both Sides Now Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 I’ll be participating. Getting my MULTIPLE 10s ready for Charmbible and Moomoirs
Guest Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 3 minutes ago, James_Dean said: Irresistible coming for #1, I fear TASTE!
Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Author Posted November 2, 2022 5 minutes ago, Limitless said: I WILL have my rate done by TONIGHT! omg no way
suburbannature Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 18 minutes ago, Limitless said: That makes the rate soooo long tho 17 minutes ago, Saddy said: I actually wanted and still want to add it but I'm afraid people will give up cuz it's going to be over 200 songs Maybe just the songs from The Remixes album and major unreleased like: When I Feel It There Goes My Heart There For Me Skydiving Help Me Make It Through the Night Right to Dream and features: When You Believe Endless Love I Know What You Want U Make Me Wanna etc. ?
Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Author Posted November 2, 2022 1 minute ago, suburbannature said: Maybe just the songs from The Remixes album and major unreleased like: When I Feel It There Goes My Heart There For Me Skydiving Help Me Make It Through the Night Right to Dream and features: When You Believe Endless Love I Know What You Want U Make Me Wanna etc. ? Yeah, I'll add them
Saddy Posted November 2, 2022 Author Posted November 2, 2022 6 minutes ago, suburbannature said: Maybe just the songs from The Remixes album and major unreleased like: When I Feel It There Goes My Heart There For Me Skydiving Help Me Make It Through the Night Right to Dream and features: When You Believe Endless Love I Know What You Want U Make Me Wanna etc. ? I also added these songs: Big Energy Remix Fantasy Remix I'll Be There Infinity Somewhat Loved Fall In Love at Christmas I Don't I Still Believe
suburbannature Posted November 2, 2022 Posted November 2, 2022 54 minutes ago, Saddy said: This year @suburbannature decided to give me the opportunity to host this rate, so thank you King Help. You didn't need my permission, legend.
Recommended Posts